Private clinic growth

Refund requests from unhappy patients: what to do

How private clinics should assess refund requests from unhappy patients: legal rights, a decision table, goodwill gestures, chargebacks and scripts.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why refund requests deserve a process
  2. The legal frame in plain English
  3. First, sort the request
  4. A decision table
  5. Goodwill gestures without admitting fault
  6. Chargebacks and card claims
  7. When it is a complaint, not just a refund
  8. Fix the causes
  9. Training the front desk
  10. Insured patients and partial payments
  11. Keep a clean record
  12. Writing the decision letter
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Patients have statutory remedies when a service falls short: repeat performance first, then a price reduction that can be the full price[1][2].
  • A refund under the price reduction right must be paid within 14 days, by the same payment method and without a fee[2].
  • Patients who paid by credit card for an item priced between £100 and £30,000 may also claim against the card provider[3].
  • Separate clinical concerns from service complaints; the first goes to a clinician, the second can often be settled at the desk.

Why refund requests deserve a process

Private patients usually feel they get value. 86% of self-pay patients said their private care was value for money[4], and satisfaction with private dental care was 93.5%, against 89.9% for NHS dental care[5]. Expectations are high, which means a disappointing appointment, a result patients do not like or a confusing bill can quickly become a refund request. Handled well, most requests end with a satisfied patient. Handled badly, they end with a chargeback, a complaint and a public review.

Satisfaction with recent dental care in England, 2026
Satisfaction with recent dental care in England, 2026Comparison. NHS dental appointment: 89.9%; Private dental appointment: 93.5%.89.9%NHS dental appointmentNHS dental appointment: 89.9%93.5%Private dental appointmentPrivate dental appointment: 93.5%Satisfaction with recent dental care in England, 2026Comparison. NHS dental appointment: 89.9%; Private dental appointment: 93.5%.89.9%NHS dental appointmentNHS dental appointment: 89.9%93.5%Private dental appointmentPrivate dental appointment: 93.5%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
NHS dental appointment89.9%
Private dental appointment93.5%

Every contract to supply a service includes a term that it will be performed with reasonable care and skill. When a service does not meet that standard, or does not match what was agreed, the patient has remedies under the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

  • Repeat performance: the patient can ask you to perform the service again so far as needed to put it right, within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience and at your cost[1].
  • Price reduction: if repeat performance is impossible or you fail to do it properly, the patient can claim an appropriate price reduction, which can be the full price[2].
  • Refund mechanics: a refund under the price reduction right must be given within 14 days of agreeing the patient is entitled, using the same payment method unless the patient agrees otherwise, and with no fee[2].

In healthcare, repeat performance is often not appropriate: a patient who lost trust in a clinician may not want another session with them, and some treatments cannot be repeated. That pushes many cases towards a price reduction.

First, sort the request

  1. Listen and log

    Record the request in the patient's words, the date, the service and the amount paid. Thank them for raising it.

  2. Separate clinical from service issues

    A concern about diagnosis, treatment or outcome goes to a clinician or the clinical lead. A complaint about waiting, rudeness, billing or a cancelled slot can usually be handled by the manager.

  3. Check the facts

    Look at the booking, the terms the patient accepted, the clinical notes and any messages. Check what the website and staff said about the service.

  4. Decide and explain

    Use the decision table below. Explain the decision in writing, with reasons, and say how to escalate if the patient disagrees.

  5. Pay promptly

    If you agree a refund, pay it quickly and by the original payment method.

  6. Learn

    Record the cause and review requests each month.

A decision table

How to respond to common refund requests at a private clinic
SituationLikely responseNotes
Service not delivered (clinic cancelled, clinician absent)Full refund or rebook at the patient's choiceNo reason to keep any payment
Service delivered with a clear shortfall in care or skillOffer to put it right; if not possible or wanted, price reduction up to full priceClinical review first
Service delivered properly, outcome disappointingExplain; consider goodwill; refund not normally owedCheck expectations were set at consent
Treatment found unsuitable at assessmentCharge for the assessment, refund the treatment elementShould be in your terms
Billing error or unexpected feeCorrect and refund the difference straight awayFix the cause on the website or booking flow
Patient changed their mind after treatmentNo refund normally owedUnless within a cancellation right that still applies

Goodwill gestures without admitting fault

A partial refund, a free follow-up or a credit can resolve a dispute quickly where the clinic has done nothing legally wrong but the patient had a poor experience. Make clear it is a goodwill gesture, and keep the wording kind and simple. A goodwill payment does not have to be an admission of liability, but it should never be offered in exchange for silence.

  • Set limits on what reception and managers can offer without senior sign-off.
  • Record every goodwill gesture and the reason, to spot patterns.
  • Do not make a refund conditional on the patient changing or removing a review. Reviews tied to hidden incentives are a banned practice under consumer law[6].

Script: 'I'm sorry the appointment didn't feel worthwhile. The doctor has reviewed your notes and is confident the assessment was done properly, so we don't think a refund is owed, but we don't want you to leave unhappy. We'd like to offer you a free follow-up call with the doctor to go through your results again. Would that help?'

Chargebacks and card claims

Some patients go straight to their bank. A chargeback is a card scheme process: the patient's bank asks your payment provider to reverse the payment, and you get a short window to respond with evidence. Separately, where a patient paid by credit card for a single item with a cash price over £100 and up to £30,000, the card provider can be jointly liable for a breach of contract or misrepresentation by the clinic[3].

  1. Respond on time

    Check your payment provider's deadline and diarise it the day the notice arrives.

  2. Send evidence

    Booking confirmation, the terms the patient accepted, attendance records, consent form and any messages showing what was agreed.

  3. Keep it factual

    Describe what was booked, what was delivered and what you offered to put things right.

  4. Talk to the patient

    Many chargebacks start from frustration. A direct call can resolve it faster than the bank process.

When it is a complaint, not just a refund

If the patient raises concerns about clinical care or safety, treat it as a complaint under your complaints procedure, alongside any money question. Acknowledge it in writing, investigate, and give a full response. Explain how the patient can escalate if they are not satisfied, including any independent adjudication scheme your clinic belongs to. Do not let a refund discussion short-cut a proper clinical review.

Fix the causes

Most refund requests come from a small number of causes: expectations not set at consent, prices or fees that surprised the patient, clinician cancellations and long waits on the day. Review requests monthly and look for patterns.

  1. Rewrite consent and pre-treatment information for services that attract repeated disappointment.
  2. Audit price information against the booking flow and invoices.
  3. Track clinician cancellations and offer rebooking before patients ask.
  4. Train staff to recognise a request early and pass it to the right person.

Example: a fictional physiotherapy clinic in Sheffield found that most refund requests came from patients who had bought a six-session package and stopped after two. It introduced a review at session two, where the physiotherapist and patient agreed whether to continue, and offered refunds of unused sessions in its terms. Requests fell and the clinic stopped arguing about money it was going to refund anyway.

Training the front desk

The first person to hear a refund request is usually a receptionist, often on the phone and often with an upset patient. What they say in the first minute shapes the outcome. Train staff to acknowledge, not argue; to take details, not decide; and to give a clear time for a reply.

  • Never say 'we don't do refunds'. Say 'I'll make sure the right person looks at this.'
  • Ask what the patient wants: a refund, an apology, a rebooking or an explanation.
  • Write down the patient's own words and pass them on the same day.
  • Give a date by which the patient will hear back, and keep it.

Insured patients and partial payments

When an insurer paid part of the bill and the patient paid a shortfall or excess, work out who paid what before agreeing a refund. Refund each payer by the original method in proportion to what they paid, unless they agree otherwise. Tell the insurer if you refund a patient for a service the insurer also paid for, because it may expect a matching adjustment.

Keep a clean record

Record every request, the decision, the reasons, the amount and the date paid. Keep correspondence in the patient's record. A clear record protects you in a chargeback, a complaint or a regulator's inspection, and it gives you the data to spot recurring problems.

Writing the decision letter

Put the outcome in the first paragraph, the reasons in the second and the next steps in the third. Avoid legal language. If you refuse a refund, say what you considered and offer an alternative where you can. If you agree one, give the amount, the method and the date the patient should expect it. Keep a copy in the patient's record.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to refund a patient who is unhappy with the outcome?

Not automatically. If the service was performed with reasonable care and skill and matched what was agreed, a refund is not normally owed, though a goodwill gesture may help. If it fell short, the patient can seek repeat performance or a price reduction[1][2].

How quickly must a refund be paid?

A refund under the price reduction right must be given within 14 days of agreeing the patient is entitled, using the same payment method and without a fee[2].

Can a patient claim from their credit card company?

Yes, where they paid by credit card for an item with a cash price over £100 and up to £30,000, the card provider can share liability for a breach by the clinic[3].

Can we ask the patient to remove a review in return for a refund?

No. Reviews tied to hidden incentives are a banned practice[6], and the request is likely to make matters worse.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 55: right to repeat performance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 56: right to price reduction (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1974). Consumer Credit Act 1974, section 75: liability of creditor for breaches by supplier (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Independent Healthcare Providers Network (IHPN) (2026). Support for using private healthcare now found across the political spectrum, new report shows (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews: guidance on the banned practice (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo