Key takeaways
- There are four levels: basic, standard, enhanced and enhanced with barred lists, each showing more than the last[1].
- The level depends on the duties of the role, not the job title; if a role does not meet the criteria for a higher check, it can obtain a basic check[2].
- Reception roles that involve chaperoning or other regulated activity need a different level from roles that only handle the phones and front desk, so assess each role.
- A disclosure is not an automatic bar: record a fair, role-based risk assessment and the decision.
- Keep a record of the check level, date, outcome and decision for every member of staff; inspectors look at recruitment records as part of how well-led a practice is[3].
The four levels in plain terms
The Disclosure and Barring Service offers four levels of criminal record check. A basic check shows unspent convictions and conditional cautions. A standard check shows spent and unspent convictions and cautions. An enhanced check shows the same as a standard check plus any information held by local police. An enhanced check with barred lists also shows whether the person is on a list of people barred from certain work[1].
Employers request standard and enhanced checks through the DBS, either as a registered body or through an umbrella body that processes checks for them. More detailed checks can be requested for certain roles, such as in healthcare[1]. Anyone can apply for a basic check, which usually takes up to three days to process[4].
Eligibility follows duties, not job titles
The most common mistake practices make is asking for one level of check for everyone, or choosing a level because it feels safest. The law sets which roles are eligible for standard and enhanced checks, and an employer must not ask for a higher-level check than the role is eligible for. If the criteria are not met for a standard, enhanced or enhanced with barred list check, the role can obtain a basic check[2].
So the question is not 'what level do receptionists need?' but 'what does this particular receptionist do?'. Write down the actual duties of each admin role, then check eligibility using the DBS eligibility guidance or the tool your umbrella body provides.
| Duties in the role | Check to consider | Points to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Phones, front desk, registrations, no patient care | Check eligibility; healthcare access roles may qualify for standard, otherwise basic | Whether normal duties give access to patients receiving services |
| Acts as a chaperone during examinations | Check eligibility for enhanced with the relevant barred list | Whether the duties count as regulated activity |
| Works mainly with records, no patient contact | Basic, unless eligibility guidance says otherwise | Remote or back-office roles often only meet basic criteria |
| Manager with oversight of staff in regulated activity | Check eligibility for enhanced | Management and supervision duties in the guidance |
| Agency, bank or network staff | As for the duties they will carry out | Who holds the check and how you see the evidence |
A safe recruitment process
Define the duties
Agree the duties for the role, including whether the person will chaperone, do home visits support, or work alone with patients. This determines eligibility.
Confirm eligibility
Check the level using DBS eligibility guidance or your umbrella body before you advertise, and state the level in the advert so candidates know what to expect.
Verify identity
Check the applicant's identity documents in line with DBS identity checking guidance, in person or using an approved digital route.
Submit and track
Submit the application and track it. Do not let someone start in a role that requires the check until you have the result, unless a documented risk assessment and supervision plan allows it.
See the certificate
The certificate is sent to the applicant. Ask to see the original or check it through the Update Service with the applicant's consent.
Record the outcome
Record the level, certificate number, date, whether anything was disclosed and the decision. Do not keep a copy of the certificate longer than you need it.
When something is disclosed
A disclosure does not automatically mean you cannot employ someone. What matters is whether the information is relevant to the role. A drink-driving conviction from fifteen years ago may have little bearing on a reception job; a recent fraud conviction is relevant to a role handling cash and personal data.
- Talk to the applicant before deciding; give them the chance to explain the circumstances.
- Consider the nature of the offence, how long ago it was, whether it was a one-off and how it relates to the duties.
- Record your reasoning in a short risk assessment signed by the decision-maker.
- Treat the information confidentially and share it only with those who need to know.
- Have a written policy on recruiting people with criminal records and follow it consistently.
Rechecks and the Update Service
A DBS certificate has no official expiry date. It shows information at the date it was issued. Practices set their own policy on rechecks, usually based on risk: for example, a fresh check when someone moves into a role with different eligibility, after a long break in employment, or at a set interval for chaperones. Whatever you choose, write it down and apply it consistently.
The DBS Update Service lets applicants keep their certificate up to date and lets employers check, with the applicant's consent, whether any new information has been added since it was issued. For staff who subscribe, an online status check is quicker than a new application and gives you a dated record for the file.
Locums, agency and network staff
Not everyone who works at the front desk is your employee. Agency receptionists, bank staff from a neighbouring practice and primary care network employees who work in your building all need appropriate checks, but the check may be held by another organisation. Your responsibility is to be satisfied that the right check exists for the duties they will do in your practice, and to keep evidence of that.
- Ask agencies for written confirmation of the check level, date and outcome for each worker before their first shift, and keep it on file.
- Agree with the primary care network who holds recruitment records for shared staff and how you will see them before an inspection.
- Brief temporary staff on the duties they may and may not carry out, especially chaperoning, if their check level does not cover it.
- Add temporary and shared staff to your training and checks matrix so gaps are visible.
What inspectors look for
Inspectors look at recruitment records as part of judging whether a practice is safe and well-led. Most practices handle this well: 87% of GP practices assessed under CQC's current framework are rated good and 3% outstanding[3]. Missing or inconsistent recruitment checks are one of the avoidable issues that can pull a practice out of that group.
- Good 87%
- Outstanding 3%
- Requires improvement 9%
- Inadequate 1%
Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Good | 87% |
| Outstanding | 3% |
| Requires improvement | 9% |
| Inadequate | 1% |
- A recruitment policy that says which check each role needs and why.
- For each member of staff: check level, date, certificate number, outcome and decision, plus any risk assessment.
- Evidence of checks for locums, agency and network staff working in the practice, or confirmation from the employing organisation.
- A record of chaperone training and the check level held by everyone who chaperones.
- A recheck policy and evidence that it has been followed.
Treat this information as sensitive. Criminal record information has additional protection under data protection law, and serious failures can attract fines of up to £17.5 million or 4% of annual worldwide turnover[5]. Keep the record in a restricted HR file, not on a shared drive.
A one-page checks policy
A short written policy makes decisions consistent and shows inspectors that checks are planned rather than improvised. Keep it to one page and review it each year or whenever roles change.
- Purpose: the practice carries out recruitment checks proportionate to each role's duties.
- Roles and levels: a table of each role, its main duties and the check level it is eligible for.
- Timing: checks are completed before a start date, or a documented risk assessment and supervision plan is in place.
- Disclosures: how information is assessed, who decides and how the decision is recorded.
- Rechecks: when the practice repeats a check or uses the Update Service.
- Records: what is kept, where, who can see it and how long it is retained.
Example: sorting out mixed records
Example (fictional): A new manager at a 12,000-patient practice finds that some receptionists have enhanced checks, some basic and two none at all, with no record of why. She lists every role's duties, confirms eligibility with the umbrella body, and finds that four receptionists chaperone and need a different level from the rest. She applies for the correct checks, writes a one-page recruitment policy and adds a check column to the training matrix. At the next inspection, the recruitment files are complete and consistent.
The fix took a few weeks and very little money. The hardest part was writing down what each person actually does, which is also the foundation for fair job descriptions and training.
Frequently asked questions
Do GP receptionists need a DBS check?
Practices should carry out an appropriate check for every role. The level depends on the duties: a receptionist who chaperones needs a different level from one who only works on the phones. Confirm eligibility for each role's duties rather than using one level for everyone.
Can we use a DBS check from a previous employer?
You can accept a previous certificate if the applicant subscribes to the Update Service and a status check shows no new information, and the check is the right level and workforce for your role. Otherwise, apply for a new check.
How long should we keep DBS information?
Keep a record of the level, date, certificate number and decision for as long as you need it for employment purposes, but do not keep copies of certificates longer than necessary. Set this out in your retention policy.
References
GOV.UK (Disclosure and Barring Service) (2026). Check someone's criminal record (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Disclosure and Barring Service) (2026). Eligibility for roles working with adults (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: primary and community services (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Disclosure and Barring Service) (2026). Request a basic DBS check (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 83: General conditions for imposing administrative fines (opens in a new tab) ↑