Key takeaways
- CNSGP covers clinical negligence in NHS general practice in England, but not non-clinical claims, regulatory matters or private work.
- Every dental professional must hold indemnity appropriate to their work before they practise, whether their own policy or an employer's.
- Employers' liability insurance is a separate legal requirement, with at least £5 million of cover.
- Most gaps appear at the edges: private work, new services, locums, data breaches and premises.
Why cover is more complicated than it looks
A practice faces claims from several directions: a patient alleging negligent treatment, a member of staff injured at work, a visitor who slips in the car park, a data breach, a fire that closes the building or a regulator investigating a clinician. Each risk is covered, if at all, by a different arrangement. Some are state schemes, some are membership of a medical or dental defence organisation, and some are commercial insurance policies. The task for a manager is to map every risk to the arrangement that covers it and to find the gaps before a claim finds them.
The map differs for GP surgeries, NHS and mixed dental practices and private clinics. The sections below take each in turn, then cover the non-clinical policies every practice needs.
A map of the main types of cover
| Risk | Usual arrangement | Who it protects | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clinical negligence in NHS general practice | Clinical Negligence Scheme for General Practice | GPs and practice staff for NHS primary medical services | Private and non-NHS work is excluded |
| Clinical negligence in dentistry and private clinics | Defence organisation membership or professional indemnity insurance | Individual clinicians and, where arranged, the practice | Scope of practice, run-off cover, vicarious liability |
| Regulatory and disciplinary matters | Defence organisation membership | The individual registrant | Not covered by state schemes |
| Injury or illness of employees | Employers' liability insurance | The employer | Legal minimum cover and certificate display |
| Injury to visitors and damage to their property | Public liability insurance | The business | Car parks, contractors, shared buildings |
| Building, equipment and stock | Property insurance | The owner or tenant | Lease terms on who insures what |
| Loss of income after an incident | Business interruption insurance | The business | Indemnity period and NHS contract terms |
| Data breach and cyber attack | Cyber insurance | The business | Response costs, exclusions and conditions on security |
GP practices: what CNSGP covers and what it leaves
Since 1 April 2019, NHS Resolution has operated a state indemnity scheme for general practice in England, providing comprehensive indemnity for all clinical negligence claims within its scope[1]. It covers GPs and staff working under an NHS GP contract for primary medical services under GMS, PMS and APMS contracts, including the triage of patients' requests, online requests and bookings[1].
The scheme does not cover non-clinical matters, advice or professional regulatory matters, and it does not cover non-NHS work, for which NHS Resolution advises obtaining cover from a defence organisation or other provider[1]. In practice that means GPs still need individual membership for GMC investigations, inquests, complaints support and private work such as insurance medicals, travel clinics or occupational health sessions. Managers should keep a list of every non-NHS service the practice provides and check how each is covered.
Dental practices: an individual legal duty
Dental professionals are required by law to have appropriate indemnity or insurance in place before they practise, and the cover must be appropriate to the work they do[2]. Relying on personal savings is not permitted. A professional covered by an employer's indemnity is acceptable, but they remain responsible for checking that the cover applies to all their tasks and workplaces[2]. The GDC is clear that employers' liability insurance is not the same as professional indemnity[2].
The register is large: 49,079 dentists and 86,562 dental care professionals in October 2026[3]. Each declares indemnity when registering or renewing, by 31 December for dentists and 31 July for dental care professionals, and a false declaration may be a fitness to practise matter[2]. Practice owners should check evidence of cover for every associate, hygienist, therapist and nurse, not just take it on trust.
- Fully or mainly NHS 38%
- Fully or mainly private 37%
- Mixed NHS and private 23%
Source: Care Quality Commission, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Fully or mainly NHS | 38% |
| Fully or mainly private | 37% |
| Mixed NHS and private | 23% |
Most dentists now work across NHS and private care in some form: 38% mainly in NHS care, 37% mainly in private care and 23% in a mixed model[4]. Cover must match the full scope, including implants, sedation, facial aesthetics and orthodontics, which many policies treat separately.
Private clinics: no state backstop
Private clinics sit outside the NHS state schemes, so every clinical service needs its own cover. Demand is rising: UK self-pay private admissions rose 7.7% year on year in early 2026 to their highest ever level[5]. New services such as weight management, menopause clinics or aesthetic treatments are often launched faster than the insurance schedule is updated, which is how gaps appear.
- Check that each clinician's cover names the specific treatments they provide, not just their profession.
- Confirm whether the clinic as an organisation has its own medical malpractice policy for vicarious liability.
- Ask how cover works for visiting consultants and practising privileges.
- Keep evidence of cover renewal dates in the credentialing file for every clinician.
Employers' liability, public liability and premises
Employers' liability insurance is compulsory for almost every practice that employs staff. Cover must be for at least £5 million from an authorised insurer, an employer can be fined £2,500 for every day without proper cover, and failing to display the certificate can bring a £1,000 fine[6]. The certificate can be shown at the workplace, on a website or on the staff intranet[6].
Public liability, buildings and contents, and business interruption are not legally required in the same way, but leases, landlords and lenders often require them. Read the lease for who insures the building, and check that business interruption cover lasts long enough to rebuild or relocate a clinical service, which can take many months.
Data and cyber risk
Patient data is special category data, and serious UK GDPR infringements can attract fines of up to £17.5 million or 4% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher[7]. A cyber policy usually helps with breach response, forensic investigation, notification and restoring systems. Many policies set conditions, such as multi-factor authentication and tested backups, and may refuse a claim if they are not met. Read the conditions with your IT provider and record that you meet them.
Locums, agency staff and new starters
Temporary clinicians are where assumptions about cover are most often wrong. A locum GP's NHS sessions fall within CNSGP, but their private work and regulatory support depend on their own membership. A locum dentist, hygienist or therapist needs their own indemnity or confirmation that the practice's arrangement covers them for the exact work they will do. Agency nurses in a private clinic may be covered by the agency, by the clinic, or by neither.
- Ask for evidence of cover at booking, not on the first morning.
- Check that the scope of cover matches the sessions booked, including any sedation, aesthetics or minor surgery.
- Record the expiry date and set a reminder if the engagement runs past it.
- Confirm in writing who holds vicarious liability for agency staff, and keep the agency contract on file.
- Include cover checks in the induction checklist so they cannot be skipped when a session is filled at short notice.
The same applies to new permanent staff. A clinician moving from an NHS trust may be used to Crown indemnity and not realise that primary care or private work needs a different arrangement. A short conversation at offer stage avoids an uncovered first month.
The gaps that cause most trouble
- Private sessions in an NHS GP practice that nobody told the defence organisation about.
- Locums and agency clinicians assumed to have cover that has lapsed or does not match the work.
- New treatments added to a clinic's menu without updating the policy schedule.
- Run-off cover not arranged when a clinician retires or leaves, or when a company changes insurer.
- Shared buildings where neither tenant has insured the common areas.
- Cyber policies with security conditions the practice does not actually meet.
An annual cover review
List every service and site
Include NHS, private, outreach, home visits and remote consultations. Note who delivers each one.
Map each to its cover
For every line, record the scheme or policy, the insured party, the limit and the renewal date.
Collect evidence from clinicians
Ask every clinician for current certificates once a year and file them with their credentialing records.
Ask the awkward questions
Ask insurers and defence organisations in writing about anything new or unusual, and keep the answers.
Report to partners or the board
Present the map, the gaps and the actions taken, and record the decision in the minutes.
Example: a mixed dental practice finds two gaps
Example: a fictional mixed practice with five dentists runs its first full cover review. One associate's policy does not include the facial aesthetics sessions she started last year, and the practice's own policy does not mention vicarious liability for the self-employed hygienist. Both are fixed before the next clinic. The review takes an afternoon and is repeated every January.
Frequently asked questions
Does CNSGP cover private work done in a GP practice?
No. CNSGP covers clinical negligence in NHS primary medical services. Private and other non-NHS work needs cover from a defence organisation or insurer.
Can a dental nurse rely on the practice's indemnity?
Yes, if the employer's cover applies to all the nurse's tasks and workplaces. The nurse remains responsible for confirming that, and employers' liability insurance does not count.
Is employers' liability insurance compulsory for GP practices?
Yes, for almost all employers. Cover must be at least £5 million and the certificate must be available to employees.
Do GPs still need a defence organisation if CNSGP exists?
Usually yes, for regulatory matters such as GMC investigations, inquests, complaints support and any private or non-NHS work.
References
NHS Resolution (2025). Clinical Negligence Scheme for General Practice (CNSGP) (opens in a new tab) ↑
General Dental Council (n.d.). Indemnity guidance (opens in a new tab) ↑
General Dental Council (2026). Registration report – October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Care Quality Commission (2026). State of Care 2025/26: dental (opens in a new tab) ↑
Private Healthcare Information Network (PHIN) (2026). Private healthcare market update: September 2026 United Kingdom (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (n.d.). Employers' liability insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 83: General conditions for imposing administrative fines (opens in a new tab) ↑