Regulation compliance

CQC's assessment framework for primary care

How CQC assesses GP practices now: key questions, quality statements, evidence categories, 1 to 4 scoring, rating thresholds and what changed from KLOEs.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. The building blocks
  2. The six evidence categories
  3. How scoring works
  4. Rules that stop weak areas hiding
  5. What changed from the old model
  6. Reading the framework as a GP practice
  7. Turning the framework into a plan
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References

Key takeaways

  • The framework has 5 key questions and 34 quality statements, each written as a ‘we statement’ describing good care.
  • Inspectors score each assessed quality statement from 1 to 4, then convert key question scores into ratings using fixed percentage bands.
  • Rules stop poor areas hiding: a single score of 1 caps a key question at requires improvement.
  • Evidence comes from six categories and is gathered over time, so assessments no longer depend on a single visit.

The building blocks

CQC's assessment framework is made up of 5 key questions and, under each, a set of quality statements[1]. The key questions are the ones every practice manager knows: are services safe, effective, caring, responsive to people's needs, and well-led. Quality statements are the commitments providers should live up to, expressed as ‘we statements’ that show what is needed to deliver high-quality, person-centred care, and they link to the regulations CQC considers in its judgements[1].

Across the five key questions there are 34 quality statements: 8 under safe, 6 under effective, 5 under caring, 7 under responsive and 8 under well-led[1]. Some will feel familiar from the old key lines of enquiry, such as safeguarding, medicines optimisation and infection prevention and control. Others are newer emphases, such as equity in access, workforce wellbeing and environmental sustainability.

Quality statements under each CQC key question34 quality statements in total
Quality statements under each CQC key questionColumn chart. Safe: 8; Effective: 6; Caring: 5; Responsive: 7; Well-led: 8.02468Safe: 88SafeEffective: 66EffectiveCaring: 55CaringResponsive: 77ResponsiveWell-led: 88Well-ledQuality statements under each CQC key questionColumn chart. Safe: 8; Effective: 6; Caring: 5; Responsive: 7; Well-led: 8.02468Safe: 88SafeEffective: 66Effect-iveCaring: 55CaringResponsive: 77Respon-siveWell-led: 88Well-l-ed

Source: Care Quality Commission, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Safe8
Effective6
Caring5
Responsive7
Well-led8

The six evidence categories

CQC groups the evidence it uses into 6 categories, setting out for each quality statement which categories it will focus on, so its judgements are more transparent and consistent[2].

  1. People's experience of health and care services: patient feedback, surveys, complaints and compliments.
  2. Feedback from staff and leaders: conversations, staff surveys and speaking-up concerns.
  3. Feedback from partners: views from the ICB, PCN, local hospitals, pharmacies and social care.
  4. Observation: what inspectors see on site, such as the environment and interactions.
  5. Processes: policies, audits, logs, governance records and how they are used.
  6. Outcomes: data on clinical outcomes, screening, immunisation and access.

CQC says the number of evidence categories it considers varies with the type of service, the level of assessment and whether it is an existing service or a registration[2]. NHS GP practices sit in the primary health services group, alongside NHS 111, out-of-hours and urgent care services.

How scoring works

CQC changed how it applies scores on 2 December 2024[3]. For each quality statement it assesses, it gives a score on a scale of 1 to 4: evidence shows significant shortfalls, some shortfalls, a good standard, or an exceptional standard[3]. Inspectors use professional judgement to assign the score, based on the evidence categories they have looked at.

The quality statement scores then build up to a key question score, expressed as a percentage of the maximum possible: the number of quality statements multiplied by 4[3]. CQC translates that percentage into a rating using fixed bands[3].

CQC's thresholds for translating a key question score into a rating[3].
Key question scoreRating
25% to 38%Inadequate
39% to 62%Requires improvement
63% to 87%Good
88% and aboveOutstanding
Minimum key question score for each rating
Minimum key question score for each ratingColumn chart. Inadequate: 25%; Requires improvement: 39%; Good: 63%; Outstanding: 88%.0%25%50%75%100%Inadequate: 25%25%InadequateRequires improvement: 39%39%Requires improvementGood: 63%63%GoodOutstanding: 88%88%OutstandingMinimum key question score for each ratingColumn chart. Inadequate: 25%; Requires improvement: 39%; Good: 63%; Outstanding: 88%.0%25%50%75%100%Inadequate: 25%25%Inadequ-ateRequires improvement: 39%39%Requiresimprove-mentGood: 63%63%GoodOutstanding: 88%88%Outstan-ding

Source: Care Quality Commission, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Inadequate25%
Requires improvement39%
Good63%
Outstanding88%

Rules that stop weak areas hiding

Percentages alone could let one serious problem be averaged away. CQC applies limiting rules: if a key question score is in the good range but any quality statement scores 1, the rating is limited to requires improvement; if the score is in the outstanding range but any statement scores 1 or 2, the rating is limited to good[3].

Overall ratings follow aggregation principles. The 5 key questions are weighted equally; at least 2 would normally need to be outstanding and 3 good for an overall outstanding; the overall rating will normally be good if no key question is inadequate and no more than one requires improvement; and 2 or more key questions rated requires improvement or inadequate will normally pull the overall rating down to that level[3].

  1. Example: a safe key question

    Example: a fictional practice is assessed on all 8 safe quality statements and scores 3 on seven of them and 2 on one. That is 23 out of a possible 32, or 72%, which falls in the good band.

  2. Example: one significant shortfall

    Example: if the same practice had scored 1 on medicines optimisation instead of 2, the total would be 22 out of 32, or 69%. The percentage is still in the good band, but the limiting rule caps the rating at requires improvement.

  3. What it means in practice

    One area with significant shortfalls matters more than several areas that are merely good. Find and fix the weakest areas first.

What changed from the old model

The older approach used key lines of enquiry and prompts, with ratings largely tied to a planned inspection cycle. CQC now describes several differences for providers. It makes more use of information, including people's experiences, and gathers evidence at different times rather than mainly through site visits. It no longer uses a service's rating as the main driver of when to assess next; information received at any time can trigger an assessment. And it can update scores for individual quality statements as new evidence arrives, rather than only after an inspection.

  • Assessments can look at one, several or all quality statements, depending on risk and the evidence available.
  • CQC has said it will set priority quality statements for each type of service, reviewed at least annually.
  • Scores give a position within a rating, showing whether a good practice is nearer outstanding or nearer requires improvement.
  • Older GP guidance built around key lines of enquiry is kept as legacy material, and some pages for online primary care are marked as under review.

Because CQC adjusts its guidance regularly, check the ‘page last updated’ date on each framework page before you rely on it, and re-read the scoring guidance before any assessment.

Reading the framework as a GP practice

Most practices are already doing well against it: 87% of GP practices assessed under the current framework are rated good and a further 3% outstanding[4]. The useful exercise is to read each of the 34 quality statements and ask what evidence, in each relevant category, shows you meet it. Some statements map neatly onto existing work: safeguarding onto training records and case reviews, learning culture onto significant event analysis, providing information onto your website and patient leaflets.

Responsive statements deserve special attention because access is where patient experience is most visible. Since 1 October 2025, GP practices in England have had to offer online consultation systems throughout core hours for routine appointments and admin requests[5], so expect equity in access and person-centred care to be tested against how both digital and non-digital routes work in your practice.

Alongside the quality statements, the framework gives weight to people's own descriptions of good care, written from the patient's point of view. They are a useful test for any process: read your appointment, prescription or complaints process as a patient would experience it, and ask whether a patient would recognise the care described. Patient participation groups, complaints themes and free-text survey comments are the evidence that shows whether they would. Well-led statements, meanwhile, look for leaders who know where the practice is weak and are acting on it, so a governance record that names problems openly and tracks the fixes is stronger evidence than one that only reports successes.

Turning the framework into a plan

  1. List all 34 quality statements in a spreadsheet, grouped by key question.
  2. For each, note the evidence you hold in each relevant category and where it is kept.
  3. Score yourself honestly from 1 to 4, and mark any statement where you would score 1 or 2.
  4. Fix the lowest scores first, because of the limiting rules.
  5. Review the spreadsheet quarterly and update it when evidence changes.

For the practical side of getting ready, see the GP inspection checklist, evidencing timely access and CQC GP mythbusters. Dental practices should read CQC dental inspections, and anyone planning a new service starting a private GP service.

Frequently asked questions

How many quality statements are there?

34 across the five key questions: 8 safe, 6 effective, 5 caring, 7 responsive and 8 well-led[1].

How does CQC score a quality statement?

On a scale of 1 to 4, from significant shortfalls to an exceptional standard, based on the evidence categories assessed[3].

What percentage is needed for a good rating?

A key question score of 63% to 87% translates to good, subject to the limiting rules[3].

Are the old key lines of enquiry still used?

No. They are kept as legacy guidance for reference; assessments now use quality statements and evidence categories.

References

  1. Care Quality Commission (2025). Assessment framework (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Care Quality Commission (2024). Evidence categories (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Care Quality Commission (2025). How we reach a rating (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: primary and community services (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. British Medical Association (2025). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo