Appointments booking

Same-day versus pre-bookable slots: finding the balance

How GP practices can use their own demand data to set the mix of same-day and pre-bookable appointments, with warning signs and a worked calculation.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. The trade-off
  2. What patients are telling you
  3. Signs your mix is wrong
  4. Calculate your own mix
  5. Continuity needs pre-bookable time
  6. Same-day does not have to mean a GP
  7. Measure whether the mix is working
  8. Tell patients what will happen
  9. Adjust for the season and the week
  10. Using online booking to ease the pressure
  11. Where this fits
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • There is no correct national ratio; nationally 45% of GP appointments are booked for the same day, but your mix should come from your own demand and outcomes.
  • Too little same-day capacity shows up as 8am queues and patients sent to NHS 111; too little pre-bookable capacity shows up as missed reviews and frustrated working patients.
  • Working-age patients are the least satisfied with making appointments, so pre-bookable and online-bookable slots matter for them.
  • Calculate the mix from four to twelve weeks of data, then adjust by day of week and season.
  • Whatever the mix, patients should know on the day how their request will be handled.

The trade-off

Every GP template balances two kinds of need. Same-day slots protect access for people who are unwell now. Pre-bookable slots protect continuity, planned reviews and patients who need to arrange time off work, childcare or transport. Lean too far either way and one group loses out. The aim is a mix where most patients get the type of appointment their need calls for, at a time they can attend.

Nationally, 45% of GP appointments in England were booked for the same day in the year to August 2026, and 81% were booked to take place within two weeks[1]. That is a description, not a target. A practice with a young, mobile population may run a higher same-day share; one with many older patients with long-term conditions may need more planned capacity.

What patients are telling you

Public satisfaction with GP waiting times is low. Only 27% of people were satisfied with waiting times for GP appointments in 2025[2], and making it easier to get a GP appointment was the joint top NHS priority for the public, chosen by 46%[3]. The dissatisfaction is not even across ages. In 2024, 65% of under-65s were dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, compared with 52% of over-65s[4].

Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024
Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024Comparison. Under 65: 65%; 65 and over: 52%.65%Under 65Under 65: 65%52%65 and over65 and over: 52%Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024Comparison. Under 65: 65%; 65 and over: 52%.65%Under 65Under 65: 65%52%65 and over65 and over: 52%

Source: Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund, 2024[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Under 6565%
65 and over52%

The age gap is a clue. People of working age are more likely to find an 8am same-day scramble impossible to fit around work, and more likely to want to book a specific time in advance or online. A template that is almost all same-day can serve urgent need well and still leave this group feeling shut out.

Signs your mix is wrong

Warning signs that the same-day and pre-bookable mix needs to change, and what to try.
What you seeWhat it suggestsAdjustment to test
Same-day slots gone by 8.30am; callers told to ring tomorrowToo little same-day capacity, or released all at onceAdd same-day capacity on peak days; release in waves
Routine wait for a GP longer than three weeksToo little pre-bookable capacityConvert some same-day slots on quieter days to pre-bookable
Same-day slots unfilled by mid-afternoonToo much same-day capacity on that dayMove capacity to pre-bookable or reviews
High DNA rate for slots booked weeks aheadBooking horizon too longShorten the horizon or add a second reminder
Many same-day requests are really routinePatients use same-day because routine is unavailableOpen more routine slots, including online
Long-term condition reviews slippingPlanned care being squeezedRing-fence nurse and pharmacist review sessions

Calculate your own mix

  1. Count requests by urgency

    For four to twelve weeks, classify every request (phone, online, walk-in) as needing care today, within a few days, or routine. Care navigation or triage outcomes give you this if they are coded.

  2. Count by day of week

    Average each category for each weekday. Mondays and days after bank holidays are usually much higher for 'today' requests.

  3. Add planned work

    Add recalls, reviews, follow-ups and procedures already due, which are almost all pre-bookable.

  4. Convert to slots

    Divide each category by the number of patients a slot type can serve, allowing for the share that can be handled by phone, online or another role.

  5. Set the split per day

    The result gives a same-day and pre-bookable share for each weekday. Expect Monday to be very different from Thursday.

  6. Test and review

    Run the new split for four to six weeks and check the warning signs above before adjusting again.

Example (fictional): over eight weeks, a practice receives an average of 180 requests on Mondays and 110 on Thursdays. On Mondays, 60% need care that day; on Thursdays, 45%. With 160 clinical slots each day, it sets Monday at 96 same-day and 64 pre-bookable, and Thursday at 50 same-day and 110 pre-bookable, using the extra Thursday capacity for reviews and routine GP appointments booked up to two weeks ahead.

Continuity needs pre-bookable time

Patients with complex needs, frailty, mental illness or a recent cancer diagnosis often do best seeing the same clinician. That rarely happens through a same-day system, where patients get whoever is free. Give each GP a small number of pre-bookable slots each week reserved for their own continuity patients, bookable by the clinician or by reception on the clinician's instruction. Track how often those patients see their named clinician and protect the slots when the template is under pressure.

A simple way to start is to flag the patients each GP considers their continuity list, perhaps twenty to forty per clinician, and give reception permission to book those patients into the reserved slots without triage. Review the list every six months. Patients who no longer need continuity come off; new diagnoses and recent bereavements go on.

Same-day does not have to mean a GP

Much of the pressure on same-day capacity comes from treating 'today' as 'a GP today'. Many same-day needs can be met safely by an advanced nurse practitioner, a clinical pharmacist, a paramedic, a first-contact physiotherapist or a community pharmacy consultation. If your care navigators can route a sore throat to the pharmacy, a back strain to the physiotherapist and a medication query to the pharmacist, GP same-day slots stay free for the patients who need a GP's judgement.

Write that routing into a short care navigation guide with clear red flags, agreed by the clinical team, and review it each quarter with examples of requests that were routed well and badly. The same guide should say which requests should be offered a pre-bookable slot instead, so routine needs stop leaking into same-day capacity.

Measure whether the mix is working

Pick a handful of measures and look at them monthly, side by side, so that a change in one is not hiding a problem in another.

  • Time of day when same-day capacity runs out, by weekday.
  • Number of patients told to call back or redirected to NHS 111 because no same-day slot was left.
  • Median wait for a routine GP appointment and for a nurse review.
  • DNA rate for pre-bookable slots by lead time.
  • Share of continuity patients seen by their named clinician.
  • Patient feedback on getting through and on waiting times, from your own surveys or the Friends and Family Test.

If same-day capacity now lasts until early afternoon, routine waits are stable and reviews are on track, the mix is right for now. If any of these slips for two months running, revisit the calculation.

Tell patients what will happen

Under the Modern General Practice Access approach, patients should know on the day how their request will be handled, while their preference for a call, visit or online message is respected[5]. That principle applies whichever mix you choose. A patient told at 9am that a clinician will call before noon, or that a routine appointment is booked for next Tuesday, is far less likely to ring again or go elsewhere.

Patients are more forgiving of waits when the wait is clear. Nationally, 69.3% said the time they waited for their GP appointment was about right in 2026[6], which suggests that a reasonable, predictable wait for routine care is acceptable to most people, provided urgent need is met the same day.

Adjust for the season and the week

  • Winter: shift capacity towards same-day from November, when respiratory illness rises, and move routine reviews earlier in the autumn.
  • School holidays: expect fewer children's same-day requests and more working parents wanting pre-bookable slots.
  • Bank holidays: treat the following day as a Monday, with extra same-day capacity.
  • QOF year end: protect review capacity in the first quarter of the year so recall work does not crowd out routine appointments.

Using online booking to ease the pressure

Opening a share of pre-bookable slots online gives working-age patients a route that does not depend on the phone. It also moves some routine demand out of the morning peak. Start with appointment types that are low risk to self-book, such as HCA blood tests, smears and some nurse reviews, and keep same-day clinical slots behind triage. Our guide to offering online booking without losing control covers which slots to open and how to prevent misuse.

Where this fits

The mix is one part of the template. For slot types and release rules, see designing your appointment book template; for staggering releases through the day, see embargoed appointments; and for handling patients who arrive after their slot, see late arrivals.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of GP appointments should be same-day?

There is no set figure. Nationally about 45% are booked for the same day, but the right share for your practice depends on your demand by day of week, your population and how much planned care you deliver.

Why can't I book a GP appointment in advance?

Some practices run mainly same-day systems to protect urgent access. Many now also offer pre-bookable and online-bookable routine appointments; ask your practice how routine appointments are booked.

How often should a practice review its same-day and routine mix?

Every quarter, and before winter. Check whether same-day slots run out early, whether routine waits are growing and whether reviews are slipping.

References

  1. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2024). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2024: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. NHS England and DHSC (2023). Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo