Key takeaways
- Subscriptions give predictable income but transfer demand risk to the clinic; pay-per-visit does the reverse.
- Capacity planning decides whether a subscription works: price the plan on expected visits per member, not on hope.
- New subscription contract rules in the DMCC Act 2024 are still prospective, but design for them now[1].
- An NHS GMS practice cannot charge its own patients for NHS services[2], so subscriptions are a private-only model.
Why the question keeps coming up
Public satisfaction with GP services is low: 35% of people said they were satisfied in 2025 and 45% were dissatisfied[3]. At the same time, 71% of people would consider private healthcare if they needed treatment[4]. Private GP services have grown in that gap, and many now ask whether to sell a membership rather than single appointments.
Source: Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund, 2025[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Satisfied | 35% |
| Dissatisfied | 45% |
The appeal is clear: patients who join feel they have a doctor on hand, and the clinic gets monthly income. The risk is just as clear: if members use more appointments than the price assumed, the clinic loses money or access gets worse for everyone.
The two models side by side
| Factor | Subscription | Pay-per-visit |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Predictable, recurring | Varies with demand and season |
| Demand risk | Carried by the clinic | Carried by the patient |
| Patient behaviour | Uses more care, including minor issues | Uses care when the need feels worth the fee |
| Capacity | Must be reserved for members | Sold to whoever books |
| Cash flow | Steady, collected in advance | Lumpy, collected at booking |
| Admin | Billing, renewals, cancellations, reminders | Payment at booking |
| Legal duties | Subscription contract rules once commenced | Standard consumer rules |
| Best for | Families, people with long-term conditions, employers | Occasional users, one-off needs |
Do the capacity maths first
A subscription only works if the price covers the appointments members actually use, plus the admin, and still leaves capacity for same-day needs. Start from your clinicians' sessions, not from a competitor's headline price.
Count your bookable slots
Work out the appointment slots available per year after leave, training, admin and results time.
Estimate use per member
Use your own pay-per-visit data for similar patients. Assume members will book more often than pay-per-visit patients, because the marginal cost to them is zero.
Set a member cap
Divide slots reserved for members by expected visits per member. Do not sell beyond that number.
Price to cover the cost
Cost per slot multiplied by expected visits, plus billing and admin, plus a margin for heavy users.
Decide what is outside the plan
Tests, prescriptions, referrals letters, home visits and out-of-hours calls are often charged separately. Say so clearly.
Review every quarter
Compare actual use with your assumption and adjust the cap or the price.
Example: a fictional clinic in Oxford has two GPs offering 6,000 member slots a year. Its pay-per-visit patients book three times a year on average, and it assumes members will book five times. That supports a cap of 1,200 members. When it reached 1,000 members, it saw the average climbing towards six and paused new sales while it added a session.
What members actually value
People who choose private care most often say it is because booking is easier, cited by 28%[4]. Members of a subscription are buying access more than appointments: the ability to get through quickly, see the same doctor and message the clinic without waiting on hold. Design the plan around those, and be specific about them.
- A stated response time for messages and for same-day requests.
- A named doctor, with cover arrangements when they are away.
- Appointment lengths long enough to deal with more than one issue.
- Online booking that shows real availability rather than a request form.
If you cannot meet a promised response time during a busy week, members notice faster than any other group. Promise what you can keep in your worst month, not your best.
Fairness and who joins
Subscriptions tend to attract people who expect to use care often. That is not a problem if the price reflects it, but it can turn into one if the clinic also sees pay-per-visit patients. Members expect priority, and pay-per-visit patients can find the diary full. Decide in advance how many slots are protected for each group.
- Publish what members get: response times, appointment length, channels.
- Protect same-day slots for urgent needs, whoever the patient is.
- Do not exclude people for having long-term conditions unless the plan cannot safely support them, and explain why.
- Avoid sign-up incentives that pressure people into long commitments.
Subscriptions are a private-only model
An NHS GP contractor must not demand or accept a fee from its own patients for treatment, apart from specific exceptions[2]. A private GP subscription is therefore something offered by a private service to its private patients. Practices that hold an NHS contract and also want to offer private care need careful legal advice on how the two are kept separate.
Contract terms and the coming subscription rules
Part 4, Chapter 2 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 sets out new rules for subscription contracts, but most of it is still marked as prospective, not yet in force[1]. When commenced, traders will need to give key pre-contract information, send reminder notices before renewals, offer 14-day cooling-off periods at the start and at renewal, and make it easy to cancel, including online for online contracts[1]. Building these features now avoids a rushed change later and is good practice anyway.
Existing law already applies. A term that causes a significant imbalance in rights to the patient's detriment, contrary to good faith, is unfair and not binding[5]. Long minimum terms, automatic renewal at a higher price without notice, or cancellation only by post are the kind of terms that attract challenge.
- Plain-English summary of what is included and excluded on the sign-up page.
- Renewal date and price shown in the account and in a reminder before each renewal.
- Cancellation online in the same number of steps as sign-up.
- A clear policy on what happens to booked appointments when a member cancels.
Billing, failed payments and changes
Subscriptions create admin that pay-per-visit does not. Card payments fail, members move house, and some want to pause during a long trip abroad. Decide your rules before launch and write them into the terms: how many attempts you make to collect a failed payment, when access is paused, and whether pauses are allowed.
If you need to change the price or the benefits, give members clear notice in writing, explain what changes and when, and let them leave without penalty if they do not accept the change. A price rise slipped into a renewal without notice is the fastest way to lose trust and invite a complaint.
Measuring whether it works
- Average appointments per member per quarter, compared with the assumption in your price.
- Share of members using more than twice the average, and what they use.
- Response times against the published promise.
- Cancellation rate and the reasons members give when they leave.
- Waiting time for pay-per-visit patients, so the model does not squeeze them out.
Hybrid models that reduce the risk
Many clinics settle on a hybrid. A small annual membership gives priority booking and messaging, with appointments charged at a reduced rate. Another option is a plan with a fixed number of appointments per year and pay-per-visit after that. Hybrids keep a link between use and payment, which limits heavy-use risk while still rewarding loyalty. Corporate plans, where an employer pays for staff, are another route to predictable income with demand that is easier to forecast.
Launching without overselling
Start small. Offer the plan to a limited number of existing patients first, with a clear review date, and tell them you are testing it. Collect use data for at least two quarters before opening it more widely. That gives you real numbers for the capacity model and lets you adjust benefits before many people depend on them.
Train reception on how to explain the plan in under a minute, including what it does not cover. Most complaints about memberships come from a mismatch between what someone thought they had bought and what the terms say.
Decision criteria
- Choose subscription if you have spare clinician capacity, good data on use, and a patient base that values continuity.
- Choose pay-per-visit if capacity is tight, demand is mostly one-off, or you lack billing systems for renewals and cancellations.
- Choose a hybrid if you want recurring income but cannot absorb the risk of heavy users.
- Whatever you choose, show the total price and what is included, because satisfied self-pay patients, 86% of whom rate private care as value for money, stay when expectations are met[4].
Frequently asked questions
Is a subscription private GP model profitable?
It can be, if the price is based on the appointments members actually use and the clinic caps membership to its capacity. Track use per member every quarter.
Do the new subscription contract rules apply yet?
Most of the DMCC Act 2024 subscription chapter is still prospective, not yet in force[1]. Existing unfair terms rules already apply[5].
Can an NHS practice sell a membership to its own patients?
An NHS GMS contractor must not charge its own patients for treatment except in listed cases[2], so a subscription is a private-only model.
What should a private GP membership include?
State appointment allowances, response times, channels and what costs extra, such as tests, referrals and prescriptions.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4, Chapter 2: subscription contracts (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, regulation 24: fees and charges (opens in a new tab) ↑
Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑
Independent Healthcare Providers Network (IHPN) (2026). Support for using private healthcare now found across the political spectrum, new report shows (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 62: requirement for contract terms and notices to be fair (opens in a new tab) ↑