Key takeaways
- A zero tolerance policy sets expectations and consequences; it cannot remove patients by itself. Removal follows the contract regulations.
- For non-violent behaviour, a GMS practice needs reasonable grounds, written reasons and normally a warning in the previous 12 months before requesting removal[1].
- Removal grounds must not relate to protected characteristics such as age, disability, race or religion[1].
- Violence, or behaviour that makes staff fear for their safety, reported to the police, allows immediate removal[2].
- Policies work when they are applied consistently, recorded carefully and backed by partners; 93.7% of general practice staff in one survey reported violence or abuse[3].
What a policy can and cannot do
Most practices display a zero tolerance notice. Fewer have a policy that tells staff what to do, sets out a fair process and links to the rules that actually govern removal. The notice is the visible part; the process behind it is what protects staff and stands up to complaints.
| A policy can | A policy cannot |
|---|---|
| Define unacceptable behaviour with examples | Remove a patient without following the contract regulations |
| Authorise staff to end abusive calls and ask people to leave | Apply to behaviour linked to a protected characteristic |
| Set out warnings and acceptable behaviour agreements | Replace reasonable adjustments for disability |
| Commit the practice to report violence to the police | Guarantee a particular police or NHS England response |
| Require incidents to be recorded and reviewed | Justify inconsistent treatment of different patients |
The aim is a policy that is firm about behaviour and fair in process. Patients who receive a warning should be able to see exactly what they did, what the practice expects and what will happen if it continues.
The legal framework for removal
For GMS practices in England, removal is governed by Schedule 3 to the GMS Contracts Regulations 2015. A practice may ask NHS England to remove a patient where it has reasonable grounds, and the grounds must not relate to protected characteristics such as age, disability, race, religion or belief, or sexual orientation[1]. The practice must give written notice to NHS England and normally tell the patient its specific reasons in writing[1].
Before requesting removal, the practice must normally have warned the patient within the previous 12 months that they were at risk of removal and explained why[1]. A warning is not needed where it would harm the patient's health or put staff or others at risk, or where it is not otherwise reasonable or practical[1]. The date and reasons for the warning, or why none was given, must be recorded[1]. Removal usually takes effect on the eighth day after NHS England receives notice, or earlier if the patient registers elsewhere[1].
Violence is handled differently. Where a patient has committed an act of violence against staff or others on the premises, or behaved so that someone feared for their safety, and the incident has been reported to the police, the practice can request immediate removal[2]. The practice records the removal and circumstances in the patient's record[2], and must also notify the CQC without delay[4].
An escalation ladder staff can follow
In the moment
Staff give a single clear warning and, if abuse continues, end the call or ask the person to leave. Record it the same day.
Practice review
The practice manager or a partner reviews the record, checks for clinical context and decides whether to write.
Written warning
A letter signed by a partner describing the behaviour, the standard expected and that further incidents may lead to a removal request.
Acceptable behaviour agreement
Optional, for patients who want to stay: a short written agreement about how contact will happen, reviewed after a set period.
Removal request
If behaviour continues within 12 months of a warning, request removal with written reasons, following paragraph 24[1].
Immediate removal
For violence or credible threats reported to the police, notify NHS England straight away under paragraph 25[2].
Writing a warning letter
- Date, patient name and the date and time of the incident.
- A factual description of what was said or done, without adjectives.
- Why it is unacceptable, linked to the practice policy.
- What the practice expects from now on.
- That further incidents within 12 months may lead the practice to ask NHS England to remove them from the list.
- How the patient can discuss the letter or make a complaint.
- Signature of a partner, not the receptionist involved.
Example wording: On 3 March at 8.20am you called the surgery and shouted at and swore at a member of our reception team. This is not acceptable under our policy on patient behaviour. We expect all contact with our staff to be respectful. If this happens again within the next 12 months, we may ask NHS England to remove you from our list. If you would like to discuss this letter, please contact the practice manager.
Fair process checks before any letter
- Is there a clinical explanation, such as dementia, acute mental illness or a learning disability? If so, involve a clinician and consider adjustments first.
- Is the record clear, dated and specific, with witnesses noted?
- Has the patient been treated the same way as others in similar situations?
- Have you considered whether a warning would put staff at risk, which may justify not giving one[1]?
- Is there a safeguarding concern for the patient or others in the household?
- Has a partner reviewed and signed the decision?
Fair process protects the practice as much as the patient. A removal that is challenged by complaint or the ombudsman is much easier to defend when every step is recorded.
Explaining the policy to patients
A policy that only appears on a laminated poster does little. Explain it in plain language on the website, in the practice leaflet and, briefly, in the phone message during busy periods. Frame it around respect for everyone, patients and staff alike, and pair it with an honest explanation of how appointments work, because most incidents start with frustration about access.
Avoid threatening language. Patients respond better to a calm statement of what the practice expects and what it offers in return, such as a clear complaints route and a commitment to explain decisions, than to a list of penalties.
Training staff to use it
Staff need to know exactly when the policy applies, what to say and what happens after they record an incident. Train new starters in their first week and refresh the whole team annually, using anonymised real incidents. Practise the single warning and ending a call until the words come easily; the hesitation of not knowing whether they are allowed is what keeps many receptionists on abusive calls.
- Show staff the incident log and how to complete it quickly.
- Explain what happens next after they report, and how long it usually takes.
- Tell them the outcome of incidents they reported, so they see the process working.
- Make clear that following the policy will always be backed by partners.
Does a policy reduce abuse?
Policies on their own change little. The scale of the problem is large: in a survey of 1,152 general practice staff in England, 93.7% reported violence or abuse from patients or the public[3]. What changes behaviour is consistency. When patients see that warnings follow abuse, that partners sign them and that violence leads to removal, the minority who use abuse as a tactic learn it does not work.
- Reported violence or abuse since the pandemic 93.7%
Source: BJGP Open (Chou S, Tyrrell E, Makhijani I et al.), 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Reported violence or abuse since the pandemic | 93.7% |
Example: a fictional practice displays a new policy, trains staff on the in-the-moment script and commits to sending a partner-signed letter within a week of every recorded incident of serious verbal abuse. In the first quarter it sends nine letters; only one patient receives a second. Staff report feeling more confident ending abusive calls, which they had previously avoided.
Dental practices and private clinics
NHS dental contracts and private patient terms have their own rules on ending care. Private clinics can generally decline to continue treating a patient under their terms and conditions, but should still follow a fair process, avoid discrimination and arrange safe handover of any ongoing care. NHS dental practices should check their contract and commissioner guidance before writing a removal step into the policy.
Policy checklist
- Clear definition of unacceptable behaviour with examples.
- Staff authority to end calls and ask people to leave.
- Escalation ladder linked to paragraphs 24 and 25 for GMS practices.
- Warning letter template signed by a partner.
- Fair process checks, including clinical context and reasonable adjustments.
- Incident recording and monthly review.
- Annual review of the policy with staff input.
Related guides: tackling abuse towards reception staff, the Special Allocation Scheme and a policy for ending abusive calls.
Frequently asked questions
Is a zero tolerance policy legally enforceable in a GP practice?
The policy sets expectations, but removal must follow the GMS regulations: reasonable grounds, written reasons and normally a warning within the previous 12 months[1].
Do we have to warn a patient before removing them?
Normally yes, within the previous 12 months, unless a warning would harm the patient's health or put others at risk, or is not reasonable or practical[1].
Can we remove a patient immediately for violence?
Yes, where the patient has been violent or made someone fear for their safety and the incident has been reported to the police[2].
Who should sign a warning letter?
A partner or the practice manager, not the receptionist involved, so the message comes from the practice.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, Schedule 3 paragraph 24: removal from the list at the request of the contractor (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, Schedule 3 paragraph 25: removal from the list of patients who are violent (opens in a new tab) ↑
BJGP Open (Chou S, Tyrrell E, Makhijani I et al.) (2026). Violence and abuse towards staff by patients and the public in general practice since COVID-19: findings from an online survey (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2024). Removing violent patients and the special allocation scheme (opens in a new tab) ↑