Key takeaways
- Under the GMS regulations, essential services must be provided throughout core hours, 8am to 6.30pm on weekdays except Good Friday, Christmas Day and bank holidays[1][2].
- Online consultation tools must stay open throughout core hours too, so a lunchtime closure cannot switch them off[3].
- Staggered breaks are the simplest cover; buddy practices, PCN hubs and overflow services fill bigger gaps.
- Any planned closure in core hours needs cover agreed in advance and checked against your contract and ICB expectations.
- Patients notice: the share finding it easy to contact their practice has risen, and gaps stand out more[4].
What the contract actually requires
Some practices still close the phones for an hour at lunch, and a few close for a half day each week. Both habits come from a time when the practice was a single building with a small team, and both sit awkwardly with the current contract.
The GMS contract regulations define core hours as the period from 8am to 6.30pm on any day from Monday to Friday, except Good Friday, Christmas Day and bank holidays[2]. Regulation 17 then says that a contractor must provide the essential services it describes throughout the core hours, and must provide immediately necessary treatment in core hours for accidents and emergencies in its practice area[1]. Since 1 October 2025, practices in England have also had to keep online consultation systems available throughout core hours for routine appointments and admin requests[3].
None of this says every receptionist must be at the desk every minute. It does mean patients must be able to get help throughout core hours, and that any arrangement which leaves the practice unreachable needs a clear alternative that has been agreed in advance. PMS and APMS contracts have their own wording, so check yours, and ask your ICB how it views lunchtime and half-day arrangements before you change anything.
Why lunchtime closures cause problems
- Patients who work often can only ring at lunch. A closure at exactly that time shuts out the people with least flexibility.
- Calls build up. A one-hour closure creates a second rush at 2pm, which is often harder to staff than the first.
- Urgent calls go elsewhere. Patients who cannot get through may ring NHS 111 or go to an urgent treatment centre for something the practice could have handled.
- It contradicts the access model. NHS England's Modern General Practice Access approach expects patients to know on the day how their request will be handled[5]; a closed line at lunch makes that harder.
- It is visible. Patients and local councillors notice closed phones, and complaints often mention them.
Expectations have risen as access has improved. Government-cited ONS data showed 75.1% of patients found contacting their GP practice easy in December 2025, up from 61% in July 2024[4]. When most of the system is easier to reach, a lunchtime gap stands out.
Source: GOV.UK (DHSC and NHS England), 2025[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| July 2024 | 61% |
| December 2025 | 75.1% |
Cover options compared
| Option | Works best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Staggered breaks | Any practice with three or more reception staff | Needs a written rota that survives sickness and leave |
| Remote log-in | Staff who can take calls from a quiet back office or home | Confidentiality and supervision rules still apply |
| Buddy practice | Small practices in the same PCN on the same phone system | Clear rules on what the buddy can and cannot do for your patients |
| PCN hub or shared team | PCNs with a shared telephony platform | Data sharing agreements and access to each practice's record |
| Overflow bureau | Peaks and short closures, such as training | Scripts, escalation rules and a processor contract |
| Voicemail only | Not recommended in core hours | Callers in urgent need may not leave a message |
A combination usually works best: staggered breaks every day, plus a buddy, hub or overflow arrangement for training afternoons and staff shortages. The important thing is that whichever option is in use, patients with an urgent problem reach someone who can act.
Building a lunchtime rota that holds
Check the call data
Pull calls offered by half hour between 11.30 and 14.30 for eight normal weeks. Lunchtime demand is often lower than the morning but rarely zero.
Set a minimum
Decide how many people must be logged in to the phones at every point between 12.00 and 14.00. For most practices, one is the absolute minimum and two is safer.
Stagger breaks in fixed slots
Assign breaks at 12.00, 12.30, 13.00 and 13.30, for example, so they never overlap more than the minimum allows.
Name the cover
For each day, name who covers if someone is off. Write it on the rota rather than leaving it to the day.
Protect the clinical route
Make sure a duty clinician can be reached for urgent calls throughout lunch, even if routine calls wait a little longer.
Review monthly
Check lunchtime waits and abandoned calls in your telephony reports and adjust the minimum if needed.
What patients should hear at lunchtime
If waits are a little longer over lunch because fewer people are on the phones, say so honestly rather than pretending nothing has changed. A short lunchtime queue message sets expectations and gives callers a choice.
“Thank you for calling Elm Road Surgery. Our team is smaller over lunch, so waits may be a little longer. If this is an emergency, hang up and dial 999. You can send us a request online now through our website or the NHS App. You are number 3 in the queue. To be called back, press 1.”
Schedule the message to start and stop automatically, for example from 12.00 to 14.00, and make sure the normal message returns afterwards. Check the website's opening hours page at the same time: some practice websites still show “closed 1pm to 2pm” years after the phones stopped closing, which puts patients off ringing at a time that is now often quieter than the morning.
If you have a buddy or hub arrangement, tell patients in plain words who might answer: “At busy times, your call may be answered by our partner practice, who will pass your message to us.” An unfamiliar voice is far less unsettling when the website and the queue message have already explained it.
Half-day closures and training afternoons
Regular half-day closures, such as every Wednesday afternoon, are much harder to justify than they once were. If your practice still has one, find out how it is covered, whether the arrangement was agreed with the commissioner, and whether patients are told clearly how to get help. If the answer to any of those is unclear, fix it before someone complains.
Protected learning time and training afternoons are a different case. Many areas have local schemes where an out-of-hours provider or another practice covers urgent calls while staff train. Use those schemes where they exist, give patients notice on the website and in the queue message, and record a closure message that explains who is answering and how to get urgent help.
“Elm Road Surgery is closed this afternoon for staff training. Our phones are being answered by our local cover service, who can help with anything urgent. In an emergency, dial 999. For routine requests, you can use our website or the NHS App, and we'll respond when we reopen at 8am tomorrow.”
Example: a small practice's lunchtime fix
Example: a fictional 5,500-patient practice with three receptionists closed its phones from 13.00 to 14.00 and had a regular rush at 14.00 that ran until 15.00. The practice manager moved to staggered breaks with one person always logged in, and agreed with a neighbouring practice on the same telephony platform that each would take the other's overflow calls for short gaps, using a shared script that passes patient matters back to the registered practice.
In this example, the 14.00 rush shrank because calls were spread across lunch, and the practice no longer had a period in core hours when nobody could be reached. The cost was a more careful rota, not extra staff.
Checklist
- Read your contract's core hours wording and ask your ICB how it treats lunchtime and half-day arrangements.
- Keep the online consultation route open throughout core hours.
- Set a minimum number of people logged in over lunch and write the break rota around it.
- Make sure a duty clinician is reachable for urgent calls all day.
- Arrange cover for training afternoons and staff shortages before you need it.
- Record closure messages that explain who is answering and how to get urgent help.
- Review lunchtime waits monthly in your call reports.
An AI Employee such as Ava can help at quieter times by answering practice questions in approved wording and passing patient matters to reception, but it does not replace the clinical cover the contract expects. For the wider choice of cover models, see overflow call answering options and outsourced medical receptionists, and for the message after 6.30pm, out-of-hours messages.
Frequently asked questions
Can a GP surgery close for lunch?
Staff can take breaks, but patients must still be able to get services throughout core hours. Closing the phones with no alternative is risky; staggered breaks or agreed cover arrangements are the usual answer. Check your contract and your ICB's expectations.
Are half-day closures allowed?
A regular half-day closure in core hours needs cover agreed in advance and clear information for patients. Many commissioners now challenge them, so check your arrangements with your ICB.
Can our online form close at lunchtime?
No. In England, online consultation tools must stay open throughout core hours for routine appointments and admin requests.
Who should answer urgent calls during a training afternoon?
Use your local cover scheme if there is one, such as an out-of-hours provider or a buddy practice. Patients should hear clearly who is answering and how to get urgent help.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, regulation 17 (essential services) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015, regulation 3 (interpretation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2025). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (DHSC and NHS England) (2025). Better access to GPs with same-day appointments for urgent care (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS England and DHSC (2023). Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care (opens in a new tab) ↑