Phones call handling

Designing a phone menu patients can actually use

How to design a GP, dental or clinic phone menu: emergency message first, three or four plain options, the right order, and testing with real callers.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a phone menu is for
  2. Six rules for a usable menu
  3. Before and after: a worked example
  4. Step-by-step design process
  5. Menu layouts for different settings
  6. Design for the callers who struggle most
  7. Who is frustrated by the current system
  8. Menus outside normal hours
  9. What to watch after go-live
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Put the 999 line first, then no more than four options, worded as the caller would say them.
  • Every option you add is a chance to give up: 4.6% of NHS 111 callers hung up after its call-steering menu in July 2026[1].
  • Order options by how often they are chosen, and keep a route to a person for anyone who is unsure.
  • Design for older callers and people who find phones hard, not only for confident users[2].
  • Test the menu with real patients and re-check option usage in your call data after a month.

What a phone menu is for

A phone menu, or IVR, has one job: get each caller to the person or team who can help them, with as little effort as possible. Cloud telephony makes it easy to add options, and that is where most practices go wrong. NHS England lists call routing among the features of good digital telephony, for example sending medicine queries to a pharmacy team that serves a whole PCN[3]. Routing helps when it saves a transfer; it hurts when callers spend a minute listening to options that do not apply to them.

Large call centres see the cost of menus clearly. In July 2026, 4.6% of calls to NHS 111 were abandoned after the call-steering menu[1]. NHS 111 handles very different calls from a GP surgery, but the lesson carries over: every second and every option before a caller reaches the right place is a moment when some people give up.

Six rules for a usable menu

  1. Emergency message first, once, in one sentence: “If this is a life-threatening emergency, hang up and dial 999.”
  2. No more than four options. If you need more, your menu is doing the job of your website.
  3. Describe the caller's need, not your department: “to order a repeat prescription” rather than “for the medicines management team”.
  4. Say the description before the number: “To order a repeat prescription, press 2,” not “Press 2 for repeat prescriptions.” People remember the last thing they hear.
  5. Put the most chosen option first, which in most GP practices is appointments or a new health problem.
  6. Always offer a route to a person, such as “For anything else, please hold,” so unsure callers are not trapped.

Avoid second-level menus wherever possible. If you need one, keep it to two options and make sure pressing nothing leads to a person rather than back to the start.

Before and after: a worked example

Example: a fictional surgery's original menu took 58 seconds to reach the last option.

  • Before: welcome message, flu clinic notice, a reminder about missed appointments, then seven options: appointments, test results, prescriptions, home visits, secretaries, practice manager, and “all other enquiries”.
  • After: welcome and 999 line, then four options: “If you're calling about a new health problem or an appointment, press 1. To order a repeat prescription or ask about medication, press 2. For test results or a letter, press 3. For anything else, including home visits, please hold.”

Home visits moved to the hold route because they are rare and need a person anyway. Secretaries and the practice manager were removed from the menu entirely: professionals and patients who need them are given a direct dial or an email, and reception can transfer. The flu notice moved to the website and a seasonal queue message. In this example, the new menu reaches its last option in about 25 seconds.

Step-by-step design process

  1. List why people call

    Ask reception to tally the reason for every call over two normal weeks, using five or six simple categories. If your phone system already records menu choices, use that too, but remember that callers often pick the wrong option.

  2. Group by who handles it

    Combine reasons that go to the same person or team. If appointments and new problems both go to the same reception queue, they should be one option.

  3. Write options in patients' words

    Use the phrases callers actually use on the phone: “my prescription”, “my results”, “I need to see someone”. Avoid internal names like “care navigation” or “e-consult”.

  4. Record and time it

    Record a draft, play it back and time it. If the full menu is longer than about 30 seconds after the greeting, cut options or words.

  5. Test with five real callers

    Ask patients at the desk to listen and tell you which number they would press for a given task. If two of five choose differently, reword.

  6. Go live and check after a month

    Use your call data to see which options are chosen, how many callers press nothing, and how often reception transfers calls between queues.

Example menu layouts; adapt wording to your own services.
SettingOption 1Option 2Option 3Hold route
GP surgeryNew health problem or appointmentRepeat prescription or medicationTest results or lettersAnything else
Dental practicePain, swelling or broken toothBook, change or cancelPayment or treatment planAnything else
Private clinicNew consultationExisting appointmentResults or aftercareAnything else

In a dental practice, pain calls go first because they are time-sensitive and often the reason for the call. In a private clinic, new enquiries go first because they are the calls the clinic most needs to answer quickly.

Design for the callers who struggle most

Menus are usually designed by confident phone users and then used by everyone. The people who find them hardest are often those who rely on the phone most: older patients, people with hearing loss or cognitive impairment, people whose first language is not English, and people without reliable internet.

The population is getting older. The number of people aged 65 and over rose in every UK nation in the year to mid-2025, including by 2.0% in England, and there were 285 people of pensionable age for every 1,000 people of working age[4]. Access difficulties are not spread evenly either: adults renting from a council were 46% more likely to report difficulty contacting their GP practice than outright homeowners[5].

  • Speak slowly and leave a short pause after each option. Many recorded menus are read too fast.
  • Do not rely on speech recognition alone. Offer keypad options for callers with accents or speech difficulties.
  • Allow callers to press an option before the menu finishes, so regular callers can move quickly.
  • Repeat the menu once if no option is chosen, then route to a person rather than disconnecting.
  • Check that text relay and Relay UK calls reach a person and are not lost in the menu.

Who is frustrated by the current system

Younger patients are not necessarily happier with phone access. In the 2024 British Social Attitudes survey, 65% of people under 65 were dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, compared with 52% of those over 65[2]. Working-age callers often ring in a short break, so a menu that wastes a minute matters more to them, while older callers may need more time on each option. Good menus serve both by being short and slow at the same time: few options, read clearly.

Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024British Social Attitudes survey
Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024Comparison. Under 65: 65%; 65 and over: 52%.65%Under 65Under 65: 65%52%65 and over65 and over: 52%Dissatisfied with making a GP appointment, by age, 2024Comparison. Under 65: 65%; 65 and over: 52%.65%Under 65Under 65: 65%52%65 and over65 and over: 52%

Source: Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund, 2024[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Under 6565%
65 and over52%

When the practice is closed, the menu should usually disappear. A caller at 7pm does not need to choose between prescriptions and results; they need to know whether to call NHS 111, dial 999 or wait until the morning. Replace the menu with a single closed message, and keep any option that genuinely works out of hours, such as a cancellation line that records a message, short and clearly labelled.

During lunchtime cover or training afternoons, the menu may need to change too. If prescriptions are not answered between 1pm and 2pm, remove that option for the hour rather than letting calls queue for a team that is not there. Most cloud systems can switch menus on a schedule; set it up once and check it after every bank holiday, when schedules are easy to get wrong.

Finally, keep a short emergency version of the menu ready for days when the clinical system is down or staff numbers are very low. One option for urgent problems and a hold route for everything else is enough, with a sentence explaining why the menu is shorter today.

What to watch after go-live

  • Share of calls choosing each option. An option chosen by very few callers is a candidate for removal.
  • Calls with no option chosen. A high share suggests the options do not match why people call.
  • Abandoned calls during the menu, compared with abandoned calls in the queue.
  • Transfers between teams. Frequent transfers mean callers are choosing the wrong option, usually because of wording.
  • Comments at the desk. Ask reception to note any remark about the menu for the first month.

Once the menu is right, check the messages around it. Our guides cover the greeting script, queue position messages and how to read abandoned call rates fairly.

Frequently asked questions

How many options should a GP phone menu have?

Three or four, plus a hold route to a person. More than that and callers forget the early options by the time they hear the last one.

Should we use speech recognition instead of keypad options?

Speech recognition can help, but always keep keypad options. Accents, background noise and speech difficulties make voice-only menus unreliable for some callers.

Should the menu include a separate line for healthcare professionals?

Usually not. Give professionals a direct number or a bypass line instead, so patients do not have to listen to an option that never applies to them.

How often should we change the menu?

Rarely. Callers learn the numbers, so change options only when your data shows a clear problem, and tell patients about the change on your website and in the queue message.

References

  1. NHS England (2026). Statistical Note: Integrated Urgent Care Aggregate Data Collection (IUC ADC) July 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund (2024). Public satisfaction with the NHS and social care in 2024: results from the British Social Attitudes survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. NHS England and DHSC (2023). Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2025). Population estimates for the UK, England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland: mid-2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Experiences of NHS healthcare services in England: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo