Marketing reputation

Fake reviews and review incentives: what the law says

The DMCC Act rules on fake and incentivised reviews for practices and clinics: what is banned, publisher duties, CMA penalties and a compliance checklist.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What changed and why it matters to practices
  2. The three things that are banned
  3. Common practice habits, checked against the rules
  4. Incentives: the narrow lawful route
  5. If you publish reviews, you have duties too
  6. Healthcare-specific risks
  7. Questions to ask any agency or software supplier
  8. Penalties and enforcement
  9. A compliance checklist
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Since April 2025, fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews have been a banned practice under the DMCC Act: automatically unfair and illegal, with no need to prove harm.
  • Practices that publish reviews or testimonials on their own websites are publishers and must take steps to prevent fake and hidden-incentive reviews appearing.
  • Incentives are lawful under the Act only when disclosed and when the review still reflects a genuine experience; Google bans them outright.
  • The CMA can now impose penalties of up to £300,000 or, if higher, 10% of turnover for consumer law infringements, without going to court first.

What changed and why it matters to practices

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 created a new banned practice covering fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and publishing consumer reviews in a misleading way. The CMA describes it as behaviour that is automatically unfair and illegal[1]. Its guidance came into effect alongside the consumer provisions in April 2025.

Dental practices, private clinics and other healthcare businesses that sell to the public are traders for these purposes. So are the agencies and freelancers they hire. The scale of the problem explains the regulator's interest: government research estimated that at least 10% of product reviews on third-party e-commerce platforms used by UK consumers are likely to be fake[2], and that consumers were 3.1% more likely to buy a product with well-written fake reviews[2].

Minimum share of product reviews on third-party e-commerce platforms likely to be fakeGovernment estimate for platforms used by UK consumers
Minimum share of product reviews on third-party e-commerce platforms likely to be fakeDonut chart. Likely fake (at least): 10%.Likely fake (at least): 10%10%
  • Likely fake (at least) 10%

Source: GOV.UK (Department for Business and Trade), 2023[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Likely fake (at least)10%

The three things that are banned

  1. Fake reviews

    Reviews that purport to be based on a genuine experience but are not. That covers reviews written by the owner, staff, family, friends or an agency, reviews swapped with another business, and positive or negative reviews about competitors. A fake review can be positive or negative[1].

  2. Concealed incentivised reviews

    Reviews where the reviewer was paid or rewarded, directly or in kind, and that fact is hidden from readers. Incentives include money, discounts, free products or services and prize draws.

  3. Publishing reviews in a misleading way

    Suppressing genuine negative reviews, cherry-picking positive ones, or omitting information about how reviews were collected. The CMA lists examples such as threats of legal action against reviewers, arbitrarily stopping and starting review invitations, and making dispute resolution conditional on not leaving a negative review[1].

Commissioning or facilitating any of these is also caught. A practice that pays an agency which then posts fake reviews cannot rely on not knowing the details; the guidance expects traders who commission reviews to make clear that incentivised reviews must be disclosed and to check what is being done on their behalf[1].

Common practice habits, checked against the rules

How common review habits sit under the DMCC Act banned practice
HabitPositionDo this instead
Staff leave reviews of the practiceFake review; bannedAsk staff to share the review link with patients, not to post
Prize draw for patients who leave a reviewIncentivised; banned if not disclosed, and prohibited on Google regardlessAsk without any incentive
Asking only patients who seemed happyCan mislead by cherry-pickingAsk every patient in a neutral group
Pausing requests after a difficult weekArbitrary stopping and starting can suppress negativesKeep the trigger running consistently
Refund offered if the review is removedConditional dispute resolution; misleadingResolve the complaint on its merits
Testimonials on your website chosen from five-star reviews onlySelective publication can misleadShow a representative feed or say how testimonials were chosen
Agency promises 50 reviews a monthHigh risk of fake or incentivised reviewsDo not hire them; ask agencies how reviews are generated

Incentives: the narrow lawful route

The Act does not ban incentives outright. The CMA says traders may incentivise customers to leave a review, for example by paying them, offering future discounts or free products, provided they tell consumers the review has been incentivised and the review still reflects the reviewer's genuine experience[1]. Where a platform allows incentivised reviews, the review must be clearly identifiable as incentivised, usually by labelling it prominently[1].

In practice this route is closed for most practices. Google's policy prohibits offering incentives, such as payment, discounts or free goods or services, in exchange for any review[3]. Healthcare professionals also have professional duties not to let financial arrangements compromise patient trust. The simplest compliant position is no incentives of any kind for reviews on any platform.

Watch internal incentives too. Paying reception staff a bonus per review collected, or ranking clinicians by star rating, creates pressure to ask only the patients who look pleased, or to hover while they type. If you reward the team, reward the process: requests sent consistently to everyone in the agreed group, and complaints handled well. That keeps the incentive pointing at good care rather than at the rating.

If you publish reviews, you have duties too

Many practices show reviews or testimonials on their own website, in a widget, on a reviews page or quoted on service pages. That makes them a publisher of consumer reviews. Businesses that publish consumer reviews must take steps to prevent fake reviews and reviews with hidden incentives from being published[1]. Where incentivised reviews are published, they must be distinguished from other reviews[1].

  1. Write a short public statement on how reviews are collected, verified and displayed.
  2. If you hand-pick testimonials, say so, and make sure they represent typical experiences rather than only the best.
  3. Only display reviews from patients you can reasonably confirm attended, without displaying anything that identifies them unless they consented.
  4. Remove reviews you find to be fake or incentivised, and keep a record of the decision.
  5. If you use a widget that pulls reviews from a platform, check whether it filters out low ratings by default and switch that off.

Healthcare-specific risks

Healthcare adds layers that general retail guidance does not cover. A review or testimonial can reveal that a named person had a particular treatment, so publishing one on your own site needs that person's clear agreement, and replying to one must never add clinical detail. Testimonials that describe results are also claims about treatment: if a quoted patient says a treatment cured their condition, the practice has published that claim and must be able to support it.

  • Before using any review as a testimonial on your website or in an advert, get written consent for that specific use and keep it.
  • Check that quoted reviews do not describe outcomes most patients would not achieve, or treatments the advertising rules prevent you promoting.
  • Never edit a review's wording to make it more positive and then present it as the patient's own words.
  • Remove a testimonial promptly if the patient withdraws consent.
  • Treat negative reviews that contain the patient's own health details with care: you may ask the platform to remove them for the reviewer's protection, but never because they are critical.

Questions to ask any agency or software supplier

Review generation is a common add-on in dental and clinic marketing packages. Before you sign, ask in writing:

  1. How exactly do you generate reviews, and who sends the requests?
  2. Do your tools filter or route patients differently depending on their likely rating?
  3. Do you offer, or have you ever offered, incentives to reviewers on behalf of clients?
  4. Will you confirm in the contract that you comply with the DMCC Act and platform policies, and that you will not post reviews yourselves?
  5. What happens to our review data and patient contact details when the contract ends?

An agency that cannot answer these clearly is a risk the practice carries, because commissioning banned reviews is caught as well as posting them.

Penalties and enforcement

The DMCC Act gave the CMA direct enforcement powers for consumer law. In a final infringement notice it can impose a monetary penalty of up to £300,000 or, if higher, 10% of the total value of the trader's turnover[4]. It no longer needs to go to court first. Trading standards services can also take action, and consumers may have rights to redress.

For regulated professionals, the professional consequences may matter more than the fine. The GDC states that misleading advertising is unprofessional, may lead to a fitness to practise investigation and can be a criminal offence[5], and published testimonials are a form of advertising. Platforms add their own sanctions, from removing reviews to warning labels on the listing.

A compliance checklist

  • A written review policy that bans staff, family and agency reviews and all incentives.
  • A neutral rule for who is asked for a review, with written clinical exclusions only.
  • A contract clause requiring any marketing agency to comply with the DMCC Act and to disclose how reviews are generated.
  • A public statement on how reviews on your own website are chosen and checked.
  • A log of reviews reported to platforms and reviews removed from your own site, with reasons.
  • Training for reception and marketing staff, refreshed yearly.

Example. A fictional clinic discovers its previous agency posted dozens of five-star reviews from accounts with no other activity. The owner reports them to the platform, ends the contract, records what happened and writes to the platform asking for the suspicious reviews to be reviewed. The rating falls, but the clinic is no longer exposed to a banned practice it was paying for.

Frequently asked questions

Can our staff review the practice if they were also patients?

Avoid it. A review from someone with a conflict of interest can mislead readers, and Google's policies treat conflicts such as current or former employment as a problem. Ask staff to share the link with patients instead.

Is a prize draw for reviewers legal?

Under the DMCC Act an incentive must be disclosed and the review must be genuine. Google bans incentives outright, so a prize draw for Google reviews breaks platform rules whatever you disclose.

We only show five-star testimonials on our site. Is that a problem?

It can be. Selective publication that does not reflect reviewers' overall experience can mislead. Show a representative feed or explain how testimonials were chosen.

What can the CMA fine?

Up to £300,000 or, if higher, 10% of the trader's turnover in a final infringement notice, without first going to court.

References

  1. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews: guidance on the banned practice (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (Department for Business and Trade) (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Google (2026). Prohibited and restricted content (Maps user-generated content policy) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 182: Final infringement notice (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. General Dental Council (2026). Guidance on advertising (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo