Key takeaways
- The duty to share for individual care is as important as the duty to protect confidentiality; not sharing can harm patients too.
- In England there is a statutory duty to share information for a patient's care where it is likely to help and in their best interests, unless they object.
- Sharing for direct care relies on implied consent and the patient's reasonable expectations, not on written consent forms.
- The national data opt-out is about research and planning, not a patient's own care.
Two duties, equally weighted
Practices are trained to protect confidentiality, and sometimes that instinct leads them to withhold information another clinician needs. The Caldicott Principles were revised to correct exactly that: principle 7 says the duty to share information for individual care is as important as the duty to protect patient confidentiality[1]. A hospital doctor who does not know about a patient's allergies, or a district nurse who has not been told about a new medicine, is a risk to the patient.
The law backs this up. Section 251B of the Health and Social Care Act 2012, the duty to share information, applies where the person holding the information considers that disclosure is likely to facilitate the provision of health services or adult social care to the individual, and is in the individual's best interests[2]. The duty does not apply where the person reasonably considers that the individual objects, or would be likely to object[2].
What direct care means
Direct care, or individual care, means activities that contribute to the care of an individual patient: diagnosis, treatment, prevention, rehabilitation and the local audit of that care, carried out by people with a legitimate relationship with the patient. It does not include research, commissioning, insurance, employment or most marketing, even when the requester is a health organisation.
| Requester | Direct care? | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital team treating the patient | Yes | Implied consent; duty to share |
| Community nursing, physiotherapy or mental health team | Yes | Implied consent; duty to share |
| Community pharmacy dispensing or reviewing medicines | Yes | Implied consent |
| Adult social care team arranging the patient's care | Yes | Implied consent; duty to share for adult social care |
| Private specialist the patient has been referred to | Yes | Implied consent |
| Care home caring for the patient | Yes, for their care | Implied consent; share what is needed |
| Researcher, even within the NHS | No | Consent, approved exemption or anonymised data |
| Insurer or employer | No | Explicit consent, usually through a report |
| Commissioner planning services | No | Usually anonymised or with a legal basis |
Consent: implied, not written
Two legal frameworks apply to every disclosure. Under UK GDPR, sharing for direct care does not rely on consent: NHS providers rely on public task and private providers on contract or legitimate interests, with the health care condition for special category data[3]. Under the common law duty of confidentiality, sharing for direct care can rely on implied consent, provided the patient would reasonably expect it and has been told how their information is used.
That is why the eighth Caldicott Principle, inform patients and service users about how their confidential information is used[1], matters so much. A patient who knows that their GP shares information with the hospital, pharmacy and community teams caring for them has a reasonable expectation that it will happen. A clear privacy notice, waiting-room information and a word from the clinician at the point of referral make implied consent real.
Do not ask patients to sign consent forms for routine direct care sharing. It creates the false impression that consent is the legal basis, and implies that sharing must stop if a form is missing.
When a patient objects
Patients can object to particular disclosures, and their objection should normally be respected even when sharing would help. Explore the reasons, explain the possible consequences for their care in plain terms, and record the conversation and the decision. Where the patient lacks capacity, a best-interests decision applies. In rare cases, such as a serious risk of harm to others, a disclosure may be justified in the public interest despite an objection; that decision belongs with a senior clinician or the Caldicott Guardian.
The national data opt-out is different. It is a patient's choice about whether their confidential information is used for research and planning[4]. It does not stop sharing for the patient's own care, and staff should not tell patients otherwise.
Shared care records and agreements
Most areas of England now have shared care records that let hospitals, practices, community services and social care see key information about a patient. Practices take part through local agreements. The agreement does not create the legal basis for sharing, which comes from the law above, but it sets out the rules: who can access what, how access is audited, how patients are told, and how objections are handled.
- Know which shared record your practice contributes to and what it shows.
- Make sure your privacy notice names it and explains how patients can ask questions or object.
- Check who in partner organisations can view your patients' data, and how access is audited.
- Record patient objections in a way the shared record respects.
- Review the agreement when it is renewed or when the shared record adds new data.
Answering a request from another provider
Confirm who is asking
Use a known contact route: secure email to a verified address, a call back to the provider's switchboard, or the shared record itself.
Confirm the care relationship
Is the patient under their care now, or about to be? If not, it is not direct care.
Share what is relevant
Send the information needed for the care in question, such as medications, allergies, recent results and relevant history, not the whole record by default.
Check for objections
Look for a recorded objection or a sensitive area the patient has asked to restrict, and handle those carefully.
Send securely and record it
Use secure email or the clinical system's messaging, and note in the record what was shared, with whom and why.
Especially sensitive information
Some information needs extra thought even within direct care: sexual health, gender identity, fertility treatment, termination of pregnancy, some mental health history and safeguarding records. Patients may reasonably expect these to be shared more narrowly. Many clinical systems allow entries to be marked as sensitive or kept from the shared record; use those controls where the patient wants them, explain clearly what other clinicians will and will not see, and record the conversation so colleagues understand why an entry is restricted. The test stays the same, what does this clinician need for this patient's care, but the answer is often narrower.
Mistakes that cause harm in both directions
- Refusing to share medication or allergy information with a hospital because no consent form is on file.
- Sending the full record when the request was for a summary, including third-party and sensitive information.
- Treating a request from an insurer or employer as if it were direct care.
- Telling a patient that opting out of research also stops sharing with their hospital team.
- Forgetting to record what was shared, so the practice cannot answer the patient's questions later.
Example: a private clinic and the GP
Example: a patient at Maple Tree Clinic, a fictional private menopause clinic, starts a new medicine. The clinician tells her the clinic will write to her GP so her NHS record stays accurate and her GP knows what she is taking. The patient asks that the letter leave out a past mental health episode she discussed. The clinician explains that the letter will include the medicine and relevant monitoring, records her request, and leaves out the history that is not needed for the GP's care.
Example: the GP practice receives the letter, codes the medicine and adds it to the record, so the next prescriber sees it. Both organisations have shared what was needed for the patient's care, respected her wishes about the rest, and recorded what happened.
Trust is the point
Sharing well depends on public trust, which is high but not unconditional. In the government's public attitudes tracker, 85% of UK adults trusted the NHS to act in the public's best interest with data[5]. That trust is earned by sharing when it helps patients, explaining what happens, and respecting objections.
- Trust the NHS with data 85%
Source: GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology), 2024[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Trust the NHS with data | 85% |
Related reading: clear desk and screen rules, the IG lead's role, data protection training and when a patient complains to the regulator.
Frequently asked questions
Do we need consent to share records with the hospital?
Not written consent. Sharing for direct care relies on implied consent under the common law and on public task or another basis under UK GDPR, and there is a statutory duty to share where it helps care[2].
Can a patient stop us sharing with other providers?
They can object, and the objection should normally be respected after explaining the consequences. The duty to share does not apply where the patient objects[2].
Does the national data opt-out stop sharing for care?
No. It covers the use of confidential information for research and planning[4].
Should we send the whole record?
Usually not. Send what is relevant to the care in question, in line with the minimum-necessary principle[1].
References
GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2020). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2012). Health and Social Care Act 2012, section 251B: Duty to share information (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS (nhs.uk) (2026). Your NHS data matters (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) (2024). Public attitudes to data and AI: Tracker survey (Wave 4) report (opens in a new tab) ↑