Marketing reputation

Replying to negative reviews without breaching confidentiality

Reply templates for GP, dental and clinic reviews that never confirm someone is a patient, plus a decision guide, timescales and when to report a review.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why the obvious reply is the dangerous one
  2. Keep it in proportion
  3. Decide what kind of review it is
  4. Five rules for every reply
  5. Reply templates
  6. When the reviewer gets in touch
  7. Write a one-page review response policy
  8. Look after the staff involved
  9. Things that make it worse
  10. Example: a review about a refused prescription
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • The safest reply never confirms or denies that the reviewer is a patient and never mentions an appointment, treatment or record, even if the reviewer has shared those details themselves.
  • GDC standards say dental professionals must not post information or comments about patients on social networking or blogging sites; review replies fall into the same territory.
  • Every reply should move the conversation to a private route and point to the complaints procedure; NHS complaints must be acknowledged within 3 working days.
  • Report reviews that break platform rules rather than arguing with them, and keep a log of what you replied and why.

Why the obvious reply is the dangerous one

A negative review stings, and the natural reaction is to set the record straight: we have checked your notes and you were offered an appointment on Tuesday. That single sentence confirms the person is a patient, discloses that you looked at their record and reveals something about their care. Health information is special category data under UK GDPR, and processing it is prohibited unless a specific condition applies[1]. Posting it in a public reply is not one of them.

Professional duties point the same way. GDC standards say dental professionals must protect the confidentiality of patients' information, use it only for the purpose for which it was given and must not post any information or comments about patients on social networking or blogging sites[2]. Health and care organisations also work to the eight Caldicott Principles for protecting confidential information[3]. Doctors, nurses and other registrants should check their own regulator's guidance, which sets similar expectations. The reviewer choosing to share details publicly does not give the practice permission to add to them.

Keep it in proportion

Most patients are satisfied with their care. Among adults with a recent dental appointment, 89.9% of NHS patients and 93.5% of private patients were satisfied[4]. A single critical review is read in that context by other patients, who often judge the practice more on how it replies than on the complaint itself. A calm, brief, consistent reply reassures readers; a defensive one makes the original review more believable.

Adults satisfied with dental care after a recent appointment
Adults satisfied with dental care after a recent appointmentComparison. NHS appointment: 89.9%; Private appointment: 93.5%.89.9%NHS appointmentNHS appointment: 89.9%93.5%Private appointmentPrivate appointment: 93.5%Adults satisfied with dental care after a recent appointmentComparison. NHS appointment: 89.9%; Private appointment: 93.5%.89.9%NHS appointmentNHS appointment: 89.9%93.5%Private appointmentPrivate appointment: 93.5%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
NHS appointment89.9%
Private appointment93.5%

Decide what kind of review it is

A decision guide for negative reviews
Type of reviewWhat to doReply?
Fair criticism of access, waits or communicationAcknowledge, explain any general change, invite private contactYes, within two working days
Complaint about clinical careGeneral reply, invite contact with the practice manager, start complaints process if they get in touchYes, short and general only
Complaint naming a staff memberDo not repeat the name; support the staff member; invite private contactYes, without the name
Abusive, discriminatory or threateningReport to the platform; log it; consider whether staff need supportUsually no
Appears fake or about a different businessReport it; reply only to say you cannot identify the experience described, without mentioning recordsOptional
Contains a patient's own detailed medical informationConsider asking the platform to remove it for the reviewer's protection; never repeat itYes, general only

Five rules for every reply

  1. Never confirm or deny that the reviewer is or was a patient. Write as if anyone could have posted it.
  2. Never mention dates, appointments, treatments, test results, prescriptions or anything from a record.
  3. Never name staff, even to defend them, and never name the reviewer.
  4. Always offer a private route: a named role, an email address and a phone number, and mention the complaints procedure.
  5. Keep it short: three to five sentences, signed with a role such as practice manager, not an individual's full name if staff safety is a concern.

Before posting, ask: if this reply were printed in the local paper next to the review, would it reveal anything about anyone's care? If yes, rewrite it.

Reply templates

These templates are deliberately general. Adapt the wording to your practice and keep a library so that whoever replies uses the approved versions.

Access or waiting: Thank you for taking the time to share this. We know how frustrating it is when it is hard to get through or to get an appointment when you need one. We are always reviewing how we handle demand. If you would like to talk this through, please contact our practice manager on [phone] or [email].

Clinical concern: Thank you for your feedback. We cannot discuss anyone's care in a public forum, but we take concerns like this seriously. Please contact our practice manager on [phone] or [email] so we can look into it properly through our complaints procedure.

Staff attitude: We are sorry to read this. We expect everyone who contacts us to be treated with courtesy and respect. Please get in touch with our practice manager on [phone] or [email] so we can understand what happened.

Experience you cannot identify: Thank you for your review. We have not been able to match the experience described to our service. If you believe this relates to us, please contact our practice manager on [email] so we can look into it.

When the reviewer gets in touch

The aim of the public reply is to move the conversation into your complaints process, where you can discuss details properly. For NHS services in England, a complaint may be made orally, in writing or electronically, and the responsible body must acknowledge it not later than 3 working days after receiving it[5]. A complaint generally has to be made within 12 months of the event or of the person becoming aware of it, although that limit can be waived where there was good reason for the delay and the complaint can still be investigated fairly[5].

Dental teams should also follow the GDC standards on complaints: give the patient a copy of the complaints procedure when acknowledging, respond within the timescales in the procedure, update the patient at least every 10 days if more time is needed and respond in writing[6]. Private clinics should follow their own published procedure with similar discipline.

Write a one-page review response policy

Replies go wrong most often when nobody knows who is allowed to post them. A one-page policy, agreed by the partners or directors, removes the guesswork.

  1. Name who replies

    One owner, usually the practice manager, and one deputy. Nobody else replies on the practice's behalf, including clinicians replying from personal accounts.

  2. Set a response time

    For example, reply to negative reviews within two working days and check the profiles every working day. Speed matters less than getting the wording right.

  3. Approve the templates

    Keep the approved templates in the policy and require a second reader for anything that departs from them.

  4. Define what gets reported

    Abusive, discriminatory, threatening, fake or off-topic reviews are reported to the platform, with a screenshot saved to the log.

  5. Link to complaints

    Every reply that invites contact routes into the complaints procedure, so a review that becomes a complaint is handled to the same standard as any other.

  6. Review quarterly

    Look at the log every quarter: themes in negative reviews, replies that drew follow-up, and anything that should change in how the practice works.

Look after the staff involved

Reviews that criticise a named receptionist or clinician can be upsetting, particularly when the person cannot answer back. Tell the staff member before they find it themselves, listen to their account privately and make clear that the practice will not argue the case in public. If the review contains threats or discriminatory language, report it to the platform, record it as an incident and consider whether the police or your defence organisation should be told. Treat any learning from the review separately from support for the person, so that support does not feel conditional on accepting blame.

Things that make it worse

  • Replying within minutes while angry. Wait, draft, and have a second person read it.
  • Asking the reviewer to remove the review in return for resolving the complaint. The CMA treats making dispute resolution conditional on a consumer not leaving a negative review as suppression[7].
  • Threatening legal action in a public reply.
  • Posting the same template under every review, including positive ones, so replies look automated.
  • Encouraging staff or friends to post positive reviews to bury the negative one.

Example: a review about a refused prescription

Example. A one-star review on a fictional surgery's Google profile says the reviewer was refused a repeat prescription and that a named GP was rude. A receptionist drafts a reply explaining the practice's medication review policy and that the patient was overdue a review. The practice manager stops it, because it confirms the reviewer is a patient and reveals details of their care. The posted reply uses the clinical concern template without the GP's name. The reviewer emails the next day, the practice logs a complaint, acknowledges it within 3 working days and resolves it in writing. The GP receives support, and the review stays up with a reply that any reader can see is professional.

Frequently asked questions

Can we correct a review that is factually wrong about a patient's care?

Not publicly. Correcting it confirms the person is a patient and discloses information about their care. Reply in general terms and invite them to contact the practice privately.

Should we reply to every negative review?

Reply to most fair criticism with a short, general response. Report abusive, discriminatory or fake reviews to the platform instead of engaging.

Who should write the replies?

A trained practice manager or deputy using approved templates, with a second person checking any reply that is not a straight template.

What if the reviewer names a member of staff?

Do not repeat the name in your reply. Support the staff member privately and handle any concern through your complaints or HR process.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. General Dental Council (2013). Standards for the Dental Team: Principle 4, maintain and protect patients' information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2026). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2009). The Local Authority Social Services and National Health Service Complaints (England) Regulations 2009 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. General Dental Council (2013). Standards for the Dental Team: Principle 5, have a clear and effective complaints procedure (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews: guidance on the banned practice (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo