Key takeaways
- Digital maturity is about capability, not gadgets: how well patients get in, systems connect, data is used, risks are managed and staff are skilled.
- Score five domains on four levels, with evidence, in a one-hour team workshop.
- Compare with national figures to spot where you are behind, but plan from your own patients' needs.
- Pick no more than three priorities for the next year, each with an owner and a measure.
- Repeat the assessment yearly so progress is visible.
What digital maturity means for a practice
A practice can own a lot of technology and still be digitally immature: three messaging tools that do not talk to each other, an online form that feeds a single inbox, a phone system nobody knows how to report on. Equally, a small practice with few tools can be mature if it uses each one well, measures what happens and keeps it secure.
A useful definition has five parts: how patients reach you, how your systems work together, how you use data to decide, how you protect services and information, and how confident your team is. A self-assessment across those five domains gives managers and partners a shared picture and a sensible list of priorities.
The five domains and four levels
| Domain | Level 1: basic | Level 2: developing | Level 3: established | Level 4: leading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Access | Phone and desk only, or online tools with no workflow | Online forms and messaging, partly joined up | Phone, web and app routes share one workflow and one set of answers | Routes planned from demand data and patient feedback |
| Systems | Separate tools, lots of re-keying | Some integration with the clinical system | Core tools integrated, few manual transfers | Integrations assured, monitored and reviewed |
| Data | Little reporting beyond contract returns | Monthly reports on calls and appointments | Demand and capacity reviewed weekly | Data drives rota, access and service changes |
| Security and resilience | No outage plan, inconsistent updates | Basic controls, plan on paper | Certified controls, tested backups and failover | Regular testing, supplier risk reviewed |
| Skills and governance | Few staff confident, no owner | Named leads, ad hoc training | Training plan, approved tool list, DPIAs in place | Staff improve processes themselves |
Running the self-assessment
Gather a small group
The practice manager, a clinician, a receptionist and whoever leads IT. Mixed roles give an honest picture.
Collect evidence first
Telephony reports, online request volumes, a list of systems and contracts, the outage plan and training records.
Score each domain
Agree a level for each domain based on evidence, not aspiration. Where opinions differ, score lower and note why.
Note the gaps
For each domain, write the one thing that would move you up a level.
Choose priorities
Pick up to three gaps for the next year, based on patient impact and risk.
Keep it to an hour. The value is in the conversation and the shortlist, not in a perfect score.
Questions for each domain
Access
- Can patients reach us by phone, web, app and in person, and do all routes lead to the same workflow?
- Do we know how many calls are abandoned at peak times, and how long online requests wait for a first response?
- Can patients who cannot use digital routes get the same service?
Systems
- How many times is the same information typed into different systems?
- Which tools connect to the clinical system, and which approved interface do they use?
- Do we have tools that overlap or are barely used?
Data
- Which reports do we look at every week, and what have we changed because of them?
- Can we see demand by hour and day across phone and online together?
- Do we track patient feedback alongside activity data?
Security and resilience
- Have we tested the outage plan in the last year?
- Do all cloud systems use multi-factor authentication?
- Do we hold Cyber Essentials, and have we reviewed our suppliers' security?
Skills and governance
- Does every tool have a named owner?
- Is there an approved list of tools, including AI tools, with DPIAs where needed?
- Do new staff get trained on each system they use?
How you compare nationally
National figures help you see whether a gap is unusual. By 2025/26 every GP practice in England offered digital messaging and 81% provided online consultations, and 76% of practices could be contacted through the NHS App[1]. In the 2026 GP Patient Survey, 30.8% of patients said their last contact attempt was online, up from 16.8% in 2024[2]. A practice that has no online route integrated with its workflow is now behind most of its peers.
AI is earlier in its adoption. In a 2025 Nuffield Trust and RCGP survey, 28% of GPs said they used AI tools in clinical practice, with use higher in England than in Scotland or Northern Ireland[3]. Security basics are patchy across small organisations generally: only 3% of UK businesses held Cyber Essentials in 2025[4].
Do not chase national averages for their own sake. A practice with an older, less connected population may rightly keep strong phone access at the centre while improving digital routes more slowly. The aim is to serve your own patients well.
Adapting it for dental practices and private clinics
The grid works outside general practice with a few changes of emphasis. Dental practices and private clinics usually choose and pay for their own systems, so the systems and governance domains carry more weight: there is no ICB providing core IT, and contract terms matter more. Access looks different too, because new patient enquiries, online booking and payments are often the routes that matter most commercially.
- Access: can a new patient find you, enquire, book an assessment and pay a deposit without a phone call, and can they still phone if they prefer?
- Systems: does the practice management system connect to imaging, payments, recalls and messaging, or are there exports and re-keying in between?
- Data: do you track enquiries converted to bookings, recall response and failed appointments by month?
- Security: who holds the admin passwords for each system, and could you recover if your only IT person left?
Traps to avoid when scoring
- Scoring the tools you own rather than how well they are used. A powerful system half set up is Level 1 or 2, not Level 4.
- Letting the most enthusiastic person score alone. Receptionists often see gaps that managers and clinicians miss.
- Confusing a plan with a result. An outage plan that has never been tested does not count as established resilience.
- Ignoring patients who do not use digital routes. A high access score should mean every group of patients can get in.
- Choosing too many priorities. Five half-finished projects leave the practice at the same level next year.
Write down the evidence for each score in a sentence or two. Next year, that note is what lets you see whether you really moved.
Turning scores into a plan
- For each priority, write the outcome you want in patient or staff terms, such as 'online admin requests get a first response the same working day'.
- Name an owner and a date.
- List the steps for the first 90 days.
- Choose one measure and take a baseline now.
- Check the budget and contracts implications before committing.
- Report progress at each partners' or management meeting.
Telephony is often a high-value priority. In NHS England trials, moving practices to high-quality digital telephony raised patients' ease of getting through by 30 percentage points[5]. Changes that remove re-keying and join routes together usually come next.
Example: one practice's results
Example (fictional): a 6,000-patient rural practice runs the assessment in a lunchtime meeting.
In this example the practice scores Level 3 for access, because its phone line and online form share one workflow, but Level 1 for data, because nobody looks at the telephony reports, and Level 1 for resilience, because its outage plan is three years old and has never been tested. It chooses three priorities: a weekly ten-minute review of phone and online demand, a tested failover for the phones and an approved tool list with owners. A year later it scores Level 2 or 3 in every domain and picks new priorities.
Keep it going
Repeat the assessment once a year, ideally at the same point in your planning cycle, and keep the previous scores alongside the new ones. Progress is motivating, and it makes the case for investment far easier. Share the results with the whole team: digital maturity depends on how everyone works, not just on the people who chose the systems.
It also helps to re-run a single domain whenever something significant changes: a new clinical system, a merger with another practice, a change of IT provider or a serious incident. A quick rescore of the affected domain, with the same small group and the same evidence rules, shows whether the change moved the practice forward or exposed a gap that needs to join next year's priorities.
Frequently asked questions
What is digital maturity in a practice?
How well a practice uses technology across patient access, connected systems, data, security and staff skills, rather than how many tools it owns.
How long does a digital maturity self-assessment take?
About an hour with a small mixed group, once the evidence has been collected: telephony and online reports, a systems list, the outage plan and training records.
How many priorities should we choose?
No more than three for the year, each with an owner, a measure and a 90-day plan.
Should we aim to be at the top level everywhere?
Not necessarily. Aim for the level that serves your patients and keeps services safe, and move up where the patient impact or risk reduction is greatest.
References
NHS England (via GOV.UK) (2026). NHS England annual report and accounts 2025 to 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑
Nuffield Trust (2025). How are GPs using AI? Insights from the front line (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) (2025). Cyber security breaches survey 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
NHS England and DHSC (2023). Delivery plan for recovering access to primary care (opens in a new tab) ↑