Key takeaways
- Two suppliers dominate GP clinical systems; the CMA found EMIS held 50-60% of UK primary care record supply[1].
- The biggest practical differences are in record sharing, task and document workflow, reporting and which third-party tools integrate.
- Switching is rare because it is complex, risky and costly[1]; most practices gain more by configuring their current system well.
- Every system must now support online consultation and messaging routes in core hours, so check how tools connect to yours[2].
A market of two main suppliers
Almost every GP practice in England runs one of two clinical systems: EMIS Web, from EMIS Health, or SystmOne, from TPP. When the Competition and Markets Authority reviewed UnitedHealth Group's purchase of EMIS in 2023, it provisionally found that EMIS's share of supply of primary care electronic patient record systems in the UK was 50-60%, with a similar share in each UK nation, and stable over five years[1]. TPP accounts for most of the rest in England. Other systems, such as Vision from Cegedim, have a larger presence in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland than in England.
Because practices rarely choose from scratch, the real questions for most managers are different: how does our system compare when we merge with a practice on the other one, when our PCN shares staff, or when we pick third-party tools? This guide focuses on those practical differences rather than declaring a winner.
50-60%
EMIS share of UK primary care electronic record supply, per the CMA's 2023 provisional findings[1]
Where the systems differ in practice
| Area | EMIS Web | SystmOne | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier | EMIS Health, owned by UnitedHealth Group (Optum) since the 2023 deal | TPP, a UK company based in Leeds | Roadmap, support model and local account management |
| Hosting | Hosted centrally by the supplier | Hosted centrally by the supplier | Resilience arrangements and downtime procedures |
| Record sharing | Sharing between organisations set up through agreements and national services | Shared database across many care settings, with sharing controlled by organisation and patient settings | Who can see what, and how consent to share is recorded |
| Other care settings | Products for community and other settings | Widely used in community health services as well as general practice | Which local services are on the same system as you |
| Patient app | Patient Access | Airmid and SystmOnline | How each links to the NHS App and what patients can do |
| Third-party tools | Partner programme and national interfaces | National interfaces and supplier-approved integrations | Whether the specific tool is live on your system, not just "compatible" |
Record sharing: the difference people notice
SystmOne is built around a shared database used by many organisations, including community nursing, health visiting and other services in many areas. When those services are on the same system, clinicians can see relevant parts of each other's records, subject to sharing settings and patient consent. That can make joined-up care easier, but it also makes sharing settings an important governance job: someone must understand what is shared in and out, and patients' preferences must be recorded correctly.
EMIS Web practices typically share records with other organisations through sharing agreements, local shared care records and national services such as GP Connect. The effect can be similar, but it is configured differently. In a merger between an EMIS practice and a SystmOne practice, this is often the hardest area to explain to staff, and the one most worth a session with each supplier.
Workflow: tasks, documents and messages
Day-to-day experience depends heavily on workflow: how incoming letters, test results, prescription requests and patient messages reach the right person. Both systems have task and document handling, and many practices add a separate document management tool. What matters is how your practice has configured it.
- Map where each type of incoming item lands: results, hospital letters, online consultations, patient messages, prescription requests.
- Check who can see each queue and how items are reassigned when someone is off.
- Look at how coding of letters is done and checked, and whether templates are shared across the PCN.
- Review how online consultation and messaging tools post back into the record.
Workload pressure makes this more important. Since October 2025 practices in England must keep online consultation systems open throughout core hours, 8am to 6.30pm, for routine appointments and admin requests[2]. In a BMA survey of more than 1,300 practices, 74% saw workload rise after the online access changes[3]. A clean workflow in the clinical system is one of the few things a practice fully controls.
Digital access is now universal
Whichever system you use, patients increasingly arrive through digital routes. By 2025/26, 100% of GP practices offered digital messaging and 81% provided online consultations, and 76% could be contacted through the NHS App, according to NHS England[4]. About 2.4 million online requests a month now start in the NHS App[4]. How well those routes connect to your clinical system shapes the workload of everyone who processes them.
Reporting and searches
Both systems let practices build searches and reports for recalls, contract indicators, audits and population health work. The tools look and feel different, and staff trained on one usually need time to become fluent in the other. Practices often share searches within a PCN or ICB area, so being on the same system as neighbours can save work. If you are considering a change, ask to see how your most-used searches would be rebuilt, not just a demonstration of the reporting screen.
Integrations and third-party tools
Many practices now use tools that sit alongside the clinical system: online consultation, messaging, telephony with patient lookup, document management, dictation and transcription, and newer AI tools. National interface standards let approved products read from or write to both principal systems, but support varies by product and by function. "Integrates with EMIS and SystmOne" can mean anything from a full two-way connection to a simple patient lookup.
- Ask the vendor which interfaces it uses and whether it is live with practices on your system today.
- Ask exactly what it reads from the record and what it writes back, and whether a person confirms anything written.
- Check who is responsible if a write-back is wrong or missing.
- Ask for a reference practice on the same system and speak to its manager.
Downtime and business continuity
Because both principal systems are hosted centrally, an outage affects many practices at once and is outside your control. What you control is how the practice keeps working. Check that your business continuity plan covers:
- How clinicians see the day's appointment list and essential patient information if the system is unavailable, for example through a regularly printed or exported list.
- How prescriptions, urgent referrals and results are handled during an outage, and how they are entered afterwards.
- Who contacts the supplier and the ICB service desk, and how staff are kept informed.
- What patients are told on the phone and website while systems are down.
Test the plan once a year with a short tabletop exercise. It is far easier to discover gaps on a quiet afternoon than during a real outage on a Monday morning.
Should you ever switch?
Switching is uncommon for good reasons. The CMA heard that switching supplier is considered a complex and risky process that can involve a large financial cost, reflected in very low levels of switching to or from EMIS over five years[1]. Practices usually consider it only in a merger, when most local services are on the other system, or after long-running service problems.
Write down the problem
Is it the system, how it is configured, or training? Many complaints about a system are fixable inside it.
Talk to your ICB
Clinical system changes are funded and managed with the ICB under the GP IT arrangements. Ask what is possible and when.
Visit practices on both systems
Watch real sessions: a reception morning, a GP clearing results, a manager running searches.
Count the transition cost
Training, lost appointments during migration, data checks, rebuilding templates and searches, and re-linking third-party tools.
Decide with the whole team
Clinicians, admin staff and the PCN should be part of the decision, because they carry the transition.
Example: a merger across two systems
Example: two fictional practices, one on EMIS Web and one on SystmOne, agreed to merge. The local community nursing service and most neighbouring practices used SystmOne, so the partners chose it for the merged practice. The EMIS practice's admin team visited a neighbouring SystmOne practice for two days, the practices rebuilt their most-used templates and searches before the switch, and the ICB arranged the migration on a long weekend. The biggest surprise was not clinical: it was the number of third-party tools that had to be reconnected and retested.
How to get more from the system you have
- Ask your supplier or ICB for a configuration review once a year.
- Keep a register of templates, protocols and searches with an owner for each.
- Train new staff with practice-specific guides, not just supplier manuals.
- Share good templates and searches across the PCN.
- Review third-party integrations annually and switch off any that no longer earn their place.
Most of the difference patients and staff feel comes from configuration and training, not from which badge is on the system.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, EMIS Web or SystmOne?
Neither is better for every practice. The right choice depends on which system local services use, how you share records, the tools you rely on and your team's experience. Configuration and training matter more than the brand.
How common is it for practices to switch?
Rare. The CMA found very low levels of switching to or from EMIS over five years, because switching is complex, risky and can be costly[1].
Who pays for a clinical system change?
GP clinical systems are funded and procured through the ICB under the GP IT arrangements. Talk to your ICB digital team before approaching suppliers.
Do online consultation tools work with both systems?
Most widely used tools work with both, but the depth of connection varies. Ask what they read and write back, and whether they are live with practices on your system[2].
References
Competition and Markets Authority (2023). Anticipated acquisition by UnitedHealth Group Incorporated of EMIS Group Plc: summary of provisional findings (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2025). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS England (via GOV.UK) (2026). NHS England annual report and accounts 2025 to 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑