Key takeaways
- Employees can make a statutory flexible working request from their first day in a job[1], and can make two applications in any 12-month period[2].
- The employer must decide within two months unless the employee agrees to longer, and must discuss the request before refusing it[3].
- A refusal must rest on one of eight business reasons, such as being unable to reorganise the work or meet demand[3].
- For reception roles, test each request against your demand pattern: 45% of GP appointments are booked for the same day[4], so opening hours carry most of the load.
- A time-limited trial with agreed measures turns many difficult requests into workable arrangements.
The rules in brief
Flexible working covers any change to when, where or how long someone works: fewer hours, compressed hours, different start and finish times, term-time working, job sharing or working some admin tasks from home. Employees can make a request from their first day in a job[1]. They can make two applications in any 12-month period[2], and a written application must include the date, a statement that it is a statutory request, details of the change and when they want it to start, and whether and when they have made a previous application[2].
The employer must make a decision within two months of the request, or longer if the employee agrees[3]. Before refusing, the employer must have discussed the request with the employee[3]. If your policy offers an appeal, plan for it to finish inside the same period unless the employee agrees to an extension, so a practice that takes six weeks to hold the first meeting leaves itself very little time.
2 months
Time an employer has to decide a flexible working request, unless the employee agrees to an extension[3]
The eight business reasons
An employer can refuse a request only if it has a good business reason. The reasons listed in government guidance are[3]:
- Extra costs that will damage the business.
- The work cannot be reorganised among other staff.
- People cannot be recruited to do the work.
- Flexible working will affect quality.
- Flexible working will affect performance.
- The business will not be able to meet customer demand.
- There is a lack of work to do during the proposed working times.
- The business is planning changes to the workforce.
Naming a reason is not enough. Write down the facts behind it: the call volumes at the hour in question, the number of staff already on reduced hours that morning, or the recruitment attempts that failed. If the decision is challenged, the record of how you reached it matters as much as the reason itself.
A process that works on a busy desk
Log the request on the day it arrives
Record the date, acknowledge it in writing and set the decision deadline two months ahead in your diary. If the request is missing required details, tell the employee straight away rather than waiting.
Hold a meeting within two weeks
Discuss what the employee is asking for, why, and what flexibility they have. Many requests have more than one workable version, such as a later start on three days rather than five.
Assess the impact using data
Look at demand and cover for the hours affected, other agreed arrangements and the skills needed on those shifts. Ask the team lead for a view.
Consider alternatives
If the original request does not work, look for a version that does. Discussing alternatives is part of handling a request reasonably.
Decide and write to the employee
Confirm the decision, the reasons and, for an acceptance, the new terms and start date. For a refusal, explain the business reason and the facts, and how to appeal.
Hear any appeal promptly
Use a different manager or partner if possible, and finish within the two-month period unless an extension has been agreed in writing.
Testing a reception request against demand
Reception requests are hardest when they affect the start of the day. Demand in general practice is front-loaded: in the year to August 2026, 45% of GP appointments were booked for the same day and 81% were booked to take place within two weeks[4]. Same-day demand arrives mostly at opening, so a request to start at 9.30am rather than 8am affects the busiest part of the day far more than a request to finish at 4pm.
- Same day 45%
- Next day to two weeks 36%
- More than two weeks 19%
Source: British Medical Association, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Same day | 45% |
| Next day to two weeks | 36% |
| More than two weeks | 19% |
- Which hours does the request affect, and what are call and walk-in volumes in those hours?
- How many people are already on later starts, shorter days or term-time contracts on the same days?
- Could the employee cover a different peak, such as the afternoon release of appointments, in exchange?
- Are there tasks, such as scanning, coding or letters, that could be done at the requested times or from home?
- Would the change be workable if one colleague with a similar arrangement left?
Using a trial period
When the impact is uncertain, agree a trial instead of refusing. A trial of a few weeks gives both sides real evidence. Agree in writing the trial dates, the measures you will look at and what happens at the end. Useful measures for reception include calls answered in the affected hours, queue times, overtime used by colleagues and any complaints linked to cover.
Make the trial long enough to include a Monday after a bank holiday or a flu clinic week if those are the real tests. If the trial goes well, confirm the permanent change. If it does not, explain what the evidence showed and discuss alternatives before deciding. Remember that the overall decision still needs to be made within the statutory period unless the employee agrees to extend it.
Common requests and how to approach them
| Request | What to check | Options that often work |
|---|---|---|
| Later start every day | Cover at opening; who else starts late | Later start on two or three days; earlier finish swapped in |
| Term-time only | School holiday leave caps; holiday cover pool | Term-time contract with agreed holiday working days |
| Compressed hours | Long shifts on the phones; break cover | Four longer days with a mid-morning break protected |
| Home working for admin tasks | Data protection, equipment, task volume | Scanning, coding or letters from home on set days |
| Reduced hours | Total cover; recruitment of the remaining hours | Job share or recruit for the released hours |
Home working for clinical admin needs secure equipment, a private space where calls and screens cannot be overheard or seen, and clear rules on paper records. Check these before you agree, and write them into the arrangement.
Writing the decision
An acceptance is a permanent change to the contract unless you agree otherwise, so say so clearly. A refusal should be specific and respectful. Two short templates:
- Acceptance: 'Thank you for your request dated [date]. I am pleased to confirm that from [start date] your working pattern will be [pattern]. This is a permanent change to your contract. We will review how it is working with you on [date].'
- Refusal: 'Thank you for your request dated [date] and for meeting me on [date]. I am unable to agree to the change because [business reason]. In particular, [facts]. We discussed [alternatives] and [outcome]. If you wish to appeal, please write to [name] by [date].'
Keeping arrangements working over time
An agreed arrangement is not the end of the matter. Practices change: a merger adds a branch site, a new appointment system moves the peak, a colleague with a similar pattern leaves. Keep a simple register of every flexible arrangement in the team, with the pattern, the date agreed and the review date, so you can see the whole picture before agreeing the next one.
- Review each arrangement informally after three months and then once a year, with the employee, focusing on what is working and what is not.
- If the practice's needs change, discuss options with the employee first; an agreed contract change cannot simply be withdrawn.
- Share the overall pattern of cover with the team so people understand why later requests for the same hours are harder to agree.
- Make sure arrangements do not quietly push the hardest shifts onto the same few colleagues.
Handled well, flexible working is one of the most effective retention tools a practice has. Many experienced receptionists stay because their pattern fits their life, and replacing them costs far more than adjusting a rota.
Example: two requests, one rota
Example (fictional): Two receptionists at Brookside Surgery ask to start at 9.30am after their children change school. Call data show the busiest hour is 8am to 9am. The manager meets both, then offers a trial: one starts at 9.30am on Mondays and Wednesdays, the other on Tuesdays and Thursdays, and both cover the afternoon appointment release at 1pm. After six weeks, morning queue times have not changed and both arrangements are confirmed.
Further changes to flexible working are planned under the Employment Rights Act 2025. Keep an eye on the timeline in our employment law checklist for practices and update your policy when the new rules are confirmed.
Frequently asked questions
Can a new starter ask for flexible working in their first week?
Yes. Employees can make a statutory request from their first day in a job. The usual process and two-month decision period apply.
Do we have to agree to a trial period?
There is no legal requirement to offer a trial, but it is often the best way to test a request when the impact is uncertain, and it shows the request was considered properly.
What if several staff ask for the same hours?
Consider each request on its merits in the order received, taking account of arrangements already agreed. Explain clearly if a later request cannot be accommodated because earlier changes have already reduced cover at those times.
References
GOV.UK (2026). Flexible working (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Flexible working: applying for flexible working (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Flexible working: after the application (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑