Patient experience

Complaints in private clinics: ISCAS and good practice

How the three-stage ISCAS process works for private clinics, what adjudicators most often uphold and how to build stage 1 and 2 handling that holds up.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why private complaints need their own route
  2. The three stages and their timescales
  3. What your published procedure should say
  4. What adjudicators actually find
  5. Building a stage 1 that resolves most complaints
  6. Making stage 2 genuinely independent
  7. Managing expectations about outcomes
  8. Example: a consultant delay complaint
  9. Metrics worth tracking
  10. Records that protect everyone
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • ISCAS runs three stages: the clinic responds, a senior person not previously involved reviews, then an independent adjudicator decides[1].
  • Stage 2 reviewers are expected to send a full written response within 20 working days[1].
  • Complaints handling was the largest head of complaint at adjudication in 2023/24, at 29%[2].
  • 63% of complaint heads were upheld or partly upheld by adjudicators, and goodwill payments were made in around 68% of completed cases[2].
  • Self-pay demand is growing, so more patients will expect a clear private complaints route[3].

Why private complaints need their own route

Patients who pay for their own care are outside the NHS complaints regulations and the Ombudsman's NHS remit. CQC registers and inspects private clinics but does not resolve individual complaints. That leaves the clinic's own procedure as the main route, backed for subscribing providers by the Independent Sector Complaints Adjudication Service (ISCAS).

The volume is rising. UK self-pay private admissions grew 7.7% year on year in Q1 2026 to their highest ever level[3]. More self-pay patients means more people for whom the clinic's complaint handling is the only process they will ever see, and 86% of self-pay patients currently say their care was value for money[4]. A poorly handled complaint is one of the fastest ways to lose that view.

The three stages and their timescales

The ISCAS complaints process as published for patients
StageWho handles itEscalation windowExpected timescale
Stage 1: local resolutionThe clinic, starting with frontline staff and moving to a managerNormally within six months of the eventSet by the clinic's procedure under the ISCAS Code
Stage 2: internal reviewA senior person not previously involved, often at head officeWithin six months of the stage 1 final responseFull written response within 20 working days; aim to finish most reviews within 3 months
Stage 3: independent adjudicationAn ISCAS independent adjudicator (subscribers only)Within six months of the stage 2 final responseISCAS acknowledges within 3 working days; adjudication aims to finish within 3 to 6 months

The timescales above are those ISCAS publishes for patients[1]. The adjudicator's decision is final, with no appeal. If a clinic does not subscribe, patients cannot use stage 3, so they may turn to a regulator, a trade body, a payment provider or the courts. Saying clearly in your procedure whether you subscribe avoids false expectations.

What your published procedure should say

Patients should be able to find and understand your procedure before they need it. Keep it to one or two pages and write it for someone who is upset and short of time.

  • How to raise a complaint, with a named role, email address, phone number and postal address.
  • What happens at each stage and roughly how long each takes.
  • Who carries out the stage 2 review and how they are independent of stage 1.
  • Whether you subscribe to ISCAS, and if so how and when to ask for adjudication.
  • How to complain on someone else's behalf and the consent you will need.
  • How you will communicate if the patient prefers large print, email, an interpreter or another format.
  • That raising a complaint will not affect the patient's care.

Put the same text on your website, in welcome information and in a leaflet at reception. Train reception to say it in plain words, because the first person a patient tells is rarely the complaints lead.

What adjudicators actually find

ISCAS adjudicators issued final decisions for 112 complainants in 2023/24 and identified 343 separate heads of complaint within them[2]. The single biggest category was not clinical care. It was complaints handling.

Largest heads of complaint at ISCAS adjudication, 2023/24Share of 343 heads of complaint across 112 adjudicated complaints
Largest heads of complaint at ISCAS adjudication, 2023/24Bar chart. Complaints handling: 29%; Consultant or medical care: 27%; Accommodation: 12%; Clinical: non-medical and nursing: 10%; Discharge: 7%.Complaints handlingComplaints handling: 29%29%Consultant or medical careConsultant or medical care: 27%27%AccommodationAccommodation: 12%12%Clinical: non-medical and nursingClinical: non-medical and nursing: 10%10%DischargeDischarge: 7%7%Largest heads of complaint at ISCAS adjudication, 2023/24Bar chart. Complaints handling: 29%; Consultant or medical care: 27%; Accommodation: 12%; Clinical: non-medical and nursing: 10%; Discharge: 7%.Complaints handlingComplaints handling: 29%29%Consultant or medical careConsultant or medical care: 27%27%AccommodationAccommodation: 12%12%Clinical: non-medical and nursingClinical: non-medical and nursing: 10%10%DischargeDischarge: 7%7%

Source: Independent Sector Complaints Adjudication Service (ISCAS), 2024[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Complaints handling29%
Consultant or medical care27%
Accommodation12%
Clinical: non-medical and nursing10%
Discharge7%

Adjudicators upheld or partly upheld 63% of complaint heads, down from 71% the year before[2]. Goodwill payments were awarded in around 68% of completed cases, with an average award of £815[2]. The lesson for a clinic is that a slow, incomplete or defensive response can turn a defensible clinical complaint into one that is partly upheld on handling alone.

Building a stage 1 that resolves most complaints

  1. Make it easy to raise

    Publish the procedure on your website, in the waiting area and in treatment paperwork. Accept complaints by phone, email, letter and in person.

  2. Acknowledge fast

    Acknowledge within a few working days, name the person handling it and give a date for the response. Keep to it or explain why not.

  3. Let staff fix small things

    A receptionist who can rebook, refund a parking charge or arrange a call from the consultant the same day prevents many formal complaints.

  4. Investigate the questions asked

    Get the consultant's or clinician's account, the booking and billing history and any messages. Answer each point the patient raised.

  5. Respond in plain words

    Explain what happened, what you concluded and what changes. State that this is the stage 1 response and explain how to ask for a stage 2 review.

Making stage 2 genuinely independent

A stage 2 review by someone who signed off the stage 1 letter is not a review. Small clinics without a head office can ask a director who was not involved, a medical director from a partner clinic or an external complaints reviewer. The reviewer should read the whole file fresh, speak to the patient if useful, and write a response that either confirms the stage 1 outcome with reasons or changes it.

  • Record who the reviewer is and why they are independent of stage 1.
  • Check that every point from the original complaint has been answered.
  • Look specifically at how the complaint was handled, since that is the most common issue at adjudication[2].
  • Consider whether a goodwill gesture is appropriate, and explain what it is for.
  • Set out stage 3 clearly if you subscribe to ISCAS.

Managing expectations about outcomes

ISCAS reports that some complainants arrive at adjudication expecting a refund, revision surgery or financial compensation, outcomes that adjudication is not designed to deliver, and that these patients are signposted to more appropriate routes[2]. Clinics can prevent much of that disappointment earlier. At stage 1, ask the patient what outcome they want, and be honest about which of those the procedure can provide.

Where a patient is seeking compensation for clinical negligence, say plainly that the complaints process is not the route for a legal claim, that they may wish to seek independent advice, and that you will still answer their complaint. Do not pause the complaint because a claim is mentioned unless your insurer advises you to, and if they do, tell the patient why.

Clinical points sometimes need specialist input. Adjudicators can obtain expert clinical advice where it is needed[2], so make sure your own stage 1 and 2 responses already explain clinical decisions clearly, with the reasoning a fellow clinician would accept.

Example: a consultant delay complaint

Example (fictional): a patient at a private orthopaedic clinic complains that her follow-up was cancelled twice and that nobody returned her calls. Stage 1 apologises for the cancellations but does not mention the calls. She asks for stage 2. The reviewer finds the calls went to an unmonitored voicemail box during a staff change, upholds both points, offers a goodwill gesture and sets a rule that every voicemail box has a named owner and a daily check. The patient accepts.

The clinical care was never in question. The handling was, and the stage 1 letter missed half of the complaint.

Afterwards the clinic adds two checks to its stage 1 template: a list of every point raised, ticked off against the draft letter, and a question asking the handler whether any contact from the patient went unanswered. Both take minutes and would have closed the complaint at the first stage.

Metrics worth tracking

  • Days from receipt to acknowledgement, and to stage 1 response.
  • Share of complaints resolved at stage 1 without a request for review.
  • Share of stage 2 reviews that change the stage 1 outcome. A high rate suggests stage 1 is too quick or too defensive.
  • Themes by category: clinical, communication, billing, access, facilities, handling.
  • Goodwill gestures given and what they were for.

Most people now say they would consider private care if they needed treatment; IHPN puts the figure at 71%[4]. Those patients compare clinics on how they are treated when things go wrong as much as on outcomes. See also NHS and private dental complaints for the dental route and duty of candour for incidents that caused harm.

Records that protect everyone

Keep complaint files separate from medical records, with a short note in the record only where the complaint affects care. Each file should hold the original complaint, every response, notes of calls and meetings, staff accounts and evidence of changes. Store them securely, since they contain health information, and set a retention period in your records policy.

A quarterly summary for the board or partners, with themes, timescales and actions, turns individual complaints into management information. It is also what an inspector or adjudicator will ask to see when judging whether the clinic learns from what patients tell it.

Frequently asked questions

Do all private clinics have to subscribe to ISCAS?

No. Stage 3 adjudication is only available where the provider is an ISCAS subscriber[1]. Clinics that do not subscribe should say so and explain what other options patients have.

How long does a stage 2 review take?

ISCAS says the reviewer should send a full written response within 20 working days and aims for most stage 2 reviews to finish within 3 months[1].

Can patients appeal an ISCAS adjudication?

No. ISCAS states that the adjudicator's decision is final[1].

What is a goodwill payment?

A payment offered to recognise poor experience or handling, without it being compensation for negligence. Adjudicators awarded them in around 68% of completed cases in 2023/24[2].

References

  1. Independent Sector Complaints Adjudication Service (ISCAS) (2026). Complaints process (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Independent Sector Complaints Adjudication Service (ISCAS) (2024). ISCAS annual report 2023/2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Private Healthcare Information Network (PHIN) (2026). Private healthcare market update: September 2026 United Kingdom (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Independent Healthcare Providers Network (IHPN) (2026). Support for using private healthcare now found across the political spectrum, new report shows (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo