Data protection

Requests from solicitors, insurers and police

How a GP surgery, dental practice or clinic should check authority, consent and scope before disclosing patient records to solicitors, insurers or police.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Three questions before anything leaves the practice
  2. Who asks and what applies
  3. Solicitors
  4. Insurers and employers
  5. Police
  6. Government departments, councils and coroners
  7. Preparing what you send
  8. Example: a call from someone who says they are a solicitor
  9. Keep a disclosure log
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Every third-party request needs three answers before anything is sent: who is asking, on what authority, and exactly what they need.
  • A solicitor acting for the patient with signed consent is treated like the patient's own subject access request.
  • Insurers asking for a medical report are covered by the Access to Medical Reports Act, which gives the patient 21 days to ask to see it first.
  • Police have no automatic right to records; the crime exemption allows disclosure, it does not require it.

Three questions before anything leaves the practice

Requests for patient information arrive from solicitors, insurers, employers, police, local authorities and government departments every week. Each is a decision about confidentiality, and each should be made by someone trained to make it, not by whoever opens the post. The Caldicott Principles ask for a justified purpose and only the minimum necessary information[1], and records are special category data under UK GDPR[2].

  1. Who is asking?

    Confirm the organisation and the individual independently: a solicitor's firm on the SRA register, a police officer through the force switchboard, an insurer through its published contact details. Do not rely on a phone number or email given in the request.

  2. On what authority?

    Signed patient consent, a court order, a statutory power, or a request under an exemption. Each gives a different answer about what you must, may or must not disclose.

  3. What exactly do they need?

    A full record is rarely necessary. Ask for the dates and subject matter and send only that, unless the patient has consented to wider disclosure.

Who asks and what applies

A quick reference for common third-party requests. Escalate anything unusual to your information governance lead or Caldicott Guardian.
RequesterUsual authorityWhat you sendWatch for
Solicitor acting for the patientPatient's signed consentAs for a subject access requestConsent covering the whole record when only part is relevant
Solicitor for another partyCourt order or patient consentOnly what the order or consent coversRequests with no order and no consent
Insurer asking for a reportPatient consent under the Access to Medical Reports ActA report, not the full recordInsurers using a subject access request to get the full record
Insurer verifying a claimPatient consentInformation needed to verify the claimConsent evidence missing
PolicePatient consent, court order, or a decision under the crime exemptionThe minimum needed for the stated purposePressure for an immediate answer by phone
Employer or occupational healthPatient consent; reports under the Access to Medical Reports ActA report on the questions askedRequests for the whole record
CoronerStatutory powerWhat the coroner requestsDelays in a time-sensitive process

Solicitors

Where a solicitor acting for the patient sends the patient's written consent to disclose the full record, the BMA advises treating the request in the same way as if the patient had made it directly[3]. That means the subject access rules apply: the one-month deadline, no fee in normal circumstances, and a check of the record for third-party information and anything that could cause serious harm. The fee position is covered in charging for copies of records.

Look closely at the consent form. It should name the patient, the solicitor and the purpose, be signed and dated recently, and say what may be disclosed. If the claim is about a single injury, a call to the solicitor agreeing a narrower date range saves you work and protects the patient. A solicitor acting for someone else, such as the other party in a dispute, needs a court order or the patient's own consent.

Insurers and employers

When an insurer or employer asks a doctor for a report on a patient, the Access to Medical Reports Act 1988 applies. If the patient has said they want to see the report before it goes, the doctor must not supply it until the patient has had access or 21 days have passed from the application without the patient arranging access[4]. The patient can ask for factual corrections and can refuse to let the report be sent.

  • Check the consent form says whether the patient wants to see the report first.
  • Answer the questions asked; do not attach the full record unless the patient's consent clearly extends to it.
  • Agree any fee with the requester before starting the report, and invoice the requester, not the patient.
  • If an insurer sends a subject access request in the patient's name to get the full record for underwriting, contact the patient to explain what will be released and offer a report instead.

Police

Police requests feel urgent and official, and that is where practices make mistakes. The Data Protection Act 2018 has an exemption for the prevention, investigation or detection of crime and the apprehension or prosecution of offenders, which applies to the extent that applying the normal rules would be likely to prejudice those purposes[5]. It allows you to disclose; it does not oblige you to.

You still owe the patient a duty of confidentiality. Ask for the request in writing on a force form, with the offence, why the information is needed and why consent is not being sought. A clinician or the Caldicott Guardian should weigh the public interest, for example where there is a serious crime or a risk of serious harm to others. A court order or warrant is different and must be complied with, though you can check its scope.

Never confirm by phone whether someone is registered at the practice. Take the caller's name, rank, force and collar number, call back through the force switchboard, and ask for the request in writing.

Government departments, councils and coroners

Requests from public bodies arrive on official forms and are easy to treat as automatic. Some are backed by a legal duty to provide information; many rely on the patient's consent, which the form should evidence. Read the form for the legal basis it cites and the consent it includes, and answer only the questions asked.

  • Benefit and pension assessments usually include the patient's consent and ask specific questions; answer those rather than sending the record.
  • Local authority safeguarding enquiries can justify sharing without consent where a person is at risk; involve your safeguarding lead and record the decision.
  • Coroners have legal powers to require information for an inquest; respond promptly and keep a copy of what was sent.
  • Requests from another health or care provider for a patient's care are a different matter, covered by the duty to share for individual care rather than this process.

If a form cites a statutory power you do not recognise, ask the sender to identify the provision and check it before you disclose. A short delay to confirm the legal basis is reasonable; disclosing on an assumption is not.

Preparing what you send

  • Read the relevant entries before release and remove information about other people unless it is clearly appropriate to include.
  • Check for entries a clinician should review, such as safeguarding notes or third-party reports.
  • Send by secure email or tracked post to the verified address, never to a new email address given only in the request.
  • Mark the covering letter with what was sent, the authority relied on and any limits on further use.
  • Tell the patient where appropriate, especially when the disclosure was made without their consent and telling them would not prejudice the purpose.

Example: a call from someone who says they are a solicitor

Example: reception at Mill Lane Surgery, a fictional practice, takes a call from a man who says he is a solicitor acting for a patient and needs her records by the end of the day for a hearing. He offers to email a consent form from a personal email address. The receptionist follows the practice script: she does not confirm the patient is registered, takes his name and firm, and explains that requests need a signed consent sent from the firm's official address.

Example: the records lead checks the firm on the regulator's register and calls its published number. The firm has no one of that name. The practice logs the attempted disclosure and tells the patient. The same script works for any phone line: if an AI employee such as Ava answers out of hours, it should take the caller's details and pass them to the records team, never confirm registration.

Keep a disclosure log

Every disclosure should be traceable. Record the requester, the authority relied on, who made the decision and why, what was sent, how it was sent and when. Add a note to the patient's record. If the patient later asks who has seen their information, or complains, the log is your evidence.

Patients care about this. In the government's public attitudes tracker, 85% of UK adults trusted the NHS to act in the public's best interest with data[6], but only 73% trusted it to use data to improve services[7]. A careless disclosure to a third party is the quickest way to lose that trust locally.

UK adults' trust in the NHS with dataPublic attitudes to data and AI tracker, Wave 4
UK adults' trust in the NHS with dataComparison. Trust the NHS to act in the public's best interest: 85%; Trust the NHS to use data to improve services: 73%.85%Trust the NHS to act in the public's bestinterestTrust the NHS to act in the public's best interest: 85%73%Trust the NHS to use data to improveservicesTrust the NHS to use data to improve services: 73%UK adults' trust in the NHS with dataComparison. Trust the NHS to act in the public's best interest: 85%; Trust the NHS to use data to improve services: 73%.85%Trust the NHS to act in the public'sbest interestTrust the NHS to act in the public's best interest: 85%73%Trust the NHS to use data to improveservicesTrust the NHS to use data to improve services: 73%

Source: GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology), 2024[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Trust the NHS to act in the public's best interest85%
Trust the NHS to use data to improve services73%

Related reading: how long to keep records, Cyber Essentials for practices, and the website forms that often receive these requests in cookie banners on practice websites.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to give the police a patient's records?

Not unless there is a court order, warrant or other legal requirement. The crime exemption allows disclosure where withholding would be likely to prejudice an investigation, but the decision is yours to make and record[5].

Can a solicitor have the full record with the patient's consent?

Yes, if the patient's signed consent covers the full record; treat it like the patient's own subject access request[3].

How long must we wait before sending an insurance report?

If the patient asked to see it first, until they have had access or 21 days have passed from the application without them arranging access[4].

Can we charge third parties?

For reports and other non-statutory work, a fee agreed in advance with the requester is normal. Subject access requests made with the patient's consent are generally free.

References

  1. GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2020). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. British Medical Association (2026). Access to health records (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1988). Access to Medical Reports Act 1988, section 4 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 2, paragraph 2 (crime and taxation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) (2024). Public attitudes to data and AI: Tracker survey (Wave 4) report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) (2024). Public attitudes to data and AI: Tracker survey (Wave 4) report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo