Dental practice

Running a mixed NHS and private dental practice

How a mixed dental practice in England offers NHS and private care fairly: treatment plans, consent, clear costs and words that avoid pressure.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why mixed practice needs its own playbook
  2. The rules that apply when you mix
  3. Where mixed practices get into difficulty
  4. A neutral way to explain both options
  5. What to write in the treatment plan
  6. Reception scripts for the questions patients ask
  7. Worked example: one patient, two routes
  8. Keep the price list and diary honest too
  9. A monthly audit for practice managers
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Around a quarter of dentists in England now work in a mixed NHS and private model, so clear rules at the chair and the desk matter[1].
  • Patients must be told which treatment is available on the NHS and which is private, with costs, before treatment starts[2].
  • A written plan that records both options and the patient's choice is your best protection and the patient's best guide[3].
  • Train reception to explain bands and private options in the same neutral words every time.

Why mixed practice needs its own playbook

In 2026, 38% of dentists in England worked fully or mainly in NHS care, 37% fully or mainly in private care and 23% in a mixed model[1]. Mixed practices sit where most patient confusion happens: the same surgery, the same dentist and sometimes the same appointment can involve both NHS and private items. Patients rarely know how bands work, and many arrive having read that NHS dentistry is hard to get. Only 22% of people were satisfied with NHS dentistry in 2025[4], so some will assume the NHS option is second best before you have said a word.

How dentists in England split their work, 2026
How dentists in England split their work, 2026Bar chart. Fully or mainly NHS: 38%; Fully or mainly private: 37%; Mixed NHS and private: 23%.Fully or mainly NHSFully or mainly NHS: 38%38%Fully or mainly privateFully or mainly private: 37%37%Mixed NHS and privateMixed NHS and private: 23%23%How dentists in England split their work, 2026Bar chart. Fully or mainly NHS: 38%; Fully or mainly private: 37%; Mixed NHS and private: 23%.Fully or mainly NHSFully or mainly NHS: 38%38%Fully or mainly privateFully or mainly private: 37%37%Mixed NHS and privateMixed NHS and private: 23%23%

Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Fully or mainly NHS38%
Fully or mainly private37%
Mixed NHS and private23%

That backdrop makes fairness a commercial issue as well as a regulatory one. A practice that explains both routes calmly earns trust; one that steers patients away from NHS care risks complaints, poor reviews and questions from the commissioner or the General Dental Council.

The rules that apply when you mix

The detail differs across England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, so check your own contract. For practices in England, these are the points patients and regulators expect you to get right:

  • Make clear which treatments can be provided on the NHS and which can only be provided privately, and give the costs[2].
  • Give a treatment plan for Band 2, Band 3 or a mix of NHS and private treatment, and include any private options the patient chooses[2].
  • Tell the patient what NHS treatment will cost before it starts. Current charges are £27.90 for Band 1, £76.60 for Band 2 and £332.10 for Band 3[5].
  • Under GDC standards, every treatment plan must say whether treatment is NHS or private and include a realistic indication of cost[3].
  • In adverts and on your website, say whether the practice is NHS, mixed or wholly private[6].

A simple test for any conversation: could the patient repeat back, in their own words, what the NHS option was, what the private option was and why they chose one? If not, the explanation was not finished.

Where mixed practices get into difficulty

Most problems are not deliberate. They come from habits that drift over time, often under diary pressure.

  • Describing the NHS option in negative terms, such as 'the basic one', while describing the private option in detail.
  • Quoting a private fee without mentioning that an NHS option exists for the same clinical need.
  • Letting reception say 'we don't do that on the NHS here' when the true answer is that the clinician will discuss options at the examination.
  • Recording the private choice but not the fact that the NHS alternative was offered.
  • Changing the plan mid-course without telling the patient, even though the dentist should inform them of any changes[2].

A neutral way to explain both options

Clinicians should use their own words, but a shared structure keeps the message consistent across associates. This sequence works for fillings, crowns, dentures and most Band 2 or Band 3 conversations.

  1. State the clinical need first

    'This tooth has a crack and needs a crown to protect it.' Keep the need separate from the options so the patient knows treatment is needed either way.

  2. Describe the NHS option properly

    Name the material, what it looks like, how long it usually lasts and the band charge. Do not shorten it to 'the NHS one'.

  3. Describe the private option the same way

    Same headings, same tone: material, appearance, expected life, fee. Explain what the extra cost actually buys.

  4. Mention doing nothing or waiting

    GDC standards expect options to include delaying treatment or doing nothing, with the risks of each[3].

  5. Give time and a written plan

    Hand over or send the plan and invite questions. Patients should have enough time to ask questions and decide[3].

What to write in the treatment plan

A mixed treatment plan should let anyone reading it see both options and the patient's decision.
Plan elementWhat good looks likeCommon gap
Clinical needOne plain sentence per tooth or itemClinical codes only
NHS optionMaterial, band and charge[5]Left blank when private chosen
Private optionMaterial, fee, guarantee termsFee with no description
Patient choiceWhich option, date, how explainedChoice implied, not recorded
ChangesDated note and revised costsUpdated verbally only

GDC standards also say you should tell patients whether treatment is guaranteed, under what circumstances and for how long[3]. Put that on the plan for private items rather than in a separate leaflet nobody reads.

Reception scripts for the questions patients ask

Reception teams field the awkward questions before and after appointments. Agree answers in a short team meeting and keep them on one page by the phone.

  • 'Am I an NHS or private patient?' — 'You can have NHS treatment here, and the dentist may also offer private options for some items. They will explain both and give you a written plan before anything starts.'
  • 'Why is the private one so much more?' — 'The dentist can go through what is different. If it helps, I can book a few minutes to talk it through or send the plan by email.'
  • 'Can I have some NHS and some private?' — 'Yes, a plan can include both. The dentist will set out which is which and the cost of each.'
  • 'Will I lose my NHS place if I say no?' — 'No. Choosing an NHS option does not affect your care here.' Only say this if it is true of your practice policy, and make sure it is.

Worked example: one patient, two routes

Example (fictional): Mr K, 54, needs a crown on a lower molar and a filling on a front tooth. The dentist offers an NHS crown under Band 3, with the charge of £332.10 explained[5], and a private ceramic crown at the practice's listed fee. For the front tooth, a tooth-coloured NHS filling is clinically appropriate and offered under the same course. Mr K chooses the private crown and the NHS filling. The plan records both options for each tooth, his choice, the guarantee on the private crown and the date. When the lab reports a delay, the practice sends a revised plan rather than telling him at the next visit.

Patients who had a recent private dental appointment reported 93.5% satisfaction, compared with 89.9% for NHS appointments[7]. The gap is small. What patients remember is whether they felt informed, so the written plan and a calm explanation do more for loyalty than the choice itself.

Keep the price list and diary honest too

Fair conversations fall apart if the systems around them point the other way. GDC standards say a simple price list must be clearly displayed in reception or the waiting area, and prices must be clear in practice literature and on your website[3]. In a mixed practice, show NHS band charges and private fees on the same page, so a patient comparing options does not need two documents.

Look at the diary as well. If NHS examination slots are booked weeks out while private consultations are available tomorrow, patients will conclude the practice prefers one route, whatever the clinicians say. Decide openly how many NHS sessions each associate holds, publish whether you are taking new NHS patients, and tell callers honestly how long the wait is. Where the NHS list is closed to new adults, say so plainly on the phone and online rather than offering a private appointment as the only answer to a vague question.

Finally, keep a short written policy that every new associate and receptionist reads in their first week. It should cover how options are explained, how choices are recorded and who to ask when a patient is unsure.

A monthly audit for practice managers

  1. Pull ten Band 2 or Band 3 plans at random and check that each shows the NHS option, any private option and the patient's choice.
  2. Listen to five recorded calls where patients asked about cost, if you record calls and your privacy notice covers it.
  3. Check the website and price list say the practice is mixed and show current NHS charges[6].
  4. Review complaints and reviews for words such as 'pushed', 'pressured' or 'not told'.
  5. Feed findings back to associates as a group, not as individual criticism, and repeat next month.

If you are thinking of changing the balance, see moving from NHS to private dentistry and how dental membership plans work.

Frequently asked questions

Can a patient have NHS and private treatment in the same course?

Yes. In England the treatment plan can cover a mix of NHS and private treatment, and any private options the patient chooses should be included in it.

Does a mixed practice have to say it is mixed?

Yes. GDC advertising guidance says practices must make clear in adverts and publicity whether they are NHS, mixed or wholly private.

What if a patient feels pushed towards private treatment?

Offer a second conversation, give the written plan with both options and make clear the NHS option remains available. Record the discussion and review the case at your next audit.

Do these rules apply in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland?

The principles of clear costs and informed choice apply everywhere through GDC standards, but NHS charges and contract rules differ in each nation, so check local guidance.

References

  1. Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: dental (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. NHS (nhs.uk) (2025). What dental services are available on the NHS? (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. General Dental Council (2013). Standards for the Dental Team, Principle 2: communicate effectively with patients (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. NHS (nhs.uk) (2026). Understanding NHS dental charges (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. General Dental Council (2026). Guidance on advertising (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo