Key takeaways
- For most practices Google matters most because it is where search starts; the NHS website matters for NHS and mixed services; specialist healthcare platforms matter most for private consultants and clinics competing on named clinicians.
- Judge each platform on four tests: where your patients actually look, how reviews are verified, what control you have over replies and profile details, and the full cost including staff time.
- Running two platforms well beats running five badly; every extra profile needs accurate details, replies and monitoring.
- Whatever the platform, the same rules apply: ask fairly, never incentivise, never confirm someone is a patient in a reply.
Start with where patients look
Patients do not consult every review site. They see whatever appears when they search, plus the places the NHS sends them. When ONS asked people without a dentist how they chose a practice to contact for urgent NHS care, 30.9% used an online search and 25.5% the NHS website, while 3.5% were recommended a practice[1]. For private care, patients more often search for a named consultant or treatment, and specialist healthcare review platforms frequently appear in those results.
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Online search | 30.9% |
| NHS website | 25.5% |
| Another method | 28.7% |
| Recommendation | 3.5% |
Ratings are also moving into NHS choice tools. The government's 10 Year Health Plan says patients will be able to choose providers on the NHS App using quality data including waiting times, patient ratings and clinical outcomes[2]. NHS-funded services should expect patient feedback to become more visible at the point of choice, not less.
What patients read in a review
Before choosing platforms, it helps to know what readers take from reviews. Patients rarely read more than a handful. They look at the overall rating and the number of reviews, the dates of the most recent ones, whether the comments mention things that matter to them, such as how easy it was to book, how well a clinician explained options and how anxious patients were treated, and how the practice replied to criticism.
That has two practical consequences. First, a profile with few or old reviews carries little weight, however high the score, so a platform is only worth running if you will ask patients consistently. Second, replies are read as closely as reviews. A platform that does not let you reply, or makes replying awkward, removes one of the strongest trust signals you have.
The main platform types compared
| Platform type | Who sees it | Your control | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google reviews | Almost everyone who searches for you by name, treatment or near me | Reply, report policy breaches, manage profile details | Every practice and clinic with a physical location |
| NHS website feedback | Patients choosing NHS services through the NHS website | Profile details through Profile Manager; moderation set by the NHS | GP surgeries and NHS or mixed dental practices |
| Specialist healthcare review platforms, such as Doctify or iWantGreatCare | Patients researching named clinicians and private services | Varies by platform and plan; usually profile editing and replies | Private consultants, clinics and hospitals competing on named clinicians |
| General review sites, such as Trustpilot | Consumers checking a brand, often online services | Reply and invitation tools; terms vary | Online-first services and larger clinic groups |
| Social media recommendations | Local community groups and followers | Limited; comments on your own page only | Community reputation and word of mouth |
Treat the table as a starting point. Platform features, reach and commercial terms change, so check the current position directly with each provider before committing.
Four tests for any platform
Reach: do your patients see it?
Search for your practice, your main treatments and your clinicians on a phone that is not signed in. Note which platforms appear on the first screen. A platform that never appears in your patients' searches is unlikely to influence them.
Verification: are reviews from real patients?
Ask how the platform checks that reviewers had a real experience, how it handles suspected fake reviews and whether it labels incentivised ones. Businesses that publish consumer reviews must take steps to prevent fake reviews and reviews with hidden incentives from being published[3], so a platform's approach to this is a quality signal.
Control: what can you manage?
Check whether you can correct profile details, reply to reviews, report breaches and see who on your team has access. On Google, a practitioner profile carries only the practitioner's name, and the organisation should have its own profile for a shared location[4].
Cost: what is the full price?
Ask for the current commercial terms in writing, including any charges for profiles, review invitations or analytics, the contract length and the notice period. Add the staff time needed to keep the profile accurate and reply to reviews.
The NHS website: what you can and cannot control
For NHS services, the NHS website's own feedback facility sits beside your service profile. Its terms describe a patient feedback facility for reviewing or commenting on individual NHS services, ask commenters not to name individuals or include information that could identify someone, and say comments should not be used to make formal complaints about individual GP practices[5]. Readers can report offensive comments to the moderator[5].
You control your profile details through the NHS Profile Manager, not the reviews themselves. Keep the profile accurate, follow the same confidentiality rules in any reply you post, and direct concerns to your complaints procedure.
Example: a clinic scores its options
Example. A fictional private dermatology clinic with four consultants is deciding where to focus. The practice manager scores each platform from one to five on reach, verification, control and cost, weighting reach double because patients mostly arrive by searching for consultants by name.
| Platform | Reach (x2) | Verification | Control | Cost | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 22 | |
| Specialist healthcare platform A | 8 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 19 |
| General review site | 2 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 11 |
| Facebook recommendations | 4 | 1 | 2 | 5 | 12 |
The clinic runs Google well and keeps one specialist platform for consultant profiles. It closes a dormant general review profile that was showing an old address. The owner reviews the decision after six months using the number of consultations where patients say they found the clinic through each platform.
Private consultants who work at several sites
Consultants often see patients at a private hospital, a clinic and their own rooms, and each may run its own profile of them. Patients searching for the consultant by name then find several listings with different addresses, phone numbers and photos. Agree with each site who owns which profile and make sure every listing gives the same registration details, the same core biography and clear booking routes for that location.
- Keep one master biography and update every listing from it.
- List on each site's profile only the services offered at that site.
- Point reviews for care at a site to that site's profile, using one consistent request rule.
- When the consultant stops working at a site, ask the site to update or remove the listing promptly.
How many platforms to run
Every live profile is a promise to keep details accurate and respond to reviews. Most single-site practices do best with two: Google plus the NHS website for NHS services, or Google plus one specialist platform for private clinics. Larger groups may add a third where they have evidence that patients use it.
- Claim profiles you do not plan to use actively, correct their details and point patients elsewhere, rather than leaving them unclaimed with old information.
- Do not split your review requests across several platforms in a way that looks like steering patients to wherever you expect better scores.
- Use one review request rule for all platforms: the same neutral group, the same wording, no incentives.
- Keep a register of every profile, its login owner and the date it was last checked.
Leaving a platform
If you decide a platform is not worth keeping, do not simply stop logging in. Correct the profile details so they cannot mislead, add a note directing patients to your preferred booking route if the platform allows it, cancel any paid plan in line with the notice period and remove staff access. Reviews already published usually remain; do not ask the platform to delete genuine negative reviews as part of leaving.
Record the decision and the date in your profile register. If the platform later reappears in patients' searches for your clinicians, you will know why you left and can judge whether the reasons still apply. A short annual review of every platform you use, and every one you have left, keeps the list deliberate rather than accidental.
Rules that apply on every platform
- Fake reviews are common enough that regulators act: government research estimates at least 10% of product reviews on third-party e-commerce platforms are likely to be fake[6]. Never post, buy or swap reviews.
- Never offer incentives for reviews, even where a platform allows disclosed incentives; patients should never feel care is linked to a rating.
- Never confirm or deny in a reply that a reviewer is a patient, and never mention treatment.
- Make sure clinicians' registration details and qualifications are identical across platforms and your website.
- When a clinician leaves, update or close every profile that lists them at your practice.
Frequently asked questions
Do we need a Doctify or iWantGreatCare profile?
Not necessarily. Check whether those platforms appear when patients search for your clinicians and treatments, compare their verification and control features, and get current terms in writing before deciding.
Which platform matters most for a GP surgery?
Usually Google and the NHS website. GP patients mostly need accurate contact details and a fair picture of the practice, which those two provide.
Should we copy reviews from one platform to another?
No. Republishing reviews out of context can mislead and may breach platform terms. Link to each platform instead.
How often should we check our profiles?
Check replies weekly and profile details monthly, and update every profile on the same day when contact details or clinicians change.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department of Health and Social Care) (2025). Fit for the future: 10 Year Health Plan for England (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews: guidance on the banned practice (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Guidelines for representing your business on Google (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS website (nhs.uk) (2021). NHS website terms and conditions (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department for Business and Trade) (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑