Appointments booking

Phone, video or face to face: matching slot to need

How GP practices can match phone, video and face-to-face appointments to patient need, offer a fair choice and record each patient's preference.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Start with the need, then the preference
  2. What each mode is good for
  3. A four-question route to the right mode
  4. Recording the preference so it sticks
  5. Scripts for offering a mode
  6. Patients for whom the phone fails
  7. Trust in the clinician holds up across modes
  8. How online contact is changing the mix
  9. Questions for your clinical team to agree
  10. Example: re-routing a week of requests
  11. Mistakes to avoid
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Decide the mode from the need first and the patient's preference second, then record the preference so nobody has to ask again.
  • Most GP appointments in England are still face to face, at 59.9% in the year to August 2026[1].
  • Phone and video work best for follow-ups, results and medication questions; examination, new lumps and safeguarding concerns need a room.
  • Some patients cannot use the phone or video reliably; flag them and give them a direct route.

Start with the need, then the preference

Every request has two questions behind it: what does the clinician need to do, and how does the patient want to be seen? When the answers agree, booking is easy. When they disagree, the clinical need should decide, but the patient should hear why and have their preference recorded.

NHS England's Modern General Practice Access model puts it this way: patients should know on the day how their request will be handled, and their preference for a call, visit or online message should be respected[2]. Respecting a preference does not mean always granting it. It means asking, explaining and writing it down.

Face to face remains the main mode. In the year to August 2026, 59.9% of GP appointments in England were delivered in person, not counting home visits[1]. The rest were phone, video, online or home visits.

How GP appointments were delivered, year to August 2026England. Face to face excludes home visits; other modes include phone, video, online and home visits.
How GP appointments were delivered, year to August 2026Donut chart. Face to face: 59.9%; All other modes: 40.1%.Face to face: 59.9%All other modes: 40.1%59.9% in person
  • Face to face 59.9%
  • All other modes 40.1%

Source: British Medical Association, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Face to face59.9%
All other modes40.1%

What each mode is good for

Appointment modes compared for common GP requests
ModeWorks well forPoor fit forCheck before booking
TelephoneResults, medication queries, follow-ups, sick notes, many mental health reviewsAnything needing examination; patients with hearing lossIs the number current? Can the patient talk privately at that time?
VideoRashes and visible problems, follow-ups where seeing the patient helps, carers joiningPatients without a smartphone or data; poor connectionsHas the patient joined a video call before? Is there a fallback number?
Face to faceExamination, new lumps, chest or abdominal pain, children under one, safeguarding concernsPatients who cannot travelAccess needs, interpreter, chaperone
Online messageAdmin, simple medication questions, sharing photos when requestedAnything urgent or complexResponse time stated to the patient
Home visitHousebound patients whose condition needs assessmentPatients who can attend with helpClinician review of the request first

The table is a starting point, not a rule. Your clinicians should agree which request types go where and review the list after a few months.

A four-question route to the right mode

  1. Is it urgent or does it sound serious?

    If yes, follow your urgent or red flag process first. Mode comes second to speed.

  2. Does the clinician need to examine or see something?

    Examination means face to face. Seeing a visible problem may be possible by video or photo if the clinician agrees.

  3. Can the patient use the mode reliably?

    Check the record for a communication flag. Hearing loss, limited English, cognitive impairment or no smartphone change the answer.

  4. What does the patient prefer?

    Ask, offer the choice where the need allows it and record the answer.

Recording the preference so it sticks

A preference recorded once saves a conversation every time the patient calls. Most clinical systems have fields or alerts for communication needs and contact preferences. Agree which field your practice uses and what wording goes in it, for example "Prefers face to face; hearing loss, avoid telephone" or "Happy with phone; works shifts, call after 2pm".

Make it visible where it matters: on the booking screen for reception and in the consultation view for clinicians. A preference hidden in a free-text note is not a preference anyone will see.

Review flags when circumstances change. A patient who preferred video during a period of shielding may now want to come in, and a new carer may change what works.

Scripts for offering a mode

  • When phone fits the need: "For a medication review, the doctor will usually call you. Is this the best number, and is there a time you can talk privately?"
  • When the patient wants face to face but the need is a result: "The doctor can give you this result by phone today, or I can book you in person next week. Which would you prefer?"
  • When the need is examination: "The doctor will need to examine you, so I have booked you in at the surgery on Tuesday at 9.10."
  • When the patient cannot use the phone well: "I have noted that phone calls are difficult for you, so we will book you in person or by video in future. Is that right?"

Offering a real choice is less common than it should be. In the 2026 GP Patient Survey, 56.9% of patients were offered a choice of time or day, and only 15.9% a choice of location[3]. Even where the mode is fixed by clinical need, a choice of time is usually possible.

Patients for whom the phone fails

Phone-first models work badly for some groups, and the practice should know who they are. ONS data show that adults renting from a council or another social landlord were markedly more likely to report difficulty contacting their GP practice than outright homeowners[4]. Access problems tend to cluster with other disadvantages.

  • People with hearing loss or who use British Sign Language.
  • Patients with limited English, who may manage in person with an interpreter but not on a phone line.
  • Shift workers and carers who cannot take a call at an unpredictable time.
  • People without private space at home, including some in shared housing or with controlling partners.
  • Patients with dementia or a learning disability, who may need a carer present.

For these patients, offer timed calls with a stated window, video with a carer joining, or face-to-face appointments by default. A safeguarding concern should always prompt the clinician to consider whether a phone call is safe.

Trust in the clinician holds up across modes

Patients largely trust the people they speak to. In 2026, 92.7% of patients said they had confidence and trust in the healthcare professional they saw or spoke to[5]. That trust is an asset for remote consultations: a clear explanation from the clinician of why a call is enough today, and what would mean coming in, is usually accepted.

Safety-netting is what makes remote modes work. Every phone or video consultation should end with clear advice on what to do if symptoms change, and the clinician should be ready to convert the call into a face-to-face appointment the same day.

How online contact is changing the mix

The way patients ask for care is shifting faster than the way they are seen. In 2026, 30.8% of patients said their last attempt to contact the practice was online, up from 16.8% in 2024[6]. An online request often arrives with enough detail for a clinician to choose the mode before anyone speaks to the patient, which is a chance to get the match right first time.

Use that chance deliberately. Add a question to your online form asking how the patient would prefer to be seen and whether there are times they cannot take a call. The clinician or navigator reviewing the request can then book the right mode in one step, and the preference flows into the record. Patients who request online and are then phoned at an inconvenient time are a common source of missed calls and repeat requests.

Questions for your clinical team to agree

Reception cannot match mode to need without a clear steer from clinicians. Put these questions on the agenda of a clinical meeting and record the answers in your care navigation guide.

  • Which request types should always be face to face, whatever the patient prefers? Most practices include new lumps, chest pain, abdominal pain and babies under one.
  • Which request types can default to phone, with face to face available on request? Results and medication reviews are the usual examples.
  • When is a photo acceptable instead of a visit, and how should patients send it securely?
  • Who can convert a phone appointment to face to face on the day, and how is the slot found?
  • How long should a patient wait for a call-back, and what should they be told about the time window?
  • How will you check that the mix is working, for example by counting conversions from phone to face to face each month?

Revisit the answers every six months. Staffing, premises and patient expectations change, and a guide that is never reviewed drifts away from what clinicians actually do.

Example: re-routing a week of requests

Example, fictional: a practice reviewed one week of 410 routine requests. Clinicians judged that 120 booked as face to face could have been handled by phone, mostly results and medication questions, and 18 booked as phone needed examination and were converted later, costing a second appointment each. The practice agreed a shortlist of request types for each mode, added it to the care navigation guide and asked reception to record the patient's preference on every booking. Four weeks later, conversions from phone to face to face had dropped and patients who preferred in-person care were still offered it for anything other than results.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Defaulting every request to phone because it is quicker to book, then converting many of them later.
  • Booking a phone call without confirming the number or a time the patient can talk.
  • Hiding the preference in a free-text note nobody reads.
  • Treating a patient's request for face to face as unreasonable rather than recording it and explaining the plan.
  • Forgetting the fallback: every video appointment needs a phone number in case the link fails.

Frequently asked questions

Can patients insist on a face-to-face GP appointment?

Patients can ask, and practices should record and respect their preference where possible. The clinician decides whether the need can be met remotely, and should explain the decision and how to come in if things change.

Who decides whether an appointment is by phone or in person?

Usually the clinician or a care navigator following rules agreed by the clinicians. Reception applies those rules and records the patient's preference.

Are telephone appointments as safe as face to face?

For many follow-ups, results and medication questions, yes, provided the clinician safety-nets and converts to face to face when needed. Anything requiring examination should be seen in person.

How should we record a patient's preferred appointment type?

Use one agreed field or alert in your clinical system, with short standard wording, and make sure it shows on the booking screen.

References

  1. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. NHS England and DHSC (2023). Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo