Data protection

Verifying a caller's identity before sharing details

Proportionate identity checks for calls to a GP surgery, dental practice or clinic: tiers of checks, questions to ask, scripts and what to do if unsure.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why phone identity checks matter
  2. What the law allows you to ask
  3. Tiered checks
  4. Questions that work, and questions that do not
  5. Relatives, carers and representatives
  6. Scripts for when you are not sure
  7. Callers who need a different approach
  8. Emails and online messages
  9. Example: the new mobile number
  10. Training and checking that it works
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Match the check to what the caller wants: general information needs none, results and changes to contact details need the most.
  • Ask callers to tell you their details; never read details out for them to confirm.
  • Name and date of birth alone are weak, because both are easy to find; add a detail only the patient is likely to know, or call back on the number on the record.
  • When in doubt, offer a safe alternative rather than refusing outright: a call back, the NHS App or an appointment.

Why phone identity checks matter

The phone is still the main way many patients reach their practice. In the 2026 GP Patient Survey, 56.9% of patients said it was easy to contact their GP practice by phone, up from 49.7% in 2024[1]. Every one of those calls is a moment when someone could be given information about another person: an ex-partner looking for an address, a relative fishing for a diagnosis, or a fraudster gathering details for a later attack.

Patients who found it easy to contact their GP practice by phoneGP Patient Survey, England
Patients who found it easy to contact their GP practice by phoneLine chart. 2024: 49.7%; 2025: 52.9%; 2026: 56.9%.47.5%50%52.5%55%57.5%2024202520262024: 49.7%2025: 52.9%2026: 56.9%56.9%49.7%Patients who found it easy to contact their GP practice by phoneLine chart. 2024: 49.7%; 2025: 52.9%; 2026: 56.9%.47.5%50%52.5%55%57.5%2024202520262024: 49.7%2025: 52.9%2026: 56.9%56.9%49.7%

Source: Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England), 2026[1]

Show the data
PeriodValue
202449.7%
202552.9%
202656.9%

Impersonation is common enough in other sectors to take seriously: among UK businesses that identified a cyber breach or attack in 2025, 34% had experienced impersonation of the organisation or its staff[2]. In health, the stakes are higher, because the information is special category data[3] and a disclosure to the wrong person can put a patient at risk. Obtaining personal data from a practice by deception can be a criminal offence for the caller[4], but the practice still has to prevent it happening.

What the law allows you to ask

UK GDPR expects you to be satisfied about who you are dealing with. Where a controller has reasonable doubts about the identity of a person making a request, it may ask for additional information necessary to confirm their identity, and may delay dealing with the request until identity is confirmed[5]. The key word is necessary: ask for enough to be confident, not for everything you can think of.

Proportionate means two things: strong enough checks to stop the wrong person, and light enough checks that genuine patients, including those who are anxious, elderly or speak little English, can still get help.

Tiered checks

A tiered approach to phone identity checks. Write your own version into the practice policy.
What the caller wantsExampleCheck
General informationOpening hours, how to order a prescriptionNone
Book, change or cancel their own appointmentMoving a check-upFull name, date of birth and first line of address, given by the caller
Information from their recordWhether a result is back, what a letter saidAs above plus one more detail, or call back on the number on the record
Change contact detailsNew mobile number or addressAs above, and confirm by a call back to the old number, a letter or in person
Information about someone elseA relative asking about a parentRecorded consent or proxy access; otherwise take a message
Sensitive or high-risk informationSexual health, safeguarding, mental healthCall back on the number on the record, or ask the patient to attend or use online access

Changes to contact details deserve particular care, because they are how a determined person diverts future texts and letters. A request to change a mobile number, followed shortly by a request for results, is a pattern worth pausing on.

Questions that work, and questions that do not

  • Ask open questions: ‘Can you tell me your address?’ rather than ‘Is it still 14 Mill Road?’
  • Never read out a date of birth, address or phone number for the caller to agree with.
  • Choose extra questions the patient knows and others are unlikely to: the name of the medication they collect, the date of their last appointment, or the name of their usual clinician.
  • Avoid questions whose answers are on social media or in public records, such as mother's maiden name.
  • If the caller hesitates or guesses, do not prompt them. Move to a call back.
  • Record in the notes what was checked and what was disclosed.

Relatives, carers and representatives

Many calls come from someone other than the patient: a parent, an adult child, a carer, a care home. The Caldicott Principles cover both sides of this: access to confidential information should be on a strict need-to-know basis, and the duty to share information for individual care is as important as the duty to protect confidentiality[6]. A carer who needs to know when a repeat prescription is ready has a legitimate need; a sibling asking what a patient's appointment was about usually does not.

  1. Check for recorded consent

    Look for a note on the record that the patient agrees to this person being given information, and what kind.

  2. Check for proxy access or legal authority

    Proxy access, a lasting power of attorney for health and welfare, or parental responsibility for a young child may allow disclosure, within limits.

  3. Verify the caller too

    Ask for their name and relationship and check it matches the record.

  4. If nothing is recorded, take a message

    Offer to pass a message to the clinician or ask the patient to call. Do not confirm whether the person is a patient.

Scripts for when you are not sure

Refusing to help can feel rude, and staff often give in to avoid conflict. A clear script lets them stay polite and safe.

  • ‘To keep your information safe, I'm going to call you back on the number we hold for you. It'll be within the next few minutes.’
  • ‘I'm not able to share that over the phone, but you can see it in the NHS App, or I can book you a call with the clinician.’
  • ‘I can't confirm whether someone is registered with us, but I'm happy to take a message.’
  • ‘I understand this is frustrating. These checks are there to protect you, and they're the same for everyone.’

General questions need none of this. An AI employee such as Ava can answer opening hours, explain how to order prescriptions and pass anything patient-specific to reception, where the identity checks happen.

Callers who need a different approach

Identity checks must not become a barrier for patients who already find phoning hard. A deaf patient calling through a text relay service, a patient using an interpreter, a person with a learning disability or a patient in distress may struggle with quick-fire security questions. Adjust the method, not the standard.

  • Relay calls: the relay assistant is passing on the patient's words; run the same checks, allowing extra time.
  • Interpreted calls: put questions to the patient through the interpreter, and avoid sharing more with the interpreter than the call needs.
  • Patients with a learning disability or memory problems: use details recorded as reasonable adjustments, such as a named contact or a preferred call-back arrangement.
  • Distressed callers: if there is any sign of urgent risk, safety comes first; signpost to 999 or NHS 111 and alert the duty clinician.
  • Record any agreed adjustment on the record so every member of staff uses it.

Emails and online messages

The same principles apply to written contact. An email from an address you have not seen before, asking for results or for a change of details, is no more trustworthy than an unknown voice. Reply through the channel you already hold for the patient, such as the email or mobile on the record or the practice's online messaging, rather than to the new address. Online consultation and NHS App messages come through authenticated accounts, which is one reason to steer patient-specific questions towards them.

Example: the new mobile number

Example: a caller to Greenhill Surgery, a fictional practice, gives a patient's name, date of birth and address correctly and asks to update her mobile number. Ten minutes later the same voice calls back asking whether her pregnancy test result is in. The receptionist notices the pattern, says she will call back on the patient's previous number, and reaches the patient, who has not changed her number and has not called. The practice reverses the change, logs the incident and adds an alert to the record.

Example: the manager adds a rule that contact detail changes made by phone are confirmed by a text to the old number before taking effect, and uses the case in the next team training session.

Training and checking that it works

Run short role plays in team meetings using realistic calls: the impatient caller, the worried relative, the person who knows a lot but not everything. Spot-check notes each month to see whether checks were recorded. When an incident happens, share it, without blame, so everyone learns from it. These checks also link to information governance responsibilities, data protection training, the safeguards around AI tools, and suppliers that handle calls from abroad.

Frequently asked questions

Is name and date of birth enough to identify a caller?

Only for low-risk tasks. Both are easy to find, so add another detail the patient is likely to know, or call back on the number on the record, before sharing information from the record.

Can we refuse to give results over the phone?

Yes, where you have reasonable doubts about identity you can ask for more information or delay until identity is confirmed[5]. Offer an alternative, such as a call back or the NHS App.

Can we talk to a patient's husband or wife?

Only if the patient has agreed and it is recorded, or there is another lawful basis. Otherwise take a message.

Should we record which checks were done?

Yes. A short note of what was checked and what was disclosed protects the patient and the member of staff.

References

  1. Ipsos (GP Patient Survey provider for NHS England) (2026). 2026 GP Patient Survey results released (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) (2025). Cyber security breaches survey 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2018). Data Protection Act 2018, section 170: Unlawful obtaining etc of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 12: Transparent information, communication and modalities (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2020). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo