Phones call handling

Using call recordings for coaching, fairly

How reception leads in GP, dental and private practices can use call recordings for fair coaching: telling staff, choosing calls, scoring and feedback.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why recordings help, and why they can backfire
  2. The data protection basics
  3. Telling staff before you start
  4. Choosing which calls to review
  5. A short scoring framework
  6. Running a feedback session
  7. Example: coaching a difficult call
  8. Small teams, part-time staff and remote reception
  9. Patterns, not individuals
  10. Things to avoid
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Tell staff clearly that recordings may be used for coaching, how calls are chosen and who listens, before you start.
  • Choose calls by an agreed method, mostly random, so nobody feels targeted.
  • Score against a short, shared framework and start every session with what went well.
  • Keep coaching separate from disciplinary processes, and delete coaching clips on schedule.

Why recordings help, and why they can backfire

Reception teams work under heavy pressure. In a BMA survey of more than 1,300 GP practices, 74% saw workload rise after online access changes, 68% reported more stress and 55% reported negative effects on patient care[1]. Coaching that helps staff handle difficult calls more easily is valuable. Coaching that feels like surveillance adds to the stress it is meant to relieve.

GP practices reporting effects after online access changesBMA survey of more than 1,300 GP practices
GP practices reporting effects after online access changesBar chart. Workload rose: 74%; More stress: 68%; Negative effects on patient care: 55%.Workload roseWorkload rose: 74%74%More stressMore stress: 68%68%Negative effects on patient careNegative effects on patient care: 55%55%GP practices reporting effects after online access changesBar chart. Workload rose: 74%; More stress: 68%; Negative effects on patient care: 55%.Workload roseWorkload rose: 74%74%More stressMore stress: 68%68%Negative effects on patient careNegative effects on patient care: 55%55%

Source: British Medical Association, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Workload rose74%
More stress68%
Negative effects on patient care55%

Recordings make coaching specific. Instead of 'try to be clearer', a lead can play a twenty-second clip and say 'here is where the patient lost track; what could we say instead?' The same specificity is what makes recordings feel threatening if staff do not know the rules. The difference lies in how the scheme is set up.

The data protection basics

Recordings of practice calls contain personal data about staff as well as patients, and usually health information about patients, which is special category data[2]. UK GDPR requires that personal data is collected for specified purposes and not used in ways incompatible with them, that it is limited to what is necessary, and that it is kept for no longer than necessary[3]. For coaching, that means three things in practice.

  • Coaching must be one of the stated purposes for recording, in the staff privacy notice and the practice's recording policy, before you use recordings for it.
  • Listeners should hear only what they need: the clip for the coaching point, not a whole day's calls.
  • Clips saved for coaching need a retention period, usually short, and should be deleted when the session is done.

The Caldicott Principles, which health and care organisations in England follow to protect confidential information[4], point the same way: use the minimum necessary patient information and only where there is a clear purpose. If a coaching point can be made with a clip that contains no patient details, use that one.

Telling staff before you start

Write a one-page note for the team and talk it through at a team meeting. Cover what will happen, why, and what will not happen.

Staff note: 'Our phone system records calls. From next month, the reception lead will listen to a small number of calls each week to support coaching. Most calls are chosen at random; some are chosen because a patient or colleague has raised something. We will listen with you, start with what went well, and agree one thing to try. Clips used for coaching are deleted after the session. Recordings will not be used to monitor individual call times.'

Invite questions and change the scheme if staff raise fair concerns. Give new starters the same note in their induction. If coaching ever needs to move into a formal performance or disciplinary process, that should follow your HR policy, with its own notice and safeguards, not happen quietly through the coaching route.

Choosing which calls to review

The selection method is what makes the scheme feel fair. Agree it with the team and stick to it.

  1. Random sample: for example two calls per receptionist per month, chosen by date and time before anyone listens.
  2. Theme sample: calls of a particular type, such as prescription queries or the 8am peak, reviewed across the whole team.
  3. Triggered review: a call linked to a complaint, compliment or incident, where the staff member is told the call is being reviewed and why.
  4. Self-nominated: staff choose a call they found hard and would like help with. These are often the most productive sessions.

Include good calls deliberately. Hearing a colleague handle a distressed caller well is one of the best ways to learn, and it makes clear that coaching is not only about mistakes.

A short scoring framework

Six areas to score on a coached call
AreaWhat good looks like
OpeningPractice name and own name; calm, unhurried tone
ListeningLets the caller explain; reflects back the request
SafetySpots urgent cues; uses the agreed urgent wording; does not delay
ProcessFollows the agreed route for the request; asks only for the information needed
OutcomeClear next step, time and who will act
CloseChecks understanding and asks if anything else is needed

Use 'met', 'partly met' or 'not met' rather than numbers out of ten, and always write one specific example for each rating. A score with no example is hard to learn from.

Running a feedback session

  1. Listen together

    Play the clip with the staff member, not before them. Ask them how they think it went before giving your view.

  2. Start with strengths

    Name two specific things that went well, with the words they used.

  3. Pick one development point

    Only one. Explain why it matters for the patient, not for the statistics.

  4. Practise the alternative

    Agree the words to try next time and say them aloud. A short role-play makes the change stick.

  5. Note the agreed action

    Write one line in the coaching log: date, theme, strength, action. No patient details.

  6. Delete the clip

    Remove any saved copy after the session, in line with your retention rule.

Example: coaching a difficult call

Example: at a fictional practice, Kingsmead Surgery, a receptionist nominated a call in which a patient became angry about a prescription delay. Listening together, the lead pointed out two strengths: she kept her tone calm and apologised once, sincerely, without repeating it. The development point was that she explained the practice's process at length before acknowledging the patient's actual worry, which was running out of medication over the weekend.

They agreed a new opening line: 'I can hear you're worried about running out. Let me check what's happened and what we can do today.' They practised it twice. Three weeks later, the receptionist chose another call to review, and the lead heard the new line used naturally. The clip was deleted after each session, and the log recorded only the themes.

Small teams, part-time staff and remote reception

In a small dental practice or clinic with two or three people on the desk, random sampling can feel very personal, because everyone knows whose calls are whose. Lean more on self-nominated calls and theme reviews, and consider asking a manager from a partner practice to listen alongside you, so feedback does not always come from the same person.

Part-time and bank staff should be included on the same terms, with sessions arranged in their working hours rather than tacked on at the end of a shift. For staff working remotely, run the session on a video call with the clip shared from the phone system's portal, not downloaded to a personal device. The same rules apply wherever the receptionist sits: tell them, choose fairly, listen together, keep one action and delete the clip.

Leads need support too. If you are new to coaching, ask an experienced manager to sit in on your first few sessions and give you feedback on how you gave feedback.

Patterns, not individuals

Over a few months, the coaching log shows team-wide patterns: perhaps outcomes are often unclear, or urgent wording is used inconsistently. Those are usually system or training issues. Fix them with a team session, a script change or a process change, rather than more individual coaching.

Patterns from coaching also feed directly into your other work. Unclear outcomes link to first-contact resolution. Urgent wording problems link to the greeting and menu. Findings from mystery shopping can be checked against real calls in the same way. And if a patient asks for a recording of a call that was used in coaching, the access request process applies as normal.

Things to avoid

  • Listening to recordings without staff knowing coaching is a purpose of recording.
  • Choosing calls to build a case against one person.
  • Sharing clips in group chats or playing them in team meetings without the staff member's agreement.
  • Keeping coaching clips indefinitely on shared drives.
  • Measuring individuals on average call length, which pushes people to rush vulnerable callers.

Frequently asked questions

Do we need staff consent to use call recordings for coaching?

Consent is not usually the right basis in an employment setting, but staff must be told clearly that recordings may be used for coaching, how calls are chosen and how long clips are kept.

Can coaching recordings be used in a disciplinary case?

Only through your formal HR process, with its own notice and safeguards. Keep the coaching scheme separate so staff trust it.

How many calls should we review each month?

A small number per person, such as two, plus self-nominated calls. Regular short sessions are better than occasional long reviews.

References

  1. British Medical Association (2026). Pressures in general practice data analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). UK GDPR Article 5: Principles relating to processing of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (National Data Guardian) (2026). The Caldicott Principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo