Appointments booking

Can a GP practice remove patients for missed appointments?

What the GMS regulations allow when removing a patient for repeated DNAs in England, the warning and records required, and when removal is unwise.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What the regulations require
  3. The process, step by step
  4. When removal is lawful but unwise
  5. Why removal rarely fixes the problem
  6. Alternatives that keep the patient registered
  7. A script for the conversation
  8. Equality and fairness checks
  9. Example: a removal that was avoided
  10. What to keep on file
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • In England a practice can ask NHS England to remove a patient for repeated DNAs, but only on reasonable grounds unrelated to protected characteristics, medical condition or social class.
  • A warning explaining the risk and the reasons must normally have been given in the 12 months before the request, and both the warning and the removal must be recorded in writing.
  • The patient must be told the specific reasons in writing; removal then takes effect on the eighth day after NHS England receives notice or on registration elsewhere, if sooner.
  • Removal is lawful but unwise when the DNAs point to illness, safeguarding, caring duties or a booking system that does not work for the patient.
  • With fewer practices and bigger lists, removal moves the problem rather than solving it; fix access first.

The short answer

Yes, but it should be rare, and the process is set out in law. Under the General Medical Services contract regulations in England, a practice may ask NHS England to remove a patient from its list where it has reasonable grounds for doing so, and those grounds must not relate to the person's age, appearance, disability or medical condition, gender, race, religion, sexual orientation or social class, among other characteristics[1]. Repeated missed appointments can count as reasonable grounds. The patient's illness cannot.

PMS and APMS agreements generally mirror the GMS wording, but check your own contract. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own regulations, so practices there should read their national rules rather than relying on the English text.

What the regulations require

  • A warning: within the 12 months before the removal request, the practice must have warned the patient that they are at risk of removal and explained why[1].
  • Exceptions to the warning: none is needed where the practice reasonably believes a warning would harm the person's physical or mental health, would put staff or others at risk, or is otherwise not reasonable or practical[1].
  • A written record of the warning: the date and the reasons, or the reason no warning was given.
  • Written notice to NHS England that the practice wants the patient removed.
  • Written notice to the patient of the specific reasons, unless the reason is an irrevocable breakdown in the relationship and a more specific explanation would be inappropriate.
  • A written record of the removal, its reason and the circumstances, available to NHS England on request.

The removal then takes effect on whichever comes first: the date NHS England is told the patient has registered elsewhere, or the eighth day after NHS England receives the practice's notice. If the practice is treating the patient at intervals of less than seven days, the date moves back until that treatment is no longer needed[1].

The process, step by step

  1. Clinical review first

    A GP or clinical lead reads the record and the DNA history and confirms there is no clinical, safeguarding or capacity explanation. Write down what was checked.

  2. Support offered

    Record what the practice tried: different times, different reminder channels, a carer contact, a conversation. Without this, a removal is hard to defend.

  3. Warning letter

    Send a warning that states the risk of removal, the specific reasons and what would avoid it, and keep a dated copy. The 12-month clock starts here.

  4. Partners' decision

    If the pattern continues, the partners decide at a minuted meeting. One person should not make this call alone.

  5. Notices

    Send written notice to NHS England through your local primary care contracting route and a letter to the patient giving the specific reasons and how to register elsewhere.

  6. Hand-over care

    Keep providing care until the removal date, especially any treatment at short intervals, and make sure repeat prescriptions do not lapse.

When removal is lawful but unwise

Removal decision guide: most DNA patterns call for a different route before removal is considered.
SituationRemoval appropriate?Better route
DNAs started after a new diagnosis of depressionNo: grounds would relate to a medical conditionClinician contact, flexible booking, mental health support
Missed child immunisationsNoRecord 'was not brought', safeguarding review, health visitor contact
Patient works shifts and cannot answer the 8am phone lineRarelyOnline booking, evening or Saturday slots, reminder the night before
Patient never receives letters: no fixed addressNoText or email contact, care-of address, link worker
Repeated DNAs plus abusive behaviour at the deskPossibly, following warningsBehaviour agreement first; separate violence procedure if there is a threat
Repeated DNAs, support offered and refused, warning givenPossiblyPartners' decision with full records

The common thread is that missed appointments are often a symptom. A patient who misses a mental health review or a child's vaccinations may be the person who most needs to stay registered. Our guide to writing a fair DNA policy sets out the exceptions to build in before removal is ever discussed.

Why removal rarely fixes the problem

Removal moves a patient; it does not create capacity. Since 2015, 1,485 GP practices in England have closed or merged, leaving 6,138[2], and the average full-time GP now looks after 2,143 patients[3]. A removed patient is likely to register at a neighbouring practice that is just as stretched, or to be allocated straight back to an over-subscribed list.

GP practices in England2015 figure derived from 6,138 practices plus 1,485 closures and mergers
GP practices in EnglandColumn chart. 2015: 7,623; September 2026: 6,138.02,0004,0006,0008,0002015: 7,6237,6232015September 2026: 6,1386,138September 2026GP practices in EnglandColumn chart. 2015: 7,623; September 2026: 6,138.02,0004,0006,0008,0002015: 7,6237,6232015September 2026: 6,1386,138September 2026

Source: British Medical Association, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
20157,623
September 20266,138

Scale matters too. With around 1.3 million appointments missed or unattended in a single month[4], no practice can remove its way to a lower DNA rate. The patients who repeatedly miss appointments are a small group; the bulk of DNAs come from ordinary patients who forgot, felt better or could not get through to cancel. Reminders, easy cancellation and better-timed slots shift those numbers far more.

Alternatives that keep the patient registered

Most practices that reach the point of considering removal have not yet tried the options in between. Each of these is cheaper than processing a removal, and each leaves a record that shows the practice acted reasonably.

  • Book-on-the-day only: for a set period, the patient books same-day or next-day slots rather than appointments weeks ahead, which removes most of the forgetting.
  • Confirm-to-keep: the patient must reply to a reminder 48 hours before, or the slot is released to the cancellation list and the patient is offered another.
  • Named contact: with consent, a relative or carer receives the reminders as well.
  • Telephone first: the clinician calls at the booked time and books a face-to-face slot only if it is needed.
  • A written attendance agreement, reviewed after three months, that sets out what both sides will do.

A script for the conversation

When a clinician or the practice manager speaks to the patient before any warning, the aim is to find the cause, not to deliver a reprimand. A short structure helps:

  1. Open with the facts: 'Our records show you have not been able to attend four appointments since March.'
  2. Ask, then listen: 'Is anything making it hard to get here or to let us know?'
  3. Offer two concrete changes, such as a different time of day or a reminder to a carer.
  4. Agree what happens next and when you will review it.
  5. Write a short note in the record the same day, including what was offered and agreed.

If the conversation reveals a clinical or safeguarding issue, the removal question stops there and the case passes to the right clinician.

Equality and fairness checks

Before any removal, check whether your DNA patterns fall unevenly. Adults renting from a council were 46% more likely, and those renting from other social landlords 51% more likely, than outright homeowners to report difficulty contacting their GP practice[5]. If your process relies on phone lines and letters, those same patients will find it harder to cancel, and the regulations do not allow grounds that relate to social class[1].

  • Compare the profile of patients warned in the last year with your list profile by age, deprivation and ethnicity.
  • Check whether the patient was offered a channel they can actually use.
  • Confirm that interpreters were offered where English is not the first language.
  • Ask your safeguarding lead to see every proposed removal.

Example: a removal that was avoided

Example (fictional): a practice proposes removing Ms K after five DNAs in ten months. The clinical review shows four were early-morning blood tests and one a smear booked by text she says she never saw. She cares for her mother in the mornings. The practice switches her to afternoon phlebotomy, adds her daughter as a contact for reminders and offers the smear at the Saturday hub. She attends the next two. The warning letter is never sent, and the review notes record why.

What to keep on file

  • The DNA history with dates and appointment types.
  • The clinical review note and who completed it.
  • Support offered and the patient's responses.
  • The warning letter, the date sent and the channel, or the reason no warning was given.
  • The minuted partners' decision.
  • Copies of the notices to NHS England and to the patient.

If a patient complains, the ombudsman will ask what you warned, when and why. A dated letter and a minuted decision answer that in one page; memory does not.

Frequently asked questions

How many missed appointments before a GP can remove you?

The regulations do not set a number. The practice needs reasonable grounds, must normally have warned the patient and explained the reasons within the previous 12 months, and must record its decision.

Does the practice have to tell the patient why they were removed?

Yes. The patient must be given the specific reasons in writing, unless the reason is a breakdown in the relationship and a more detailed explanation would be inappropriate.

Can a whole family be removed because one member missed appointments?

Family members are separate patients with their own registration. Removing relatives who have done nothing themselves is very hard to justify, and each person's record should be reviewed on its own facts.

Can a removed patient re-register later?

A practice may refuse an application from someone it previously removed, but it must give the reason in writing. Many practices agree to reconsider after a period, which is worth stating in the removal letter.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, Schedule 3, paragraph 24: removal from the list at the request of the contractor (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Wessex Local Medical Committees (from NHS appointments data) (2026). Appointment Overview January 2026 (national) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo