Marketing reputation

Handling a reputation crisis in local media

What a GP surgery, dental practice or clinic should do when a complaint reaches the local paper: holding statements, confidentiality and staff briefing.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What a crisis looks like for a practice
  2. Prepare before anything happens
  3. The first hour
  4. Holding statements for common situations
  5. What you cannot say
  6. Briefing the team
  7. Talking to the journalist
  8. Reviews and social media during the storm
  9. After the story moves on
  10. Example: a phone queue story
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • In the first hour, decide who speaks, issue a short holding statement and brief every member of staff.
  • Never confirm that someone is a patient or discuss their care in public, even if they have spoken to the press themselves[1][2].
  • Public mood is difficult: only 35% were satisfied with GP services and 22% with NHS dentistry in 2025[3][4], so stories land on fertile ground.
  • Focus statements on what the practice is doing, how patients can raise concerns and what has changed.

What a crisis looks like for a practice

Most practices never face a national scandal. They do face the local version: a patient's complaint shared thousands of times on a community Facebook group, a reporter calling about a closed list or a long phone queue, a story about a practice merger or closure, a data breach, a critical inspection report, or a staff member filmed being rude. Any of these can bring a sudden spike of calls, angry reviews and worried patients.

The public backdrop makes these stories easy to tell. In the 2025 British Social Attitudes survey, 35% of people were satisfied with GP services and 45% dissatisfied[3]. Only 22% were satisfied with NHS dentistry, while 54% were dissatisfied[4]. A single story about a practice can feel like confirmation of what readers already believe, which is why the response needs to be calm, quick and consistent.

Public satisfaction with GP services and NHS dentistry, 2025British Social Attitudes survey, Great Britain
Public satisfaction with GP services and NHS dentistry, 2025Column chart. GP services: Satisfied 35%, Dissatisfied 45%; NHS dentistry: Satisfied 22%, Dissatisfied 54%.0%20%40%60%GP services · Satisfied: 35%35%GP services · Dissatisfied: 45%45%GP servicesNHS dentistry · Satisfied: 22%22%NHS dentistry · Dissatisfied: 54%54%NHS dentistryPublic satisfaction with GP services and NHS dentistry, 2025Column chart. GP services: Satisfied 35%, Dissatisfied 45%; NHS dentistry: Satisfied 22%, Dissatisfied 54%.0%20%40%60%GP services · Satisfied: 35%35%GP services · Dissatisfied: 45%45%GP servicesNHS dentistry · Satisfied: 22%22%NHS dentistry · Dissatisfied: 54%54%NHS dentistry
  • Satisfied
  • Dissatisfied

Source: Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemSatisfiedDissatisfied
GP services35%45%
NHS dentistry22%54%

Prepare before anything happens

The practices that handle a story well have usually done a little preparation on a quiet day. Half an hour at a team meeting each year is enough to put the basics in place:

  • A one-page crisis plan naming the spokesperson, the deputy and who covers social media and reviews.
  • Contact details for your defence organisation or indemnifier, commissioner, data protection lead and IT supplier, kept somewhere accessible out of hours.
  • Draft holding statements for the situations most likely to affect you, agreed in advance so you only need to adjust them.
  • Access to every social media account and review profile, with passwords held by more than one person.
  • A short reception script for media calls and for patients asking about a story.
  • A habit of checking local community groups and reviews weekly, so you hear about problems before a journalist does.

Rehearse once. Ask a colleague to play a reporter calling at 4pm on a Friday and see how the call is handled. The gaps show up quickly.

The first hour

  1. Name one spokesperson

    Usually the practice manager or a partner. Everyone else directs enquiries to them. Agree a deputy in case they are unavailable.

  2. Establish the facts internally

    What happened, when, who was involved and what is already public. Do not speculate in writing.

  3. Check for patient safety issues

    If anyone is at risk, deal with that first. A media response never comes before patient safety.

  4. Issue a holding statement

    Short, factual and kind. It buys time to investigate without appearing to hide.

  5. Brief the whole team

    Reception, clinicians and anyone who answers the phone or social media. Give them a script.

  6. Tell the people who need to know

    Your ICB or commissioner for NHS services, your defence organisation or indemnifier, and the data protection lead if personal data is involved.

Speed matters, but accuracy matters more. "We are looking into this urgently and will update" is better than a full answer that turns out to be wrong.

Holding statements for common situations

Example holding statements for a fictional practice; adapt them with your defence organisation if a complaint or claim is involved
SituationExample holding statement
Complaint shared publiclyWe are aware of concerns raised online. We take every concern seriously and would welcome the opportunity to discuss it directly. Anyone with a concern can contact our practice manager on our main number or by email.
Long phone queuesWe know some patients have found it hard to get through recently, and we are sorry. We are adding staff at our busiest times and patients can also contact us online during opening hours.
Closed list or reduced servicesWe have had to make a difficult decision about our capacity. Existing patients are not affected. We have written to patients with details and our team can answer questions.
Data incidentWe are investigating an incident involving patient information and have taken immediate steps to contain it. We are contacting anyone affected directly and have notified the appropriate authorities.
Inspection reportWe accept the findings and have an improvement plan under way. Patients can continue to use our services as normal, and we will share progress.

What you cannot say

This is where practices most often make things worse. A patient may have told a journalist everything about their care, posted their records online or named the doctor involved. The practice still cannot respond with details of that patient's care. Data concerning health is special category data under UK GDPR, protected unless a specific condition applies[5], and serious breaches can attract fines of up to £17.5 million or 4% of worldwide turnover[6].

Professional duties go further. GDC guidance quotes standard 4.2.3: dental professionals must not post any information or comments about patients on social networking or blogging sites[1]. Health and care organisations in England follow the eight Caldicott Principles to keep confidential information protected[2]. Other regulators take the same line for doctors, nurses and pharmacists.

  • Do not confirm or deny that the person is a patient.
  • Do not correct their account with clinical facts, however unfair it feels.
  • Do not reply to reviews or posts with details of an appointment.
  • Do talk about your processes: how complaints are handled, how appointments work, what has changed.
  • Do offer to discuss the matter directly with the person through your complaints procedure.

Briefing the team

Staff will be asked about the story by patients at the desk and on the phone, by friends and on their own social media. Give them a short script and the reassurance that they do not have to answer questions.

Reception script: "I understand you have seen something about the practice. I am not able to discuss it, but our practice manager is happy to talk to anyone with a concern. Can I take your details for a call back?" For callers who are angry: "I can hear this has upset you. I will pass your concerns to the practice manager today."

  • Ask staff not to post, like or comment on anything about the story, including in private groups.
  • Remind them that a patient being in the news does not change confidentiality.
  • Tell them who to pass journalists to, and that "no comment" should be replaced by "I will pass you to our spokesperson".
  • Check in with the people named or involved. Media attention is stressful, and support should be visible.

Talking to the journalist

  • Ask for the deadline, the angle and what they already have. Most local reporters want a fair quote, not a fight.
  • Reply in writing where you can, so your words are not paraphrased.
  • Lead with care and action: what you are doing, how people can raise concerns, what has improved.
  • Use facts about your service that are already public, such as your inspection rating or opening hours, if they help.
  • Never go off the record, and never criticise the patient.

76.7%

of patients rated their GP practice as good overall in the 2026 GP Patient Survey[7]

Context helps when it is relevant. Most patients rate their own practice well: 76.7% rated their GP practice as good overall in 2026[7]. You cannot use that to dismiss a complaint, but you can say that most patients have a good experience while acknowledging that this one did not.

Reviews and social media during the storm

Expect a burst of reviews, some from people who have never been patients. Respond to each with the same short, polite message inviting direct contact, and do not argue. Fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews are a banned practice under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024[8]; if a platform hosts reviews that appear coordinated or fake, report them through the platform's process rather than replying in public.

After the story moves on

  1. Run a short debrief within two weeks: what happened, what worked, what you would change.
  2. Close the loop with the person who complained, through the complaints procedure.
  3. Make the changes you promised and tell patients about them in a newsletter or on your website.
  4. Update your crisis plan: spokesperson, deputy, holding statement templates and contact list.
  5. Watch call volumes and reviews for a month, and thank the team.

Example: a phone queue story

Example: Larkfield Surgery (fictional) was the subject of a local news article after a patient posted a video of a long phone queue. The practice manager issued a holding statement within an hour, briefed reception with a script and asked the patient, through the complaints route, to get in touch. A week later the practice published a short update explaining its new call-back option and extra morning staff. The follow-up story was about the changes, and the original post was largely forgotten.

Frequently asked questions

Can we correct a patient's false account in the press?

Not with details of their care. You can describe your processes and invite them to discuss it directly. Patient information remains confidential even when the patient has gone public[2][5].

Should we say "no comment"?

Avoid it. A short holding statement that shows care and action is better, and it buys time to investigate.

Who should be our spokesperson?

Usually the practice manager or a partner who can speak calmly and knows the facts. Name a deputy and tell the team who it is.

What if staff are named on social media?

Support them, ask them not to respond, and report abusive posts to the platform. Consider whether the police need to be involved if there are threats.

References

  1. General Dental Council (2025). Guidance on using social media (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2026). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2025). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2025: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 83: General conditions for imposing administrative fines (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews: guidance on the banned practice (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo