Key takeaways
- CQC now gathers evidence continuously, so preparation is a habit of keeping evidence current rather than a pre-visit sprint.
- Organise evidence by the five key questions and be ready to show how you know things work, not just that policies exist.
- Brief every member of staff, including reception, on the practice's systems for access, safety, complaints and data protection.
- Most practices assessed under the current framework are rated good, and preparation is about showing that clearly.
How assessment works now
CQC's assessment framework applies across health and social care. Its five key questions, whether services are safe, effective, caring, responsive and well-led, and the four ratings of outstanding, good, requires improvement and inadequate remain central to its approach[1]. Under each key question sit quality statements, and evidence is collected in six categories[1].
The biggest practical change from the old model is timing. CQC gathers evidence in a variety of ways and at different times, not just through on-site inspections, and evidence or information received at any time can trigger an assessment. That means the practice that keeps its evidence current all year is the one that is ready.
The starting point is reassuring. Of GP practices assessed under CQC's current framework, 87% are rated good and 3% outstanding, with 9% requiring improvement and 1% inadequate[2].
- Good 87%
- Requires improvement 9%
- Outstanding 3%
- Inadequate 1%
Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Good | 87% |
| Requires improvement | 9% |
| Outstanding | 3% |
| Inadequate | 1% |
Evidence to gather, by key question
| Key question | Evidence to have ready | Questions to be able to answer |
|---|---|---|
| Safe | Significant event log and learning, safeguarding training and leads, infection control audits, medicines management, patient safety alerts log, recruitment checks, business continuity plan | How do you know alerts are acted on? How are lessons shared? |
| Effective | Clinical audits, QOF and recall performance, care plans for long-term conditions, staff training matrix, clinical supervision records | How do you monitor outcomes and improve them? |
| Caring | Patient feedback and survey results, carers register, chaperone policy and training, examples of compassionate care | How do you involve patients in decisions about their care? |
| Responsive | Access data, online consultation availability, reasonable adjustments, complaints log and responses, interpreter use | How can patients get help, and what have you changed because of feedback? |
| Well-led | Governance structure, meeting minutes, risk register, data security and protection toolkit status, staff survey, freedom to speak up arrangements | Who is accountable for what, and how do you know things are working? |
The question behind every quality statement is ‘how do you know?’. A policy shows intent. An audit, a log or a changed process shows that it works.
Access: the area most scrutinised
Patient access gets close attention because it is where patients feel the service most. Since 1 October 2025, GP practices in England must offer online consultation systems throughout core hours, 8am to 6.30pm, for routine appointments and admin requests[3]. Demand has risen with it: online consultation requests per 1,000 patients rose 67% between March 2025 and March 2026[4].
- Show your online consultation availability across core hours, and what happens to requests outside them.
- Show phone access data, such as calls answered, wait times and call-backs, and what you have done in response.
- Show how patients who cannot or will not use digital routes still get help.
- Show how urgent requests are identified and handled the same day.
- Show reasonable adjustments, such as interpreters, text relay and longer appointments, and how they are recorded.
Data security and continuity evidence
CQC does not directly assess compliance with data protection law or make detailed technical assessments of data security. Its inspectors are interested in how practices assure themselves they are meeting their responsibilities to protect patient data, and all organisations with access to NHS patient data and systems must use the Data Security and Protection Toolkit[5]. Have your latest toolkit status, breach log, training completion and access audit to hand.
For continuity, CQC's GP guidance says a robust plan should name a person responsible, reflect local risk registers, set out key functions with a maximum acceptable disruption time for each, describe how they will be restored and identify key materials, services and staff[6]. Scenarios to consider include staff absence, major IT disruption, loss of premises, damaged paper records and supplier failure[6]. Show when the plan was last tested and what changed as a result.
Gaps that often surface during preparation
- Significant events recorded, but no evidence of what was learned or changed.
- Patient safety alerts received, but no log showing who reviewed each one and what action followed.
- Recruitment files missing references, DBS checks or immunisation status for some staff, often locums or long-serving staff.
- A complaints log with responses but no themes or improvements drawn from them.
- Training records held by individual staff rather than in one matrix the manager can show.
- A business continuity plan that names staff who have left and has never been tested.
None of these needs a big project to fix. Each needs an owner and a few hours, which is why starting early matters more than working late.
Briefing staff
Inspectors talk to staff at every level, and reception and admin staff are often asked the most practical questions. Nobody needs a script, but everyone should be able to describe how things work in their own words.
Hold a short briefing for each team
Fifteen minutes is enough: how assessment works, what inspectors may ask, and where key policies and logs are kept.
Cover the core questions
Who is the safeguarding lead? How do you report a significant event? What do you do if a patient is aggressive? How does a patient complain? What happens to an urgent request?
Include data protection
How do you check a caller's identity? What do you do if you send information to the wrong person? Who is the IG lead?
Encourage honesty
Tell staff it is fine to say ‘I'd check with the manager’ and show where they would look. Inspectors value honest answers over rehearsed ones.
Include locums and new starters
Give them a one-page summary of practice leads, reporting routes and key policies.
The day itself
- Welcome the inspection team, confirm the plan and agree a room and a named contact.
- Have the evidence folder ready, organised by key question, with a short index.
- Keep clinical sessions running; inspectors want to see the practice as it normally works.
- Arrange time with the partners, practice manager, leads for safeguarding, infection control and IG, and a sample of staff.
- Keep a note of what was asked for and provided, and of any concerns raised.
- At the end, ask for any initial feedback and clarify anything that may have been misunderstood.
If something is found that you can fix on the day, such as an out-of-date fire log or a missing signature, fix it and note that you did. Do not argue; explain, provide evidence and record the conversation.
After the assessment
CQC sends a draft report for a factual accuracy check. Use it carefully: you can say where information is factually incorrect or where evidence in the report is incomplete, supported by evidence. It is not a chance to re-argue the judgement, but it is the right place to correct errors and add evidence the team did not see.
- Read the draft with the partners and manager, separating factual errors from disagreements with judgement.
- Submit corrections with evidence within the deadline given.
- Start on any required improvements straight away, whatever the final rating.
- Share the outcome and the improvement plan with staff and the patient participation group.
Example: preparing in a month
Example: Brookfield Medical Practice, a fictional surgery, learns that an assessment is likely within weeks. The manager spends week one building a shared evidence folder by key question, finding gaps in the significant event learning log and an untested continuity plan. Week two runs a tabletop continuity exercise and updates the log with recent learning. Week three holds short team briefings and a mock conversation with reception staff. Week four checks the toolkit status, training matrix and complaints log, and prepares the index.
Example: on the day, a receptionist is asked what she would do if a caller seemed confused about their medicines. She describes flagging it to the duty clinician and recording it, and shows where the process is written down. The practice's evidence shows not just policies, but that they are used.
Keep it going
The best preparation is a practice that keeps its evidence current as part of normal work. Update the folder monthly, review it quarterly at a partners' meeting, and treat every significant event, complaint and audit as evidence in the making.
Read next: CQC's assessment framework for primary care, evidencing timely access, CQC GP mythbusters, CQC dental inspections and, for new services, starting a private GP service.
Frequently asked questions
How much notice does a GP practice get of a CQC inspection?
It varies with the type of assessment. Because CQC gathers evidence continuously, practices should keep evidence current rather than relying on notice.
What does CQC look at for data protection?
Not detailed legal or technical compliance, but how the practice assures itself that patient data is protected, including the Data Security and Protection Toolkit[5].
What are the five key questions?
Whether services are safe, effective, caring, responsive and well-led[1].
Can we challenge a draft report?
You can submit factual accuracy comments with evidence where information is incorrect or incomplete. It is not a route for re-arguing judgements.
References
Care Quality Commission (2025). Assessment (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: primary and community services (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2025). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: primary and community services (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2022). GP mythbuster 85: Data security and protection – expectations for general practice (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2022). GP mythbuster 69: Business continuity – arrangements for emergencies and major incidents (opens in a new tab) ↑