Key takeaways
- Clawback applies when UDA delivery falls below 96% of the target; the urgent-course requirement has its own 96% threshold.
- Year-end reconciliation is completed by September, so the money question for one year is settled well into the next.
- Most clawback is visible by the autumn: a cumulative line below the 96% pace, a growing pile of open courses and rising rejected claims.
- Recovery works best as a written plan agreed with clinicians and shared with the commissioner before the mid-year review.
How clawback works
After each financial year, every contract goes through reconciliation, which NHS Dental Services complete by September[1]. If a contract delivered fewer than 96% of its UDA or UOA target, a financial clawback applies, up to the value of 100% of the activity target, and the contract may receive a breach notice[1]. Between 96% and 100%, the shortfall is carried forward and must be delivered in the next year before any new activity counts[1]. For contracts measured in courses of treatment, such as some sedation or domiciliary services, any delivery under 100% is subject to clawback[1].
From April 2026 there is a second test. Contracts specify a required number of urgent treatments, and contract sanctions do not apply if at least 96% of those are delivered[2]. A practice can therefore pass on UDAs and fail on urgent courses, or the other way round. Track both.
Clawback is calculated on the whole shortfall below the target, not just the part below 96%[1]. Falling from 96% to 95% can turn a carry-forward into a repayment of several percent of contract value.
The early warning signs
Clawback rarely arrives as a surprise to a practice that looks for it. The signs usually appear in the first half of the year.
- Cumulative credited UDAs below the 96% pace line[1] for two months running.
- A rising count of courses open for more than six weeks.
- More rejected or queried claims on the monthly schedule than usual.
- A clinician leaving, on long-term leave or reducing sessions without a replacement plan.
- Urgent courses running below the weekly level needed for the required number.
- Carried-forward activity from last year still not cleared by midsummer.
- Diary utilisation falling because of failed appointments or unfilled cancellations.
- Example practice
- 96% pace
- 100% pace
Source: NHS Business Services Authority, n.d.[1]
Show the data
| Period | Example practice | 96% pace | 100% pace |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr | 780 | 800 | 833 |
| May | 1,610 | 1,600 | 1,667 |
| Jun | 2,420 | 2,400 | 2,500 |
| Jul | 3,180 | 3,200 | 3,333 |
| Aug | 3,780 | 4,000 | 4,167 |
| Sep | 4,560 | 4,800 | 5,000 |
| Oct | 5,390 | 5,600 | 5,833 |
| Nov | 6,200 | 6,400 | 6,667 |
| Dec | 6,800 | 7,200 | 7,500 |
| Jan | 7,650 | 8,000 | 8,333 |
| Feb | 8,520 | 8,800 | 9,167 |
| Mar | 9,480 | 9,600 | 10,000 |
The example chart shows a fictional practice that starts the year on pace, slips over the summer and never quite recovers, finishing at 94.8% of its target. Every month from August onwards, its line sits below the 96% pace. That is the moment to act, not March.
Why claims and paperwork matter at year end
A surprising share of year-end shortfalls is administrative. FP17 claims must be submitted within two months of the date the course was completed; later claims have their UDAs disallowed[3]. A claim received after the year-end report is published does not count towards the correct year's performance[3]. In the last quarter, a fortnight's backlog in claiming can decide whether a practice crosses the threshold.
- Run a weekly report of completed but unclaimed courses from January onwards.
- Correct rejected claims the week they appear.
- Close failed-to-return courses promptly under your policy so the work done is recorded.
- Check that every clinician's claims are reaching NHSBSA, especially new starters and locums.
Building a recovery plan
Quantify the gap
Project year-end delivery from the current run rate and seasonal pattern. Express the gap in UDAs and in clinical days needed to close it.
Recover the paperwork first
Clear open courses, late claims and rejected claims. This costs little and often closes a meaningful part of the gap.
Add capacity with a cost
Price extra sessions, a locum, or additional hygienist or therapist time against the clawback they would prevent.
Target the right patients
Focus extra capacity on overdue recalls and patients waiting for treatment, not on unnecessary activity.
Agree it with the team
Share the plan, who is doing what and how extra sessions will be paid. A plan imposed in February rarely works.
Write it down for the commissioner
Send the gap, the causes and the plan to your contract manager before the mid-year review, and update them monthly.
Running a year-end countdown
From January, switch from monthly to weekly tracking. The last quarter is when small delays matter most, and a weekly rhythm gives the team time to react.
Week by week from January
Update the projection every Monday with credited and claimed UDAs, open courses and urgent courses. Share it with clinicians the same day.
February: protect the diary
Fill cancellations from a short-notice list and keep urgent slots running. Avoid booking new long courses that cannot finish before 31 March unless clinically needed.
March: complete and claim
Focus on finishing open courses and sending claims promptly. Check with each clinician that nothing completed is sitting unclaimed.
April to June: tidy up
Correct rejected claims for the old year quickly and check that every claim reaches NHSBSA before the year-end report is produced.
Write the countdown into the practice calendar in the autumn so it happens every year without depending on one person remembering.
Talking to your commissioner
Commissioners deal with under-delivery every year. They respond better to a practice that raises a problem early, explains it with evidence and shows a credible plan than to one that waits for year end. The mid-year review now covers the required number of urgent treatments as well as UDAs[2], so bring both sets of figures.
- Explain causes you could not control, such as a sudden long-term absence, with dates.
- Ask whether a temporary variation to the target is possible, and get any agreement in writing as a formal variation.
- Ask how the commissioner will treat urgent-course delivery if routine activity is reduced to protect it.
- Copy your Local Dental Committee if the discussion turns to a permanent reduction in contract value.
Be cautious about agreeing to hand back activity permanently. A reduction may solve this year's problem but will reduce income in every future year.
Plan the finances as well as the activity
Because reconciliation is completed months after the year ends, a clawback can arrive in the middle of the following year. Owners should estimate the likely figure at year end and set money aside in the accounts, rather than spending contract income that may have to be repaid. Ask your accountant to show the expected clawback or carry-forward as a separate line in the management accounts from the autumn onwards.
Nationally, NHS activity is rising: England delivered 76.8 million UDAs in 2025/26, 5.1% more than the year before[4], and 25,419 dentists had NHS activity, up 3.1%[5]. A national recovery does not protect any single contract; it only makes it more likely that commissioners will expect delivery in full.
Source: NHS Business Services Authority, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024/25 | 73.1 million |
| 2025/26 | 76.8 million |
What not to do
- Do not split courses of treatment or claim treatment that was not clinically needed to raise units. Inappropriate claiming is a probity and fraud risk.
- Do not overbook clinicians so heavily that failed appointments and errors rise.
- Do not leave the problem to the last quarter in the hope that January demand will fix it.
- Do not rely on informal emails from the commissioner about tolerance; only a formal variation protects the contract.
Example: a recovery that worked
Example: a fictional practice with a target of 10,000 UDAs sees its cumulative line fall below the 96% pace in August after an associate leaves. In September the manager projects 9,480 UDAs for the year, 94.8%. The recovery plan clears 210 open courses and late claims, books a locum for two days a week from October and moves hygienist time to overdue recalls. The contract manager receives the plan before the mid-year review. The practice finishes at 97.1%, carries forward the small shortfall and avoids clawback.
The following April, the manager starts the year with the carried-forward shortfall booked into the first two months of the forecast, so it is cleared before the summer holidays. The same weekly countdown runs from January, and the locum budget is agreed in the autumn rather than in a hurry. The practice does not need a second rescue.
Frequently asked questions
When does clawback apply?
When UDA or UOA delivery falls below 96% of the annual target. Between 96% and 100%, the shortfall is carried forward to the next year instead.
Is clawback only on the amount below 96%?
No. Once delivery falls below 96%, clawback can apply to the whole shortfall against the target, which is why the threshold matters so much.
Does the urgent care requirement have its own threshold?
Yes. Contract sanctions do not apply if at least 96% of the required urgent treatments are delivered.
When will we know the year-end result?
Reconciliation is completed by September after the financial year ends, so plan your accounts for a possible clawback in the following year.
References
NHS Business Services Authority (n.d.). What happens if I under or over-perform on my contract? (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). The National Health Service (Primary Dental Services and Dental Charges) (Amendment) Regulations 2026: explanatory note (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS Business Services Authority (n.d.). How long do I have to submit an FP17 or FP17O? (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS Business Services Authority (2026). Dental statistics - England 2025/26 (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS Business Services Authority (2026). Dental statistics - England 2025/26 (opens in a new tab) ↑