Seasonal operations

Dark evenings: late appointment no-shows

Do dark winter evenings raise late appointment no-shows? How to check your own data after the clocks go back, and timing and reminder changes that help.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The question practices ask every November
  2. The winter attendance picture
  3. Why darkness might matter
  4. When the light changes
  5. Check your own data
  6. Fixes that address timing
  7. Fixes that work whatever the cause
  8. What not to do
  9. Dental and private clinics
  10. Booking scripts for winter
  11. Measure and repeat
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • The clocks go back on the last Sunday in October (25 October 2026, 31 October 2027), and late afternoon appointments move into darkness overnight[1].
  • Missed appointments are a large winter problem: 1.3 million GP appointments were missed in England in January 2026 alone[2].
  • National data do not break non-attendance down by time of day, so check your own: DNA rate by slot time, month and patient group.
  • Offer daylight slots to patients who avoid travelling after dark, and phone or video for late slots where clinically suitable.
  • Reminders and easy cancellation work: the NHS App helped avoid an estimated 1.75 million missed appointments in 2025/26[3].

The question practices ask every November

Many practice managers notice the same thing each autumn: after the clocks go back, the last appointments of the day seem to go missing more often. Older patients say they do not like driving in the dark, parents struggle with school pick-up and early sunset, and icy pavements make the walk to the surgery less appealing. Is the effect real, and if so, what can be done about it?

The honest answer is that national statistics do not tell you. They count missed appointments by month, not by time of day or daylight. Your own appointment data can answer the question for your practice, and the fixes are cheap enough to test.

The winter attendance picture

Missed appointments are already high in winter. In January 2026, 1.3 million GP appointments in England were missed or unattended, 107,000 more than in January 2018[2]. Over the same period, demand rose: practices delivered 460 appointments per 1,000 patients in January 2026, against 389 in January 2018[2].

GP appointments missed or unattended in England in JanuaryJanuary 2018 figure is 107,000 below January 2026, as reported
GP appointments missed or unattended in England in JanuaryComparison. January 2018: 1.19 million; January 2026: 1.3 million.1.19 millionJanuary 2018January 2018: 1.19 million1.3 millionJanuary 2026January 2026: 1.3 millionGP appointments missed or unattended in England in JanuaryComparison. January 2018: 1.19 million; January 2026: 1.3 million.1.19 millionJanuary 2018January 2018: 1.19 million1.3 millionJanuary 2026January 2026: 1.3 million

Source: Wessex Local Medical Committees (from NHS appointments data), 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
January 20181.19 million
January 20261.3 million

Not all of that is about darkness. Winter illness, weather, travel and longer booking lead times all play a part. But each missed slot in a pressured month is a slot another patient needed, so even a small timing effect is worth finding.

Why darkness might matter

Before testing, it helps to be clear about the mechanisms, because each one suggests a different fix. These are hypotheses to check against your own patients, not established findings.

  • Driving: some older patients, and some with eye conditions, avoid driving after dark. A late slot that was easy in September becomes impossible in November.
  • Walking and public transport: dark, wet or icy pavements and less frequent evening buses deter patients without a car.
  • Family routines: early sunset compresses the time between school pick-up and evening routines, so parents cancel late slots more often.
  • Safety: some patients, particularly those living alone, feel less safe travelling in the dark.
  • Illness: winter bugs and fatigue lead to more last-minute cancellations at any time of day, which can look like a late-slot effect if late slots are booked further ahead.

The last point is why the analysis matters. If late slots are booked further in advance than morning ones, they will show more DNAs for that reason alone. Check lead times as well as times of day.

When the light changes

In the UK, the clocks go back one hour at 2am on the last Sunday in October and forward at 1am on the last Sunday in March[1]. In 2026 the clocks go back on 25 October, and in 2027 they go forward on 28 March and back on 31 October[1]. Overnight, a 5pm appointment that was in daylight becomes an appointment after dark for much of the country.

Use those dates as natural break points in your analysis. Comparing the four weeks before and after the change, in the same year, gives a cleaner test than comparing summer with winter, because most other factors are similar across a few weeks.

Check your own data

  1. Export the appointment book

    Pull at least a year of booked face-to-face appointments with date, start time, status (attended, did not attend, cancelled) and patient age band.

  2. Group by time band

    Group start times into bands, for example before 10am, 10am to 2pm, 2pm to 4pm, and 4pm onwards.

  3. Compare before and after

    Calculate the did-not-attend rate for each band in the four weeks before and after the clocks go back.

  4. Split by age

    Repeat for patients aged 75 and over, and for families with young children, who are often most affected.

  5. Check the spring change

    Repeat for the weeks around the clocks going forward in March. If late DNAs fall again, the light effect is likely real for your practice.

Example: a fictional practice finds its did-not-attend rate for face-to-face appointments after 4pm rises from about 4 in every 100 to about 7 in every 100 in the four weeks after the clocks go back, while morning rates barely change. The rise is largest among patients aged 75 and over. In the weeks after the clocks go forward, the late rate falls back.

If your data show no difference, the problem lies elsewhere, and the fixes below aimed at timing will not help much. Look instead at lead time, reminders and how easy it is to cancel.

Fixes that address timing

Example timing changes to test in winter (measure each one)
ChangeWho it helpsEffort
Offer daylight slots first to older and vulnerable patients from November to FebruaryPatients who avoid travelling after darkLow: a booking prompt
Use late slots for phone or video where clinically suitableWorking patients; anyone avoiding a dark journeyLow to medium
Move routine reviews for frail patients into late morningOlder patients, carersMedium: template change
Keep late face-to-face slots for working-age patients who request themCommutersLow
Review home visit timing for housebound patientsHousebound patients and carersLow

The aim is not to empty the late afternoon, but to match slots to the people who can use them. Evening sessions often suit working patients well. Primary care networks must provide enhanced access between 6.30pm and 8pm on weekdays and 9am to 5pm on Saturdays[4], and the BMA has reported concerns that some PCN evening and weekend sessions can be under-used[4]. Steering working-age patients who prefer evenings into those sessions, and older patients into daylight slots, can improve attendance in both.

Fixes that work whatever the cause

  • Send a reminder the day before and on the morning of the appointment, with a one-step way to cancel.
  • Encourage patients to manage appointments in the NHS App, which helped avoid an estimated 1.75 million missed appointments in 2025/26[3].
  • Keep booking lead times short in winter; the further ahead an appointment, the more likely plans change.
  • Fill late cancellations from a short-notice list of patients who can come at short notice; see cancellation lists.
  • Ask patients who miss an appointment, briefly and without blame, what got in the way; the answers tell you which fix to try.

Face-to-face appointments are still the majority. In the year to August 2026, 59.9% of GP appointments were delivered face to face[5]. Most of the remainder are phone and video, which are less affected by darkness and weather, so the mix you offer in winter is itself a lever.

What not to do

  1. Do not remove late face-to-face slots altogether; working patients and many families depend on them.
  2. Do not assume every older patient avoids the dark, or that younger patients do not. Ask.
  3. Do not penalise patients for a single missed winter appointment without finding out why; a policy that ignores ice and darkness will feel unfair.
  4. Do not change several things at once, or you will not know which one helped.

Dental and private clinics

Dental practices and private clinics often rely more heavily on late appointments, because their patients are more likely to be at work during the day. The same analysis applies: compare late-slot attendance before and after the clocks change, by age band. Private clinics can also look at enquiry-to-booking conversion for late slots, since some patients decline a late winter appointment at the enquiry stage and simply book elsewhere. Offering an early morning alternative, such as a 7.30am slot, can recover some of that demand.

Booking scripts for winter

Script: "We have a face-to-face appointment at 4.50pm on Thursday, or 11.20am on Friday. Some patients prefer daylight appointments in winter. Which would suit you better? If you are not able to come in, the doctor can also call you."

Offering the choice, rather than deciding for the patient, matters. Plenty of older patients are happy to come at 5pm, and plenty of younger ones would rather not. The script simply makes the option visible.

Measure and repeat

Change one or two things at a time, from the week the clocks go back, and compare the late-slot DNA rate with the same weeks last year. Keep the analysis for spring, when the clocks go forward, and decide which changes to keep for next winter. Related reading: back to school: vaccinations, forms and checks for the autumn run-up, sports seasons and physio demand for private clinic timing, and protected learning time closures for planning around afternoon closures.

Frequently asked questions

Do more patients miss appointments after the clocks go back?

National data do not show this by time of day, but many practices see it locally. Compare your did-not-attend rate by time band in the four weeks before and after the change.

When do the clocks go back?

At 2am on the last Sunday in October: 25 October 2026 and 31 October 2027[1].

How many GP appointments are missed in winter?

In January 2026, 1.3 million GP appointments in England were missed or unattended[2].

What reduces missed appointments in winter?

Reminders with easy cancellation, shorter booking lead times, offering daylight slots to patients who prefer them, phone or video for late slots where suitable, and refilling cancellations quickly.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). When do the clocks change? (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Wessex Local Medical Committees (from NHS appointments data) (2026). Appointment Overview January 2026 (national) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. NHS England (via GOV.UK) (2026). NHS England annual report and accounts 2025 to 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. British Medical Association (2024). Focus on use of enhanced access appointments (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo