Key takeaways
- A formal list closure is a written application to NHS England (in practice your ICB), not a notice you simply publish[1].
- The closure period you ask for must be between three months and 12 months, and the commissioner has 21 days to decide unless you agree longer[1].
- Commissioners must discuss support that could keep your list open, so arrive with options you have already tried and data that shows why they were not enough.
- A closed list still accepts immediate family members of registered patients, and a separate process lets the commissioner assign patients to closed lists[2][3].
- Plan the reopening at the same time as the closure: the application itself has to say how you intend to reopen.
Why practices consider closing the list
List closure usually comes up when registrations keep rising and clinical capacity does not. Across England the average number of patients per full-time-equivalent GP reached 2,143 in September 2026, up 205 since 2015[4]. The number of full-time-equivalent fully qualified GPs was 29,400, only 36 more than in September 2015[5]. A practice in a growing area, or one that has just lost a partner, can feel that arithmetic within months.
Source: British Medical Association, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| September 2015 | 1,938 |
| September 2026 | 2,143 |
Closure is a legal process with conditions, timescales and a commissioner decision. It is also a signal to your ICB and neighbouring practices that something has to change locally. Used well, it buys time to recruit, rebuild a rota or absorb a housing development. Used badly, it pushes demand onto neighbours and invites scrutiny of your access model. This guide covers GMS practices in England; check your own contract if you hold a PMS or APMS agreement, and practices in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland work under separate regulations.
The formal process, step by step
The rules sit in Part 3 of Schedule 3 to the GMS Contracts Regulations 2015[1]. In practice NHS England delegates primary care commissioning to ICBs, so your application goes to the ICB primary care team named in your contract.
Send a written application
The application must set out the options you have already considered, the discussions you have had with patients and other contractors, the closure period you want, any support you have asked for and your plan for reopening[1].
Wait for acknowledgement
The commissioner must acknowledge receipt within seven days[1]. If nothing arrives, chase it in writing so the clock is clear.
Take part in the discussions
The commissioner must open discussions about support or changes that could keep the list open, and both sides must use reasonable endeavours[1]. Bring numbers, not adjectives.
Receive the decision
The commissioner must decide within 21 days of receipt, or a longer period you both agree[1]. Approval comes as a closure notice with the closure and reopening dates.
If refused, wait or change the facts
You must normally wait three months before reapplying, unless your circumstances have changed, and you will receive written reasons[1].
Extend or reopen early
An extension request must arrive no later than eight weeks before the closure expires, and early reopening needs the commissioner's agreement[1].
You can normally make only one closure application in any 12-month period unless your circumstances have changed[1]. Treat the first application as the one that has to work.
Evidence that makes an application credible
Commissioners compare your request with local capacity and with what neighbouring practices are carrying. The strongest applications show a clear gap between demand and capacity, the steps already taken to close it and a dated plan for reopening.
- List size by month for the last 24 months, with new registrations and deductions shown separately.
- Clinical sessions available per week, split by GP, ARRS role and locum, and the sessions you have lost or failed to fill.
- Recruitment evidence: adverts placed, dates, applications received and offers declined.
- Access data: same-day demand, online requests per day, call volumes and abandoned calls for the same period.
- Premises limits, such as consulting rooms in use per session and any planned building work.
- Correspondence with neighbouring practices and your PCN about shared capacity.
- A reopening plan with the trigger you will use, such as a new partner starting or list size falling below a set number.
Example: a fictional practice of 9,800 patients loses a partner and two salaried sessions in spring. Registrations from a new estate add about 60 patients a month. Its application shows six months of list growth, three rounds of GP adverts with no appointable candidate, a converted room that will be ready in five months, and a request for a six-month closure tied to that date. That is a specific, time-limited case the ICB can test.
Alternatives commissioners will expect you to have tried
Because the regulations require discussion of support that could keep the list open, expect to be asked what else you have done[1]. Practices nationally report heavier workload since online access changes: in a BMA survey of more than 1,300 practices, 74% saw workload rise[6]. That pressure is real, but it is also universal, so local specifics matter more.
| Option | What it relieves | What the ICB will look for |
|---|---|---|
| PCN or ICB-funded sessions | Short-term clinical capacity | Evidence you asked and what was offered |
| Wider team roles | Appointments that do not need a GP | Role mix and how requests are navigated to them |
| Boundary change | Growth from outside your core area | Map of where new registrations live |
| Temporary premises fixes | Room shortage | Session plan showing rooms as the limiting factor |
| Locum or bank cover | Gaps while recruiting | Spend and fill rates for recent months |
| Merger or shared list management | Long-term sustainability | Partner discussions and timetable |
A boundary change is a separate variation and is often the better fix when growth comes from one direction. If you are unsure how patients from outside the area should be handled, see the guide on out-of-area registration.
What changes while the list is closed
A closed list is not a sealed list. While closed, a practice may still accept an application from an immediate family member of a registered patient, under the conditions in paragraph 18 of Schedule 3[2]. The regulations also contain a separate Part on assignments to closed lists, decided through an assessment panel, so a commissioner can still place patients with you in some circumstances[3].
- Brief reception on the exact wording to use with new enquiries, and keep a log of who was turned away and where they were directed.
- Update the website and phone message on the day the closure starts, with the reopening date if known.
- Keep processing registered patients as normal, including temporary residents where your contract requires it.
- Review capacity monthly against the reopening trigger and tell the ICB early if the trigger is met.
Patients often read closure as a sign the practice is failing. A short, factual explanation helps. The guide on explaining your access model to patients has wording you can adapt.
A script for new registration enquiries
Reception will take most of the questions. Give them one script and keep it short:
- Confirm what the caller wants: to register, or help for someone already registered.
- If registering: explain the list is temporarily closed to new patients and give the reopening date if one has been set.
- Check whether they are an immediate family member of a registered patient, which may still allow registration.
- Point them to the NHS website service search for other local practices and to NHS 111 for urgent needs in the meantime.
- Log the enquiry so the practice can show demand when it plans the reopening.
If an automated phone assistant handles first contact, update its practice information on the closure date. An AI Employee such as Ava can give this registration message consistently and pass anything clinical straight to reception.
Talking to your PCN and neighbouring practices first
The application has to describe discussions with other contractors, so hold them before you write it[1]. Neighbouring practices will absorb some of the registrations you turn away, and they will be asked for their view. A closure that lands on them without warning damages relationships you will need for shared rotas, enhanced access and PCN services.
- Share your list growth and capacity figures with the PCN clinical director and ask whether shared sessions or a hub can cover part of the gap.
- Ask neighbouring practices how their own lists are moving and whether they could take more registrations for a defined period.
- Agree what each practice will tell patients so nobody is sent round in circles.
- Record the date, attendees and outcome of each conversation, because the commissioner will ask.
- Agree how you will review the position together before the closure ends.
If a neighbour is also near its limit, say so in the application. Two practices under pressure in the same area is information the ICB needs for wider planning, and it strengthens the case that a short closure is a reasonable response rather than a first resort.
Common mistakes
- Informal closure: stopping registrations without an approved closure notice breaches the contract.
- Asking for 12 months by default when your evidence supports a shorter, defined period.
- Applying before talking to the PCN and neighbouring practices, which the application must describe[1].
- No reopening plan, or a plan with no measurable trigger.
- Forgetting to request an extension at least eight weeks before expiry[1].
Done carefully, closure is a short pause with a plan attached. The aim is to reopen on time with a practice that can safely carry its list.
Frequently asked questions
Can a GP practice refuse new patients without formally closing its list?
Not as a general rule. An open list accepts applications under paragraph 18 of Schedule 3[2], and stopping all new registrations needs an approved closure through the process in Schedule 3 Part 3[1].
How long can a practice list be closed?
The closure period must be at least three months and no more than 12 months. An extension can be requested no later than eight weeks before the period ends[1].
How long does the ICB have to decide?
The commissioner must acknowledge the application within seven days and decide within 21 days of receiving it, unless you agree a longer period[1].
Can family members still register while the list is closed?
Yes, a closed practice may accept an application from an immediate family member of a registered patient, subject to the conditions in paragraph 18[2].
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, Schedule 3 Part 3: closure of lists of patients (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, Schedule 3 Part 2: patients (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015: contents (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑