Key takeaways
- Patients referred for a first consultant-led or mental health outpatient appointment have a legal right to choose a provider with an NHS contract[1].
- The right does not cover urgent care, maternity or suspected cancer referrals, among other exceptions[2][3].
- A patient waiting more than 18 weeks for non-urgent consultant-led care can ask to move to a provider that can see them sooner[3].
- Most of the admin load comes from patients arriving with a provider name; a short checking routine and template wording solve most of it.
Why choice questions keep coming up
The NHS elective waiting list in England stood at 7.3 million pathways in 2025/26, down only slightly from 7.5 million the year before[4]. Patients facing long waits search for faster options, read about 'right to choose' on forums and social media, and then ask the practice to send them somewhere else. Practice teams need to know exactly what the right covers, so they can say yes quickly when it applies and explain clearly when it does not.
Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024/25 | 7.5 million pathways |
| 2025/26 | 7.3 million pathways |
What the law actually says
The duty sits in the NHS Standing Rules. When a patient needs an elective referral for a first outpatient appointment with a consultant or a consultant-led team, they must be offered a choice of any clinically appropriate provider that holds a qualifying NHS contract, and of any clinically appropriate consultant-led team at that provider[1]. Where the first appointment is in mental health and not with a consultant, the choice extends to a team led by a named healthcare professional[1].
The NHS Choice Framework, the patient-facing guide, adds two practical points. The choice is made at the point of referral, and referrers are asked to shortlist about five options where that is practicable, clinically appropriate and what the patient wants[3]. A patient who was not offered a choice can contact the responsible commissioner to exercise it[1].
Where the right does not apply
| Situation | Legal right to choose? | What to tell the patient |
|---|---|---|
| First routine consultant-led outpatient referral | Yes | You can choose any suitable provider with an NHS contract |
| First mental health referral led by a consultant or mental health professional | Yes | You can choose the provider and the team |
| Onward referral for a condition already being treated | No | Your current team decides where you go next |
| Urgent, emergency or crisis care | No | Speed comes first; we will send you to the right urgent service |
| Urgent referral for suspected cancer | No | This uses a fast pathway with its own standard |
| Maternity services | No legal right, though choice is encouraged | You can still book directly or choose a unit |
| Prisoners, people detained under the Mental Health Act, serving armed forces | No | Other arrangements apply |
These exceptions come from the regulations, which exclude cancer diagnosis services, maternity services and any service where urgent care is necessary[2], and from the Choice Framework's list of groups without the legal right[3].
The 18-week right patients often miss
There is a second, separate right that many patients do not know about. If someone has waited, or will wait, more than 18 weeks to start non-urgent consultant-led treatment, they can ask to be referred to a different provider that can see them sooner[3]. The request goes to the integrated care board or NHS England rather than to the practice, and there are exceptions, for example where the patient chose to wait longer, where no alternative can treat them sooner, or where delay is in their clinical interest[3].
Reception teams can save time by pointing patients to the right body. A practice cannot move a patient between hospital waiting lists on its own, but it can explain who can and give the contact details.
A referral routine that respects choice
Decide the clinical need
The clinician decides whether a referral is needed and how urgent it is. Urgency determines whether choice applies.
Offer the options
For routine referrals, show the patient suitable providers, including distance and waiting time where your system shows it. Aim for a shortlist rather than a single default.
Record the choice
Note in the record that choice was offered, which provider the patient chose and why if they declined to choose.
Check any provider the patient names
If the patient brings a provider name, confirm it holds an NHS contract for the service and accepts referrals from your area.
Send and confirm
Send the referral through the usual route and tell the patient how the provider will contact them.
Hand over the chasing
Give the patient the provider's contact details so waiting-time questions go to the provider, not the practice.
When the patient arrives with a provider name
This is where most of the extra work happens, particularly for ADHD and autism assessments, where patients often research providers themselves. Treat it as a simple check, not a debate.
- Ask for the provider's full name and website, and whether the patient has already contacted it.
- Check that it offers the service under an NHS contract rather than privately.
- Confirm what the provider needs from the practice: a referral letter, a form, recent results.
- Tell the patient that later prescribing requests, if any, will be considered separately.
Script: 'You can choose where you are referred for this assessment, as long as the provider has an NHS contract for it. I'll pass the details to the doctor, who will check it is suitable and send the referral. Please allow [time] for that, and the provider will then contact you directly about their wait.'
Our guides on private ADHD assessments and shared care requests cover what happens after the assessment.
Reducing the admin load
Choice generates repeat contacts when patients are unsure what happens next. A few small changes stop most of them.
- A short page on your website explaining the right to choose, its exceptions and the 18-week right, with links to the NHS Choice Framework.
- A referral form question asking whether the patient has a provider in mind, so the clinician sees it before the consultation.
- Template text that clinicians can paste into the record to show choice was offered.
- A standard reply for patients asking to change provider after referral, pointing them to the provider and the ICB.
- A monthly look at how many choice-related contacts you receive, so you can see whether the changes work.
Example: a fictional practice in Coventry found that four in ten calls about referrals were from patients asking which hospital they had been sent to or how long it would take. Adding the provider name and contact number to the referral confirmation text halved those calls within two months.
When the patient mainly wants speed
Many patients who ask about choice are really asking how to be seen sooner. Answer that question directly. Choice can help when a nearby provider has a shorter wait, but it is not a guarantee, and some providers with short published waits have long waits for follow-up or treatment after the first appointment.
- Ask what matters most: distance, speed, a particular hospital, or continuity with a team they know.
- Show waiting information where your referral system displays it, and say it is an estimate.
- Explain that changing provider later can mean starting again at the new provider's first appointment.
- If the patient is considering paying privately, explain that private care is separate from NHS choice and that NHS referral rules still apply if they come back to the NHS.
What the practice manager should keep an eye on
Choice is a legal duty, so it belongs in your governance. A small monthly check is enough for most practices.
- A sample of routine referrals: was choice offered and recorded?
- Complaints or feedback that mention choice or referral delays.
- Any providers patients name repeatedly, and whether they hold NHS contracts.
- Time from consultation to referral being sent, which is the part the practice controls.
If audits show choice is rarely recorded, the fix is usually a template prompt in the referral form rather than more training.
Choice on the NHS App
The government's 10 Year Health Plan says patients will be able to choose providers on the NHS App using quality information such as waiting times, patient ratings and clinical outcomes[5]. As that develops, more patients will arrive at appointments having already compared options, and more choice will happen without the practice in the middle. The practice's role becomes making a good-quality referral and giving the patient the information they need to choose well.
Mistakes to avoid
- Telling patients they have no choice because the practice usually refers to the local trust.
- Offering choice on urgent referrals and delaying them while the patient decides.
- Agreeing to refer to a private-only service as if it were an NHS choice.
- Promising that the new provider's wait will be shorter without checking.
- Taking on waiting-list chasing that belongs with the provider or the ICB.
Frequently asked questions
Who has the right to choose in England?
Patients referred for a first routine outpatient appointment with a consultant-led team, or a first mental health appointment led by a consultant or mental health professional, can choose any clinically appropriate provider with an NHS contract[1].
Does right to choose apply to urgent referrals?
No. Services where urgent care is necessary, cancer diagnosis services and maternity services are excluded from the duty[2].
Can a patient switch provider if the wait is long?
If they have waited, or will wait, more than 18 weeks for non-urgent consultant-led treatment, they can ask the ICB or NHS England to move them to a provider that can see them sooner, with some exceptions[3].
Can a patient choose a private-only provider under right to choose?
No. The provider must hold an NHS contract for the service. Fully private care is paid for by the patient.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2012). The NHS Commissioning Board and Clinical Commissioning Groups (Responsibilities and Standing Rules) Regulations 2012, regulation 39: duty to offer a choice of provider (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2012). The NHS Commissioning Board and Clinical Commissioning Groups (Responsibilities and Standing Rules) Regulations 2012, regulation 40: services to which the choice duties do not apply (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department of Health and Social Care) (2024). The NHS Choice Framework: what choices are available to me in the NHS? (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department of Health and Social Care) (2025). Fit for the future: 10 Year Health Plan for England (opens in a new tab) ↑