Patient experience

Duty of candour: what GP, dental and private practices must do

When the statutory duty of candour applies to a practice, the harm thresholds, the steps in order, the records to keep and how reception handles calls.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Two duties, one culture
  2. Which harm test applies to your practice
  3. The steps, in order
  4. When you cannot reach the patient
  5. What reception needs to know
  6. Example: a missed result
  7. How CQC looks at it
  8. Building it into practice routines
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Regulation 20 requires registered providers to be open with patients and to act on every notifiable safety incident[1].
  • GP, dental and private practices are not health service bodies, so the wider harm test in regulation 20(9) applies to them[1][2].
  • Prolonged pain or psychological harm means a continuous period of at least 28 days[1].
  • Notify in person, give the facts, explain next enquiries, apologise, then follow up in writing and keep copies[1].
  • An apology under the regulation is an expression of sorrow or regret, not an admission of liability[1].

Two duties, one culture

There are two duties of candour, and practices need both in their heads. The professional duty applies to every registered clinician and asks them to be open with patients when something goes wrong. The statutory duty, in regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, applies to the registered provider, the organisation, and sets out specific steps for notifiable safety incidents[1].

The statutory duty starts with a general requirement: registered persons must act in an open and transparent way with relevant persons in relation to care and treatment[1]. The detailed steps only kick in for notifiable incidents, but the general openness requirement applies to everything, including the routine errors that never reach the threshold.

Openness matters to the relationship as well as to compliance. In the 2026 GP Patient Survey, 92.7% of patients said they had confidence and trust in the healthcare professional they saw or spoke to[3]. Trust that high is worth protecting, and it is lost far more quickly by concealment than by an honest account of a mistake.

Which harm test applies to your practice

Regulation 20 has two definitions of a notifiable safety incident. The narrower one in paragraph 20(8) is for health service bodies, which the regulations define as NHS trusts, NHS foundation trusts, special health authorities and NHS England[2]. GP practices, dental practices and independent clinics are none of these, so they use the wider test in paragraph 20(9)[1].

Under that wider test, a notifiable safety incident is any unintended or unexpected incident during a regulated activity that, in the reasonable opinion of a health care professional, appears to have resulted in death directly related to the incident, an impairment of sensory, motor or intellectual functions lasting or likely to last at least 28 days, changes to the structure of the body, prolonged pain or prolonged psychological harm, or a shortened life expectancy. It also covers incidents that need treatment by a health care professional to prevent death or an injury that would otherwise lead to one of those outcomes[1].

Key definitions from regulation 20 with fictional practice examples
TermMeaning in regulation 20Practice example
Prolonged painPain experienced, or likely to be experienced, for a continuous period of at least 28 daysA nerve injury after a dental extraction that leaves pain for weeks
Prolonged psychological harmPsychological harm lasting, or likely to last, for a continuous period of at least 28 daysSignificant distress after a delayed cancer referral
Changes to the structure of the bodyPart of the wider test for providers that are not health service bodiesWrong tooth extracted
ApologyAn expression of sorrow or regret in respect of a notifiable safety incidentWe are very sorry that this happened to you

The judgement is clinical. Agree who decides whether the threshold is met, usually the clinical lead, and record the reasoning either way.

The steps, in order

  1. Become aware and assess

    Once the practice is aware of an incident, a clinician decides whether it meets the notifiable threshold. Start the clock from awareness, not from the end of an investigation.

  2. Notify in person

    As soon as reasonably practicable, a representative of the practice tells the patient or their representative in person and offers reasonable support[1].

  3. Give a truthful account

    Share the facts known at the time, true to the best of your knowledge, without speculating about cause or blame[1].

  4. Explain further enquiries

    Say what will be looked into, who will do it and when the patient will hear more[1].

  5. Apologise

    Include a sincere apology in the conversation. The regulation defines an apology as an expression of sorrow or regret[1].

  6. Record the conversation

    Make a written record of the notification and keep it securely[1].

  7. Follow up in writing

    Send written notification with the account, the planned enquiries, an apology and, later, the results of those enquiries[1].

  8. Keep the correspondence

    Keep copies of every letter and email sent to the patient under the duty[1].

When you cannot reach the patient

If the relevant person cannot be contacted in person or declines to speak to the practice, the in-person and written steps do not apply, but you must keep a written record of your attempts to make contact[1]. In practice, that means a dated log of calls, letters and messages, the numbers and addresses used and any reply. If the patient later gets in touch, start the conversation then.

The relevant person is usually the patient. Where the patient has died, is a child or lacks capacity, it may be someone acting lawfully on their behalf. Check your records for a lasting power of attorney or a named representative, and be careful with family members who are not authorised; the guide to proxy access and speaking to relatives covers that boundary.

What reception needs to know

Reception staff are not usually the people who notify, but they are often the first to hear from a worried patient or relative. They need three things: to recognise that a call might relate to an incident, to avoid giving any account themselves, and to route it to a named lead the same day.

“Thank you for telling us. I want the right person to speak to you properly, so I'm passing this to Dr Patel, our clinical lead, now. Can I check the best number and time to reach you today?”

  • Do not say “that shouldn't have happened” or “that's not our fault”. Neither is yours to judge.
  • Do note the time, the caller, their relationship to the patient and what they said.
  • Do flag the record so that anyone answering a follow-up call knows a lead is involved.
  • Do tell the lead before the end of the shift, not by a task that might sit unread.

Reception also sees the aftermath. A patient who has been notified may ring with questions, or a relative may call angry before the meeting has happened. Staff do not need to know the details to be helpful; they need to know that a lead is involved, how to reach that lead quickly and that it is fine to say they cannot discuss it themselves.

Example: a missed result

Example (fictional): a raised blood result is filed as normal by mistake and the patient's treatment starts six weeks late. The duty doctor spots it on a later review. The clinical lead judges that the delay could cause prolonged psychological harm and treats it as notifiable. She phones the patient that afternoon to arrange a meeting, then meets him in person two days later, explains what happened as far as is known, apologises, and says the practice will review its results workflow and report back within four weeks.

The meeting is written up the same day. A letter follows within a week repeating the account and the apology and confirming the review. Four weeks later a second letter sets out the findings: a filing shortcut had been allowed for normal results and was used in error. The shortcut has been removed. Every step is on file.

How CQC looks at it

Duty of candour is one of the fundamental standards in the 2014 regulations, so it is part of how CQC judges whether a service is safe and well led. Most GP practices are rated well: 87% of those assessed under the current framework are good and 3% outstanding[4]. Inspectors typically ask how incidents are identified, who decides on the threshold, and to see records of notifications and follow-up letters.

CQC ratings of GP practices assessed under the current framework
CQC ratings of GP practices assessed under the current frameworkDonut chart. Good: 87%; Outstanding: 3%; Requires improvement: 9%; Inadequate: 1%.Good: 87%Outstanding: 3%Requires improvement: 9%Inadequate: 1%GP practices
  • Good 87%
  • Outstanding 3%
  • Requires improvement 9%
  • Inadequate 1%

Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Good87%
Outstanding3%
Requires improvement9%
Inadequate1%

A simple incident log with a candour column answers most of those questions. Record whether each incident was assessed against the threshold, the decision and its reason, the date of notification and the dates of written follow-up.

Building it into practice routines

  1. Name a candour lead and a deputy, and write their roles into your incident policy.
  2. Add a threshold question to your significant event template: is this notifiable under regulation 20?
  3. Prepare a short template letter that can be adapted quickly, with spaces for the account, the enquiries and the apology.
  4. Include candour in induction for every clinician and in reception training on incident calls.
  5. Review the log at each clinical meeting and close each entry only when the final letter has been sent.
  6. Link candour to complaints: if a complaint reveals a notifiable incident, the duty applies from that moment.

Candour and complaints often meet. A good response to a complaint about harm should be consistent with what was said under the duty; see complaints in private clinics and writing a complaint response letter.

Frequently asked questions

Does the duty of candour apply to GP practices?

Yes. Regulation 20 applies to all registered providers. Because GP practices are not health service bodies as defined in the regulations, they use the wider notifiable incident test in regulation 20(9)[1][2].

How quickly must we tell the patient?

As soon as reasonably practicable after becoming aware of a notifiable safety incident[1]. Do not wait for the full investigation to finish.

Is saying sorry an admission of liability?

The regulation defines an apology as an expression of sorrow or regret about the incident[1]. It is part of the duty. Ask your defence organisation for help with wording if a claim is likely, but do not leave the apology out.

What if the patient will not speak to us?

The in-person and written steps do not apply, but you must keep a written record of your attempts to contact them[1].

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2014). The Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, regulation 20: duty of candour (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2014). The Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, regulation 2: interpretation (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: primary and community services (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo